I have a feeling slow dancing for a harvest sky will feel even better with shorter days and longer nights

 

Obvious will look so good as the This WAS 2025 rate winner

 

1 hour ago, greento said:

Don't include her then!

 

I'm sure Oklou, sombr and…. Billy Woods will be enough to draw a crowd 

Why are you getting at me when I was the one who suggested including Taylor?

https://rateyourmusic.com/list/auntler/albums_released_on_9_11_01/

 

Never Forget: Glitter vs. The Blueprint vs. Ghetto Fabolous vs. Bob Dylan vs Nickelback vs. 

32 minutes ago, Reverie said:

https://rateyourmusic.com/list/auntler/albums_released_on_9_11_01/

 

Never Forget: Glitter vs. The Blueprint vs. Ghetto Fabolous vs. Bob Dylan vs Nickelback vs. 

The way Blueprint solos this whole lineup.

11 minutes ago, Wicked said:

The way Blueprint solos this whole lineup.

10s across the board  

 

Like what rate concept can we force it in, colors of the rainbow face off? And yet another mid Mariah album follows us

52 minutes ago, Reverie said:

10s across the board  

 

Like what rate concept can we force it in, colors of the rainbow face off? And yet another mid Mariah album follows us

The Rap Blockbusters in the New Millennium rate or whatever supa called it: Stankonia/The Notorious KIM/Miss E.../The Blueprint?

Ace coming up with rate ideas:

 

 

6 hours ago, Reverie said:

https://rateyourmusic.com/list/auntler/albums_released_on_9_11_01/

 

Never Forget: Glitter vs. The Blueprint vs. Ghetto Fabolous vs. Bob Dylan vs Nickelback vs. 

I’m actually here for this!

4 hours ago, conatus said:

The Rap Blockbusters in the New Millennium rate or whatever supa called it: Stankonia/The Notorious KIM/Miss E.../The Blueprint?

You sneaking in Kim instead of Eminem #Justice4GangstaBoo

2 hours ago, Eeveelution said:

Ace coming up with rate ideas:

 

 

The way you all are allergic to interesting themes…

2 hours ago, supaspaz said:

You sneaking in Kim instead of Eminem #Justice4GangstaBoo

I guess we could throw her in too but Marsha is just... ratings poison. She'll never be Gangsta Boo, may she rest in peace.

 

Though there is always the option of doing either The Eminem Show or The Michael Myers LP. Truly spoiled for choice there.

 

On 9/10/2025 at 6:48 PM, Eeveelution said:

Not too much.

 

 

On 9/10/2025 at 6:52 PM, honights said:

Okgod is the AOTY so I will be there

 

 

On 9/10/2025 at 6:59 PM, Reverie said:

I have a feeling slow dancing for a harvest sky will feel even better with shorter days and longer nights

 

 

On 9/10/2025 at 7:05 PM, Eeveelution said:

Obvious will look so good as the This WAS 2025 rate winner

 

The way you all just made this person up... when did Riley Keough take on a pseudonym?!??!

2002 will be next in the (YEAR) makes a woman, I fear. Think of the options!

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

2002 will be next in the (YEAR) makes a woman, I fear. Think of the options!

Brandy? Norah? Ashanti? Amerie? Best New Artist Grammy Winner Legend X? Tweet? Trina? Faith (Hill, not Evans)?

 

Just please not Shania...

 

Just now, conatus said:

Brandy? Norah? Ashanti? Amerie? Best New Artist Grammy Winner Legend X? Tweet? Trina? Faith (Hill, not Evans)?

 

Just please not Shania...

 

Thinking...

 

Stripped v. Full Moon v. Come Away with Me v. Let Go v. Ashanti v. This is Me... Then (someone needs to go home first!)

17 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Thinking...

 

Stripped v. Full Moon v. Come Away with Me v. Let Go v. Ashanti v. This is Me... Then (someone needs to go home first!)

Ashanti there twice iktr

 

37 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Thinking...

 

Stripped v. Full Moon v. Come Away with Me v. Let Go v. Ashanti v. This is Me... Then (someone needs to go home first!)

This is Brandy's to lose 

 

3 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

This is Brandy and Ashanti's to lose 

 

Exactly

 

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

Exactly

 

She will get her 10s for Foolish

 

Inspired by the latest episode of my favorite podcast…

 

https://slate.com/podcasts/hit-parade/2025/09/how-songs-debut-at-no-1-on-the-billboard-pop-chart

 

How about a rate of every song to debut at #1 on the Hot 100? Could do it later this fall, after Taylor’s inevitable next chart-topper.

@Ace Reject at some point, probably not for a few months, I was thinking of doing another Carly rate, this time for all her unreleased songs, sort of like a Side B teas and also because I'm not gonna have time to do it for the current rate. Just wanted to confirm whether a rate focusing on unreleased material would be allowed?

Rate idea - British pop is in good hands

 

JADE vs Rose Gray vs Pinkpantheress vs Lola Young

 

5 hours ago, Eeveelution said:

Rate idea - British pop is in good hands

 

JADE vs Rose Gray vs Pinkpantheress vs Lola Young

 

Why, maybe!

 

HAD AN IDEA of how to handle THIS WAS POP 2025:

 

Mayhem v. Man's Best Friend v. The Life of a Showgirl v. LANA v. brighter days ahead 

 

Like, the actual superstars. Which leaves room for the rate you suggested, @Eeveelution, and for another TWPOP rate with Tate and Addison and sombr and... others. ("New" Kids on the Block? Let's go with that.)

 

Vie. Alligator Bites Never Heal v. Am I The Drama can be its own rate!

7 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Why, maybe!

 

HAD AN IDEA of how to handle THIS WAS POP 2025:

 

Mayhem v. Man's Best Friend v. The Life of a Showgirl v. LANA v. brighter days ahead 

 

Like, the actual superstars. Which leaves room for the rate you suggested, @Eeveelution, and for another TWPOP rate with Tate and Addison and sombr and... others. ("New" Kids on the Block? Let's go with that.)

 

Vie. Alligator Bites Never Heal v. Am I The Drama can be its own rate!

And of course, 2025 Makes the Woman - Mariah vs Miley vs Demi vs Ava Max vs Ichiko Aoba vs Hayley Williams