Just now, Lukey said:

That was released in 2017, fat.

Oh didn't realise this is a 2016 list  Isn't it too late for that though?

5 minutes ago, Vxspertine said:

Oh didn't realise this is a 2016 list  Isn't it too late for that though?

Why would it be?

 

I only did 2015 last year  

 

I started in 2014, so I'm going to do 2016, then 2017 and then probably go back to 2010  

Just now, Lukey said:

Why would it be?

 

I only did 2015 last year  

 

I started in 2014, so I'm going to do 2016, then 2017 and then probably go back to 2010  

Oh nice didn't know that's how it goes, here for it  

The Jennifer Lopez Essentials Rate is concluded! The winner is "(What Is) Love?"

Hi, I would like to host an Avril Lavigne discography rate.

 

We haven't had such a rate for her in New ATRL, and the Avril Base is very active nowadays, so there's going to be interest in it. 

On 1/9/2018 at 11:56 PM, Ventitonic said:

Thank you.
Let us not spread narcolepsy to the entirety of the forum.

 

Mariah would not want us to suffer

Additionally, any 2019 ultimate rankings of Rainbow will be happening in Hell, as that rancid piece of trash does not deserve to be discussed!

 

So, This Was Pop 2017 - which edition should be held first?

 

1) The Big (Or Formerly Big) Guns: Reputation/Witness/Rainbow/Divide

2) Young and Old - Younger Now/Meaning of Life/Tell Me You Love Me/Beautiful Trauma

 

And ... who is hosting them?

18 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Reputation/Witness/Rainbow/Divide

I would like to do 'This Was Pop 2017' with Reputation/Witness/Rainbow/Beautiful Trauma/Double Dutchess

Edited January 14, 20188 yr by Carly

5 hours ago, Carly said:

I would like to do 'This Was Pop 2017' with Reputation/Witness/Rainbow/Beautiful Trauma/Double Dutchess

Well, the lineup is Taylor/Katy/Kesha/Ed, so take it or leave it!

6 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Well, the lineup is Taylor/Katy/Kesha/Ed, so take it or leave it!

This isn't a good idea imo, Ed is literally the most hated artist on ATRL, no sense in doing a rate with him vs 3 of ATRL faves; I can also see a lot of people skipping the rate because of him. We should use another pop girl album!

Edited January 15, 20188 yr by Mark Rih

8 hours ago, Mark Rih said:

This isn't a good idea imo, Ed is literally the most hated artist on ATRL, no sense in doing a rate with him vs 3 of ATRL faves; I can also see a lot of people skipping the rate because of him. We should use another pop girl album!

Agrih’d!

Quote

The Big (Or Formerly Big) Guns: Reputation/Witness/Rainbow/Divide

Those albums deserve each other xx

Hey, can I do a Tove Lo Discography Rate ? 

We're doing a base rate for Born to Die's sixth anniversary!

Check it out here

@Ace Reject we do not need permission for definitive rankings, correct?

On 1/15/2018 at 11:57 AM, Ace Reject said:

Well, the lineup is Taylor/Katy/Kesha/Ed, so take it or leave it!

I want to do this but not sure if I can commit to regular updates. Maybe @Carly can be my co-host.

 

I can accept the scores and tally it (and maybe the graphics too) and then you can do the reveal and overall moderarion of the thread.

 

I wanna do this because I'll make sure that Ed and Katy are rated fairly because Castle on the Hill and Witness are some of the bes tracks among all four albums.

21 hours ago, Clueless said:

@Ace Reject we do not need permission for definitive rankings, correct?

You do! What strikes your fancy?

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

You do! What strikes your fancy?

Still want to do the Sign o the Times one tbh! I know @conatus was thinking about doing it.

That ... would have worked last year toots. You missed your window of opportunity!

On 16.1.2018 at 6:45 PM, Moonlightbae said:

Hey, can I do a Tove Lo Discography Rate ? 

@Ace Reject

when  are some fun rates going to start?

On 1/17/2018 at 4:56 PM, Ace Reject said:

That ... would have worked last year toots. You missed your window of opportunity!

Omg u just broke my heart

Including Ed with Kesha, Katy and Taylor  That's moronic

Can I do the final part of the 21st Century OHW Rate yet?