12 hours ago, supaspaz said:

So the Gaga/Taylor/Sabrina/Addison/Tate/Lorde pop girl showdown is out?

I feel like whatever the lineup is the result will be the same. Condragulations Abracadabra!

 

1 hour ago, Eeveelution said:

I feel like whatever the lineup is the result will be the same. Condragulations Abracadabra!

 

Well, hopefully taste will prevail instead.

Wouldn't be mad. Abra is indeed better than the entirety of 4 of those albums.

 

2 hours ago, Graves said:

Wouldn't be mad. Abra is indeed better than the entirety of 4 of those albums.

 

'4 of those albums', you knew not to try it with Addison.

 

1 hour ago, Eeveelution said:

'4 of those albums', you knew not to try it with Addison.

 

Well I certainly wasn't talking about Taylor, Sabrina, or Tate.

 

“House Tour” should win

On 10/9/2025 at 1:32 PM, Ace Reject said:

We'll make an ATRL friendlier but still acclaimed lineup.

 

BON IVER, Addy, Turnstile, Tyler, et cetera and so forth.

They're not ready for this slay 

D'Angelo's passing about to make the Neo-Soul 2000 rate all the more bittersweet

 

our last St Vincent discog rate was pre-Masseduction so lowkey I wanna do one 

2 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

our last St Vincent discog rate was pre-Masseduction so lowkey I wanna do one 

Krokodil sweeping 

When 1997MTW Part 2 is Left of the Middle vs. Let's Talk About Love vs. Share My World vs. Supa Dupa Fly vs. Surfacing

 

And then we throw in Robyn is Here too because it got its US release in 1997

 

This range

 

 

I may have already posted this before I think I'm just getting forgetful in my old age

 

The International Madonnas Part One is over and the winner is...

 

Spoiler

"California" by Mylène Farmer!

 

Diva Rate Japan is also done

 

traveling by Hikaru Utada was the winner!

On 10/23/2025 at 4:09 PM, conatus said:

 

The International Madonnas Part One is over and the winner is...

 

  Hide contents

"California" by Mylène Farmer!

 

@California their power!

 

This Lily album has come and fucked up the entire game, hasn't it? 

The International Madonnas Part Two is live!

 

What was Ace's rejigged 2018 lineup again? @Ace Reject

 

I'm... considering taking the plunge.

 

I've actually got something in the works. I'm hoping to launch it in the next few days.

4 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

I've actually got something in the works. I'm hoping to launch it in the next few days.

And we will be voting!

On 10/28/2025 at 4:06 PM, Graves said:

What was Ace's rejigged 2018 lineup again? @Ace Reject

 

I'm... considering taking the plunge.

 

Toni. Kylie. Legend X. Lily. Ari. Mimi.

 

Do your damnedst! 

Ooh, the essay I just wrote for this OP!

 

6 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Toni. Kylie. Legend X. Lily. Ari. Mimi.

 

Do your damnedst! 

No Shame over Honey?

 

10 hours ago, conatus said:

No Shame over Honey?

 

Well, none of these albums has been rated previously, and Honey (the song) won @supaspaz his THIS WAS 2018 rate.

 

So give the icons and legends a chance? And, instead thinking No Shame over Honey, think No Shame over CAMILA.

Spoiler

Also No Shame is better.

 

 

31 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

And, instead thinking No Shame over Honey, think No Shame over CAMILA.

Well actually, when you put it like that...

 

And that brings me to THIS YEAR.

 

Allow me, if you will, to present three lineups (three more to come!):

 

THIS WAS POP 2025: NORTH AMERICA (hosted by @supaspaz)

So Close to What v. Mayhem v. Addison v. Man's Best Friend v. The Life of a Showgirl

 

THIS WAS POP 2025: UK (hosted by... @Eeveelution?)

 

eusexua v. Fancy That v. THAT's SHOWBIZ BABE! v. The Art of Loving v. West End Girl

 

THIS WAS INDIEPOP 2025 PART 1 (OPEN FOR ANYONE)

 

Forever is a Feeling v. I Quit v. Virgin v. Moisturizer v. Willoughby Tucker, I Will Always Love You