1 minute ago, Graves said:

Usher locked out of the Top 5 is nasty business.

Swap “Jesus Walks” for “U Don’t Have to Call.”

 

I love his booty forward pose in that banner. Such a little diva!

1 minute ago, conatus said:

Oh I'm down to repeat albums as many times as possible if the concepts are fun.

 

Not Eminem though. Once is too much when it comes to Marsha.

 

You’ll probably be too busy rating the Kylie Minogue of Malaysia anyway.
 

The way I want to rate Shaggy now…

14 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

The concept of Mac DeMarco winning an atrl rate 

I'm sowing the seeds. I will reap the harvest!!!!

 

1989 Makes The Woman: will be fascinating. Outside of Madonna and Janet, you have:

 

Cher

Tina 

Diana

Dolly

Reba

Liza

Kate

Cyndi

 

Belinda Carlisle

Debbie Gibson

Queen Latifah

 

And, of course, Jody!

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

I'm sowing the seeds. I will reap the harvest!!!!

 

1989 Makes The Woman: will be fascinating. Outside of Madonna and Janet, you have:

 

Cher

Tina 

Diana

Dolly

Reba

Liza

Kate

Cyndi

 

Belinda Carlisle

Debbie Gibson

Queen Latifah

 

And, of course, Jody!

Paula not being an 89 release is heartbreaking.

18 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Some more ideas that would never work on ATRL!

 

2000: The Marshall Mathers LP vs. Country Grammar vs. Hot Shot vs. Voodoo vs. Sound Loaded (just generally ignoring R. Kelly’s existence here and everywhere)

2001: The Blueprint vs. 8701 vs. Invincible vs. Escape vs. Room For Squares (and add “Love and Theft” for shits and giggles)

 

2002: The Eminem Show vs. Nellyville vs. Justified vs. Sea Change vs. The Rising (or American IV)

 

2003: Get Rich or Die Tryin’ vs. Speakerboxxx vs. The Love Below vs. The Black Album vs. Heavier Things (or keep it fully among the rappers with Jackpot or Street Dreams instead)

 

2004: Confessions vs. The College Dropout vs. Smile vs. (ugh, I guess) Encore vs. (do we need to acknowledge country here?) Live Like You Were Dying  or When the Sun Goes Down

 

I know these are dumb, but this is such a fun exercise!

Born to Do It for 2000! 

1971 Makes the Man: American Pie vs. Hunky Dory vs. Pieces of a Man vs. Songs of Love and Hate vs. What's Going On

 

I refuse to acknowledge John Lennon's solo career

 

2 minutes ago, Graves said:

Paula not being an 89 release is heartbreaking.

You should throw her with Janet, Madonna and maybe I’m Your Baby Tonight for a true A-list throwdown.

 

1989 Makes the Woman can be for the rest: Kate Bush! Bonnie Raitt!

3 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Born to Do It for 2000! 

Fill Me In's perfect 10.0 average is looming

4 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Born to Do It for 2000! 

Cute! I guess he could take D’Angelo’s spot, since conatus is “definitely” hosting that other rate

6 minutes ago, Graves said:

Paula not being an 89 release is heartbreaking.

There's always my old Daughters of Control idea (Jody's debut vs. Forever Your Girl vs. The Right Stuff ... vs. Out of the Blue? Pebbles? The Karyn White album?)

 

9 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

I'm sowing the seeds. I will reap the harvest!!!!

 

1989 Makes The Woman: will be fascinating. Outside of Madonna and Janet, you have:

 

Cher

Tina 

Diana

Dolly

Reba

Liza

Kate

Cyndi

 

Belinda Carlisle

Debbie Gibson

Queen Latifah

 

And, of course, Jody!

So many flops and you still forgot future AOTY winner Nick of Time

Just now, supaspaz said:

So many flops

1 minute ago, conatus said:

There's always my old Daughters of Control idea (Jody's debut vs. Forever Your Girl vs. The Right Stuff ... vs. Out of the Blue? Pebbles? The Karyn White album?)

 

Debbie doesn’t belong there. Throw in Pebbles so that “Mercedes Boy” can win!

Just now, supaspaz said:

Debbie doesn't belong there. Throw in Pebbles so that "Girlfriend" can win!

Exactly

1 minute ago, conatus said:

Well, that was basically the end for Cyndi! And poor Belinda.

2 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

You should throw her with Janet, Madonna and maybe I’m Your Baby Tonight for a true A-list throwdown.

 

1989 Makes the Woman can be for the rest: Kate Bush! Bonnie Raitt!

How could I forget the AOTY winner!

 

We could ignore Madonna and Janet since they were rated with Paula prior (Battle of The Small Voices!) and make 89 MTW a real legends lineup.

 

Nick of Time v. Heart of Stone v. Results v. Working Overtime v. Foreign Affair v. The Sensual World vs. White Limozeen! Yes!

Just now, Ace Reject said:

How could I forget the AOTY winner!

 

We could ignore Madonna and Janet since they were rated with Paula prior (Battle of The Small Voices!) and make 89 MTW a real legends lineup.

 

Nick of Time v. Heart of Stone v. Results v. Working Overtime v. Foreign Affair v. The Sensual World vs. White Limozeen! Yes!

Sister, now's our chance to get Don't Drop Bombs to win a rate @Ghibli

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

There's always my old Daughters of Control idea (Jody's debut vs. Forever Your Girl vs. The Right Stuff ... vs. Out of the Blue? Pebbles? The Karyn White album?)

 

YES. 

 

And one based on a Pop Pantheon album, with Belinda/Tiffany/Debbie/Taylor Dayne!

1 minute ago, conatus said:

Sister, now's our chance to get Don't Drop Bombs to win a rate @Ghibli

See when you're one of the best songs of all time...

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

YES. 

 

And one based on a Pop Pantheon album, with Belinda/Tiffany/Debbie/Taylor Dayne!

If you took out Belinda, this could have such a cute mall rats theme

6 minutes ago, conatus said:

There's always my old Daughters of Control idea (Jody's debut vs. Forever Your Girl vs. The Right Stuff ... vs. Out of the Blue? Pebbles? The Karyn White album?)

 

Jody Watley.

The Right Stuff.

Forever Your Girl. 

Pebbles.

Karyn White.

 

It's like you read my mind. All of Janet's sisters! YES.

Just now, supaspaz said:

If you took out Belinda, this could have such a cute mall rats theme

Belinda was also aiming for the youth! Add Kylie (Enjoy Yourself) and you really have something cooking!

Just now, Ace Reject said:

Belinda was also aiming for the youth! Add Kylie (Enjoy Yourself) and you really have something cooking!

2 minutes ago, conatus said:

 

Classics. We love CLASSICS over here!

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Jody Watley.

The Right Stuff.

Forever Your Girl. 

Pebbles.

Karyn White.

 

It's like you read my mind. All of Janet's sisters! YES.

Be a Man, Girlfriend, Most of All, The Way That You Love Me, Secret Rendezvous top 5... Whew