11 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Include Billie if you dare!

Completely forgot she had an album coming out, but yes! Do you see the vision?

20 hours ago, supaspaz said:

Random thought: Instead of waiting for This Was 2024, we do Popdemonium! 2024 this summer, featuring Eternal Sunshine vs. Cowboy Carter vs. The Tortured Poets Department vs. Radical Optimism.

Dua is going to get massacred 

On 4/7/2024 at 7:33 AM, Achilles. said:

I think Troye has enough of a catalog for a discography rate by now, doesn't he?

oof let me know when this happens so I can give for him. the points 

On 5/16/2024 at 9:40 PM, supaspaz said:

Completely forgot she had an album coming out, but yes! Do you see the vision?

I see it! And a part two with Charli and Sabrina and others!

23 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

I see it! And a part two with Charli and Sabrina and others!

I know! There’s too many big releases.

34 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

I know! There’s too many big releases.

I fear we may have to move Dua to part two instead, you know? Save the first part for the albums with hits...

 

Bey/Tay/William/Ari

 

Dua/Charli/Sabrina/Faded 80s born popstar of your choice

We've had rates for such j-pop queens/monarchs as Ayumi, Namie, Utada etc. but we kind of left the most gay-friendly of them, Kumi Koda, behind, so in the spirit of the Pride Month I suggest a singles rate for her. The only problem is that she has more than 100 of them, so if it's possible, we could split the rate into two parts: her 00s singles, which roughly make up the half of them, and her 10s-20s singles. Something also shifted in her approach to the singles after the 00s, so it's not only out of pure convenience. And while the 00s singles have a clear favorite among them, the latter half will be more unpredictable in its outcome. The first part can take part at some point in the summer (I'm ready whenever), and the second one in the fall.

On 6/24/2024 at 11:20 PM, Suilen said:

We've had rates for such j-pop queens/monarchs as Ayumi, Namie, Utada etc. but we kind of left the most gay-friendly of them, Kumi Koda, behind, so in the spirit of the Pride Month I suggest a singles rate for her. The only problem is that she has more than 100 of them, so if it's possible, we could split the rate into two parts: her 00s singles, which roughly make up the half of them, and her 10s-20s singles. Something also shifted in her approach to the singles after the 00s, so it's not only out of pure convenience. And while the 00s singles have a clear favorite among them, the latter half will be more unpredictable in its outcome. The first part can take part at some point in the summer (I'm ready whenever), and the second one in the fall.

Sure!

I don't recall a Britney discography rate happening after Glory and the only one I see listed in the OP was cancelled. If there wasn't such rate recently, could I host one?

The gang needs a Kendrick Lamar discography rate tbh.

 

But I don't remember the qualifications for that. Can unreleased songs be included to a fault? Like you can't really talk his music without Cartoon & Cereal.

 

I shoulda said this like 2 months ago cause idk if I can host it but I'll throw the idea out lol

On 6/26/2024 at 10:50 PM, Ace Reject said:

Sure!

I have everything ready for the first part, and I can start it this weekend, if that's ok.

I do think if Taylor is included in TW24, that only the original 16 songs from TTPD should be included.

I know CC has 27 but the interludes can be cut to bring it down to 19/20.

On 7/5/2024 at 5:08 AM, Wicked said:

The gang needs a Kendrick Lamar discography rate tbh.

 

But I don't remember the qualifications for that. Can unreleased songs be included to a fault? Like you can't really talk his music without Cartoon & Cereal.

 

I shoulda said this like 2 months ago cause idk if I can host it but I'll throw the idea out lol

Mention it all!

This is a crisis.

 

There are no active rates right now.

 

Can someone do something?!?!?

Someone needs to do This Was Pop 2023 with Chappell, Troye, RAYE, Kim Petras and PinkPantheress or something like that 

5 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

This is a crisis.

 

There are no active rates right now.

 

Can someone do something?!?!?

Well

 

 

With so many girls releasing this year, I hope will have a big ass rate at the end of the year? 

 

Ariana, Taylor, Beyonce, Billie, Dua, Katy, Charli, Nelly Furtado, maybe Gaga?

 

What a rate

On 7/11/2024 at 8:19 AM, Hurem said:

With so many girls releasing this year, I hope will have a big ass rate at the end of the year? 

 

Ariana, Taylor, Beyonce, Billie, Dua, Katy, Charli, Nelly Furtado, maybe Gaga?

 

What a rate

Talk to @supaspaz - he wants to do a TW2024 with the first five!

On 7/10/2024 at 11:17 PM, greento said:

Someone needs to do This Was Pop 2023 with Chappell, Troye, RAYE, Kim Petras and PinkPantheress or something like that 

Don't make people suffer through Kim like that!

 

TW POP 2023 Part 1 - Jessie/Kylie/Miley/Troye

 

Part 2 - PinkPantheress/Chappell Roan/RAYE/Madison Beer

 

TW ALTPOP 2023 - Lana/Caroline/Kelela/Sufjan

 

Come on everyone?!?!?!? @Eeveelution @MP2K @madonnas @khalyan @touya kinomoto @Wicked @naval23 

 

Someone anyone?!??! Think of the children!

11 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Don't make people suffer through Kim like that!

 

TW POP 2023 Part 1 - Jessie/Kylie/Miley/Troye

 

Part 2 - PinkPantheress/Chappell Roan/RAYE/Madison Beer

 

TW ALTPOP 2023 - Lana/Caroline/Kelela/Sufjan

 

Come on everyone?!?!?!? @Eeveelution @MP2K @madonnas @khalyan @touya kinomoto @Wicked @naval23 

 

Someone anyone?!??! Think of the children!

Actually,

 

Move Troye to Part two - add Carly Rae and/or Pink to part one.

 

And THIS WAD R&B 2023: Tinashe/Chloe/Janelle and 1/2 others. 

 

Come y'all!

46 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Don't make people suffer through Kim like that!

 

TW POP 2023 Part 1 - Jessie/Kylie/Miley/Troye

 

Part 2 - PinkPantheress/Chappell Roan/RAYE/Madison Beer

 

TW ALTPOP 2023 - Lana/Caroline/Kelela/Sufjan

You really think the Miley or Madison albums are better than Kim's??

19 minutes ago, greento said:

You really think the Miley or Madison albums are better than Kim's??

J/K/M/CRJ and T/PP/CR/RAYE are lineups that would get people interested! Can't say the same about....

@Ace Reject Since ATRL is here for the 20th anniversary of Autobiography, what about an Ashlee Simpson discography rate? 

It's been 2 years since I hosted a rate.

Okay let's revive my Lilith Fair Rate idea