To whoever does This Was and This Was Pop please tag me 

15 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

THIS WAS 2022 (hosted by @supaspaz)

 

Beyoncé v. Taylor Swift v. Bad Bunny v. Harry Styles v. Rosalîa (and maybe a surprise sixth)

ATRL will be shaking!

 

15 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

THIS WAS POP (up for grabs!)

 

Carly Rae Jepsen v. Charli XCX v. Rina Sawayama v. Tove Lo  v. The Weeknd 

And I will be perched for this!

23 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

ATRL will be shaking!

 

And I will be perched for this!

Thinking... maybe twigs should replace Abel for that last slot? What say you, ATRL?

27 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Thinking... maybe twigs should replace Abel for that last slot? What say you, ATRL?

I'm not opposed to that

Okay, let's do that then! 

 

@Insanity you can do your rate with a revised lineup, under the title THIS WAS POP 2022: Men Strike Back.

 

The Weeknd/Post Malone/Charlie Puth/Drake (Honestly, Nevermind) and ONE of the following 'up and coming' pop boys - Joji, Omar Apollo, Rauw Alejandro or Conan Gray. I'll let you choose who's the fifth LP! 

 

And THIS WAS POP 2022: BYE BOYS! BUY GIRLS! will consist of CRJ, Charli, Rina, twigs, Tove, and Lizzo. @Stevie? @creativity. @minho you down?

4 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Okay, let's do that then! 

 

@Insanity you can do your rate with a revised lineup, under the title THIS WAS POP 2022: Men Strike Back.

 

The Weeknd/Post Malone/Charlie Puth/Drake (Honestly, Nevermind) and ONE of the following 'up and coming' pop boys - Joji, Omar Apollo, Rauw Alejandro or Conan Gray. I'll let you choose who's the fifth LP! 

 

And THIS WAS POP 2022: BYE BOYS! BUY GIRLS! will consist of CRJ, Charli, Rina, twigs, Tove, and Lizzo. @Stevie? @creativity. @minho you down?

alright ill keep that in mind.  I personally listen to Conan the most

Edited November 12, 20223 yr by Insanity

On 11/11/2022 at 1:52 PM, Ace Reject said:

Okay, let's do that then! 

 

@Insanity you can do your rate with a revised lineup, under the title THIS WAS POP 2022: Men Strike Back.

 

The Weeknd/Post Malone/Charlie Puth/Drake (Honestly, Nevermind) and ONE of the following 'up and coming' pop boys - Joji, Omar Apollo, Rauw Alejandro or Conan Gray. I'll let you choose who's the fifth LP! 

 

And THIS WAS POP 2022: BYE BOYS! BUY GIRLS! will consist of CRJ, Charli, Rina, twigs, Tove, and Lizzo. @Stevie? @creativity. @minho you down?

 

On 11/11/2022 at 7:52 PM, Ace Reject said:

And THIS WAS POP 2022: BYE BOYS! BUY GIRLS! will consist of CRJ, Charli, Rina, twigs, Tove, and Lizzo. @Stevie? @creativity. @minho you down?

I love this idea but I wouldn’t want Lizzo, she doesn’t fit the vibe of the other 5.

 

im also loving the indie pop idea with MUNA, Florence etc.

31 minutes ago, greento said:

I love this idea but I wouldn’t want Lizzo, she doesn’t fit the vibe of the other 5.

 

im also loving the indie pop idea with MUNA, Florence etc.

I mean, she fits the vibe more than FKA twigs, even if Special is not a good album.

1 hour ago, supaspaz said:

I mean, she fits the vibe more than FKA twigs, even if Special is not a good album.

Hmm I think she’s too popular to fit with the others

 

twigs should be in indie pop. 
 

carly, Charli, Rina and Tove should just have their own tbh. They’re all very similar in terms of popularity and sound.

7 hours ago, greento said:

I love this idea but I wouldn’t want Lizzo, she doesn’t fit the vibe of the other 5.

 

im also loving the indie pop idea with MUNA, Florence etc.

 

6 hours ago, supaspaz said:

I mean, she fits the vibe more than FKA twigs, even if Special is not a good album.

 

5 hours ago, greento said:

Hmm I think she’s too popular to fit with the others

 

twigs should be in indie pop. 
 

carly, Charli, Rina and Tove should just have their own tbh. They’re all very similar in terms of popularity and sound.

I concur. Let's drop Lizzo and keep the other five..

 

so 2022 Makes The Woman would have Lizzo, Meghan, Megan, Camila and... Avril? Willow? I wish whoever takes that on an ounce of luck!

1 hour ago, Ace Reject said:

so 2022 Makes The Woman would have Lizzo, Meghan, Megan, Camila and... Avril? Willow? I wish whoever takes that on an ounce of luck!

What kind of hell on earth...

@supaspaz I know this is a random request but I thought it would be interesting. Can we have an Ariana Grande discography rate? This site hasn't had one in YEARS, pre-Positions and I'm interested to see in 2022 how everybody ranks her discography and where songs rank. She's one of my favorite female artists and is one of biggest female singers ever, there's enough stans on this site too to participate. Can we have one again?

4 hours ago, yeezytaughtme said:

@supaspaz I know this is a random request but I thought it would be interesting. Can we have an Ariana Grande discography rate? This site hasn't had one in YEARS, pre-Positions and I'm interested to see in 2022 how everybody ranks her discography and where songs rank. She's one of my favorite female artists and is one of biggest female singers ever, there's enough stans on this site too to participate. Can we have one again?

I think this is more up to @Ace Reject. But if there is only one new album since the last time it was done, it feels like maybe a bit too soon to do it again. Unless you do it within the base, which is allowed and has been before for other artists.

5 hours ago, yeezytaughtme said:

@supaspaz I know this is a random request but I thought it would be interesting. Can we have an Ariana Grande discography rate? This site hasn't had one in YEARS, pre-Positions and I'm interested to see in 2022 how everybody ranks her discography and where songs rank. She's one of my favorite female artists and is one of biggest female singers ever, there's enough stans on this site too to participate. Can we have one again?

If there hasn't been one since before... her last album, there's no need.

 

But I do believe you can do an Essentials rate! Every Ari track but the singles. See what the fans really love before you get new stuff. (Only 1 top five or bust!)

@Ace Reject or @supaspaz can you pin my Mariah thread? I need at least 5 more people to send me their ballot (I don't want to cancel it) and maybe who doesn't know about this rate will participate  
thanks 

 

@Ace Reject don't you think it's time for @supaspaz to host the CRJ discography rate? i mean, i would like supa to do it since the E•MO•TION definitive ranking thing that he did was a success!

 

also i'm thinking if a slot opens some time next year, i would like to host a rate for Billboard's 100 Greatest K-pop Songs of the 2010s.

https://www.billboard.com/media/lists/best-k-pop-songs-2010s-top-100-8544710/

@Ace Reject I just finished Mariah's rate. The winner is Underneath The Stars 

Yay!

Has This WAS 2022 or Pop 2022 started yet? I'd love to participate, but I'm too busy to host anything.

21 hours ago, Stevie said:

Has This WAS 2022 or Pop 2022 started yet? I'd love to participate, but I'm too busy to host anything.

Just @Insanity and their Male version. Patiently waiting for the others! Still figuring out where to place SOS, for example..

@Ace Reject can we have a Taylor Swift Discography Rate? I’m not sure we’ve ever had a complete one, or if there was it was pre-Lover, so definitely enough time has passed. I thought it would be fun to do one now before The Eras Tour starts. I can host, unless someone else just really wants to. I’ve got everything typed up and saved. 

2 hours ago, 1989 said:

@Ace Reject can we have a Taylor Swift Discography Rate? I’m not sure we’ve ever had a complete one, or if there was it was pre-Lover, so definitely enough time has passed. I thought it would be fun to do one now before The Eras Tour starts. I can host, unless someone else just really wants to. I’ve got everything typed up and saved. 

Sure!

5 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Sure!

Yay thank you! 

i feel like a taylor discog rate should be saved until after all the Taylor's Versions are released