sure

Did anyone ever agree to do The Supremes rate?

Somebody should do a Queens Disco or Singles Rate 

I would LOVE a Queen singles rate! There was one attempted in the old days, but it was never finished!

On 12/29/2017 at 8:13 PM, Ace Reject said:

It's come to my attention ... that Lily Allen has enough singles for a rate.

 

Who's taking it on?

I would sure participate.

On 2017-11-13 at 8:43 PM, prézli said:

 

He didn't even start his own rate.

 

 

Anyway, I don't think he will approve it yet because his rate is similar to this.

 

 

was this rate ever finished??

This might be a bad/overdone rate idea, but what about when pop girls snapped and made their ~dark~ album? Something like Rated R / Reputation / Blackout / Under My Skin / Prism

On 1/3/2018 at 5:37 PM, Dom said:

was this rate ever finished??

Thanks for bringing this back up - I was looking for it!

Terminado!

Thank you for the opportunity @Ace Reject!

@Ace Reject Can I do a tenth anniversary ranking for Mariah's E=MC2 or should we just do in the Mariah base? thanks 

On 26.01.2017 at 0:55 PM, mxtthewdelrey said:

I'd like to reserve the Charli XCX discography rate for after XCX3. I was born to host this rate  

Most of us will be dead by then, right now is the perfect time for this rate

@Ace Reject If no one snatches the Never Say Never ranking before the anniversary, I'll take it myself......along with janet. 25.

@Ace Reject since everyone is asking to do rankings, can we do one for Ray of Light for its 20th Anniversary next month? I’d be fine to run it I think.

 

Edit: Wait never mind I just remembered I’ll be overseas during then.  

Edited January 9, 20188 yr by nikkysan

18 hours ago, Slamless said:

@Ace Reject Can I do a tenth anniversary ranking for Mariah's E=MC2 or should we just do in the Mariah base? thanks 

That's an inessential album (I love it though!), so the base is appropriate.

 

@jdmc218, you'll have to fight with @eli's_rhythm over who gets to host The Ultimate janet. ranking.

3 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

That's an inessential album (I love it though!), so the base is appropriate.

 

@jdmc218, you'll have to fight with @eli's_rhythm over who gets to host The Ultimate janet. ranking.

E=MC2?! Inessential???

 

 

I don't think so.

Any Music Box rankings will also be happening in the MC Base, and not in the main forum.

 

Again, off the top of my head, the albums that will be ranked ultimately:

 

janet.

Never Say Never

Exile in Guyville

Ray of Light

Debut

Fearless

The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill

BEYONCE

(POSSIBLE Body Language)

 

And, if we can get enough supporters, either Daydream Nation, Surfer Rosa, or It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back.

On 07/01/2018 at 2:08 AM, Diarrhoea said:

This might be a bad/overdone rate idea, but what about when pop girls snapped and made their ~dark~ album? Something like Rated R / Reputation / Blackout / Under My Skin / Prism

@Ace Reject

Blackout's been used sis - and Reputation will be in the first edition of THIS WAS POP: 2017!

has anyone done a "daddies" rate? i have an idea for hot, male artists over 30 that are still relevant mostly (i.e. bruno, jt, usher, frank, drake, about 4 or 5 more guys)

 

got the idea from @Carly 's boys rate if he'd like to

Edited January 9, 20188 yr by montrealxo

5 hours ago, montrealxo said:

has anyone done a "daddies" rate? i have an idea for hot, male artists over 30 that are still relevant mostly (i.e. bruno, jt, usher, frank, drake, about 4 or 5 more guys)

 

got the idea from @Carly 's boys rate if he'd like to

After my last rate, I have in mind to do it, but I need to know if there's people interested in participating 

12 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Any Music Box rankings will also be happening in the MC Base, and not in the main forum.

Thank you.
Let us not spread narcolepsy to the entirety of the forum.

 

Mariah would not want us to suffer

Edited January 10, 20188 yr by Ventitonic

gayTRL needs a rate like this:

 

 

Is it okay if I start preparing The Flops of 2016? 

Albums I was thinking of:

Alicia Key's - Here

Charlie Puth - Nine Track Mind (I know it's gone gold, but it can be considered an underperformance considering the era and hype)

Foxes - All I Need

Usher - Hard II Love

JoJo - Mad Love

Sabrina Carpenter - Evolution

LeAnn Rimes - Remnants 

 

??

 

Not sure which are eligible for a rate and which four albums to use! 

4 minutes ago, Lukey said:

Is it okay if I start preparing The Flops of 2016? 

Albums I was thinking of:

Alicia Key's - Here

Charlie Puth - Nine Track Mind (I know it's gone gold, but it can be considered an underperformance considering the era and hype)

Foxes - All I Need

Usher - Hard II Love

JoJo - Mad Love

Sabrina Carpenter - Evolution

LeAnn Rimes - Remnants 

 

??

 

Not sure which are eligible for a rate and which four albums to use! 

Witness not even making it on this list? ohwow.gif she really lost

Just now, Vxspertine said:

Witness not even making it on this list? ohwow.gif she really lost

That was released in 2017, fat.