Just now, Overprotected said:

Can I do a discog rate for the best UK girl group All Saints? 

Omg thoughts? @Auburn

2 minutes ago, Overprotected said:

Omg thoughts? @Auburn

absolutely here for this!   I know @prézli is in idk about any other stans I think I remember @Legend E and/or @Hey Dude praising them sorry if I'm wrong and tagged you for nothing

41 minutes ago, Auburn said:

absolutely here for this!   I know @prézli is in idk about any other stans I think I remember @Legend E and/or @Hey Dude praising them sorry if I'm wrong and tagged you for nothing

I actually checked them out thanks to their feature on GTA 5 a few years ago, so I'll join this 

16 hours ago, Auburn said:

absolutely here for this!   I know @prézli is in idk about any other stans I think I remember @Legend E and/or @Hey Dude praising them sorry if I'm wrong and tagged you for nothing

It would actually be a great opportunity for me to fully delve into their discography

On 10/5/2023 at 12:53 PM, Overprotected said:

Omg thoughts? @Auburn

I LOVE THIS. Yes! Chills!

On 10/1/2023 at 11:35 PM, Hey Dude said:

I plan to put up the Kylie Singles Rate tomorrow (October 2nd) 

Will do some visuals and make an @ list 

 

I think a month will be good to give time to send scores.

 

Probably best to reveal the bubbling under 100 as one post and do 25 reveals each day. 

Hold on now! Shouldn't you wait until... more singles from Tension are announced?

This will be fun 

Just now, Ace Reject said:

Hold on now! Shouldn't you wait until... more singles from Tension are announced?

Some people actually asked about this as well and a few would like a full discography rate so I can definitely put it on pause if you would like. Only 4 lists came in so far. 

23 minutes ago, Hey Dude said:

Some people actually asked about this as well and a few would like a full discography rate so I can definitely put it on pause if you would like. Only 4 lists came in so far. 

Yep - pause it until the new year please!

43 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

I LOVE THIS. Yes! Chills!

Yayy will prep for it 

Hey!

Am I allowed to make a Beyoncé's RWT Opening Outfit Rate?

Basé has been asking for it and I might be up for the task!

Seeing as the wee Kylie rate has been pushed back, maybe we should do a different diva rate in the meantime?

 

And since she’s on her greatest hits tour rn, a Medoner rate could be fun. Singles perhaps?

Are there any active rates at the moment? 

9 hours ago, khalyan said:

Are there any active rates at the moment? 

Doesn't seem so 

 

I would love to do a rate inspired by Lilith Fair for pop rock ladies ATRL is familiar with.

8 hours ago, Hey Dude said:

Doesn't seem so 

 

I would love to do a rate inspired by Lilith Fair for pop rock ladies ATRL is familiar with.

A couple of years ago, @Ace Reject and I were working on a shortlist for a 2010s Dance Hits rate. Calvin Harris, David Guetta, Avicii, Chainsmokers, Disclosure, Zedd, etc. Maybe it's time to finally get that finished, I could probably have time for the rate after Thanksgiving. 

On 11/12/2023 at 9:57 AM, khalyan said:

A couple of years ago, @Ace Reject and I were working on a shortlist for a 2010s Dance Hits rate. Calvin Harris, David Guetta, Avicii, Chainsmokers, Disclosure, Zedd, etc. Maybe it's time to finally get that finished, I could probably have time for the rate after Thanksgiving. 

Ooh! Yes!

On 11/12/2023 at 1:41 AM, Hey Dude said:

Doesn't seem so 

 

I would love to do a rate inspired by Lilith Fair for pop rock ladies ATRL is familiar with.

Rating their albums or singles?

Why are things all quiet on the ATRL Grammys front? 

2 hours ago, Achilles. said:

Why are things all quiet on the ATRL Grammys front? 

@supaspaz has a lot to do, between that and THIS WAS 2023! But.... this year...

6 hours ago, Achilles. said:

Why are things all quiet on the ATRL Grammys front? 

I’m sorry. I’ve been super busy recently and they also moved up the nominations so early this year, there was no way I could get things together in time. But I’m also honestly struggling with motivation this year. Something about it feels so daunting…

1 hour ago, supaspaz said:

I’m sorry. I’ve been super busy recently and they also moved up the nominations so early this year, there was no way I could get things together in time. But I’m also honestly struggling with motivation this year. Something about it feels so daunting…

Don’t apologize, I get it! I imagine arranging the whole thing is even more demanding than it looks—and it already looks like a lot! But if there’s anything I can do to help lighten the load somehow I’d be more than happy to help out!

So, We've had a consensus. Year ends are approaching and we have to sort this out!

 

THIS WAS 2023 will be split into TWO rates.

 

I believe @supaspaz has expressed interest in the first lineup:

 

Boygenius

Jessie Ware

Victoria Monet

Zach Bryan

Olivia Rodrigo

 

Which leaves the second edition needing a host! Rating these albums....

 

Lana Del Rey

Kelela

Caroline Polachek

Mitski

Sufjan Stevens

 

And THIS WAS POP 2023 will be split up into two, as well

 

Rate 1 - Icons and Legends

 

Miley Cyrus

Pink

Kelly Clarkson

Kylie Minogue

Nicki Minaj (if it actually is released this year)

 

Rate 2 - The New Class

 

Amaarae

Madison Beer

Troye Sivan

Chappell Roan 

PinkPantheress 

 

Who wants in?

Does anyone have the results of Her Madgesty: The Madonna Discography Rate? I missed that one and would love to see how it all went down 

On 11/13/2023 at 12:55 PM, Ace Reject said:

Rating their albums or singles?

I have these artists in mind:

 

Sarah McLachlan

Kelly Clarkson

P!nk

Avril Lavigne

Michelle Branch

Natalie Imbruglia

 

From my experience there is a lot of overlap between fans of these artists. 

I think their 10 most successful hits may be good? I remember there was a rate with such a format for individual Spice Girl careers. 

 

10 hours ago, Hurem said:

Does anyone have the results of Her Madgesty: The Madonna Discography Rate? I missed that one and would love to see how it all went down 

Can't access it but I remember someone said Sky Fits Heaven won (it also won in the oldATRL rate as well apparently)