Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (โ‹ฎ) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Communion

ATRL Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Communion

  1. For those who forgot the infamous reporting from 2020's primaries:
  2. Nevermind I'm fine with them blowing up a bunch of lead over Iowa now.
  3. @LegaMyth There's probably an easy way to get AI to do this but I'm difficult ddd. Basically those clustered 'over' of the general trend wave are being progressive for their district and those clustered 'under' are too moderate for their district. Notably, most House leadership are moderates representing deep blue districts.
  4. Edit - Oops, quote fixed. @nooniebao This was meant for @LegaMyth I don't think progressives claim her much but it's less-so anger at her and she's probably a victim of negative polarization in the way centrists weaponize her to attack the left. She's literally a middle-of-the-pack Dem. Pros: Co-Sponsor on the Block the Bombs Act Voted in favor of Massie amendment to eliminate $3.3b in aid to Israel Voted in favor of the Lebanese War Powers Resolution Voted against rules package on Israel/Ukraine/Taiwan that had the Tiktok Ban tied to it Does not take AIPAC money Cons: Endorsed Haley Stevens in MI-Sen Democratic primary Voted for withholding funds from colleges with events that violated the IHRA definition of antisemitism She seems basically like the archetype of a 'normie' Dem. She's not ideologically progressive OR ideologically anti-progressive. ie: if a vote has something like 70-80% of the caucus voting for it, she's likely to vote for it, even if it's anti-progressive, so she's not like.. ideological in her support for Palestine or progressive causes. But if a progressive idea or policy has broad popularity with voters, there's notable times she's part of the 40-50% of the Dem caucus who support it even if half of the caucus does not. She's thus not ideologically anti-progressive. I always think it's most interesting when a politician randomly breaks ranks because it shows their views, ie: the Squad often are the 10% of the caucus who vote for ultra progressive policy on foreign policy, for example. Some notable examples of Underwood: Voted against ending a pilot program to let AI voice recognition technology be used for drug testing It's odd as, if I was a journalist, I'd be interested in if she gets any pro-AI funding, but she's been very good on voting against pro-crypto legislation. See her other votes randomly for one-off pro-oil or pro-hard on crime bills. She's essentially a "consensus Democrat". She's not AOC but she's also not DWS.
  5. The way the "she said they'll keep him, a black man, ON A SHORT ROPE" isn't even what was said. "I think he will have a relatively short rope to show that kind of urgency and perhaps abandon some of the caution that everybody notes as one of his one of his qualities," There's no way to interpret "he has a short rope to show.." as somehow meaning "we're gonna keep him on a short rope/leash" in good faith.
  6. Is her voice okay? I'm not even a "you need to sing!!!" person but the vocals around 0:20 sound like she's genuinely sick / congested. Was this a surprise / impromptu performance?
  7. Just some additional context to this. The CBC-related PAC did help McKinney but McKinney likely feels fine voting more-so with DSA because the actual organizing that took place to get him elected over Shri came from progressive groups and DSA. There was a thread shared on here awhile back during primary season on how the black political establishment in Detroit are essentially hapless and have had no success to either primary Rashida Tlaib or Shri Thanedar to get black representation elected. Much of the organizing for Donovan was pushed for by Rashida herself. He leaned much more into DSA/Hasan's logistical support (fundraising, canvassing) to beat Shri.
  8. It's good if the few states who have a big enough economy can launch public insurance do so, but I do think some hesitations should be had on if such is a viable alternative to Medicare For All. It's also relevant to the context of people like Searchlight and Majority Democrats spreading the lie that "Vermont tried M4A and it failed". States cannot try Medicare For All. Medicare is a federally administered program. Vermont tried not to "do M4A" but launch its own public health insurance, "Green Mountain Care". The issue? Because it's a state-ran program, you can't just fold the states' Medicare members into it. CMS manages Medicare, not states. You can't also use the federal funding that is going to subsidize rates for those Medicare members. CMS was clear it would not let states manage Medicare funds! A state-run insurance requires funding entirely generated by the state and the state alone. You can't even try and re-allocate the dollars states receive for Medicaid for it due to funding for Medicaid being a combination of federal and state funding. States like California and New York definitely have large economies to make sure every resident is guaranteed at least some basic coverage at no cost sharing, but all of this highlights why Medicare For all is really the most efficient plan because it largely utilizes money we already spend.
  9. The issue is that there's an inherent selfishness in Jeffries wanting to taint the legacy of the first black person to be Speaker of the House by knowing his ideology will simply not work and will usher in a level of political failure that will ultimately hurt black politicians in his failure. That it's a disservice to what it means to be the "first black Speaker of the House" by knowing you will be the first black Speaker of the House to also vote against universal healthcare because you want poor people to die to save insurance companies, the first black Speaker of the House to vote for slaughtering Palestinians and defending a genocide, the first black Speaker of the House to let majority-black communities be poisoned to death from the polluted waste and forever PFAS chemicals in their water from mass data center proliferation. Historical materialism is not a vibe. It's a science! It's the observable truth of linear history! The contradictions of capitalism don't care about political narratives. The innate propulsion of inequality as it worsen under capitalism don't stop just because "the first black man becomes the Speaker of the House". These problems require transformative policy to stop them. Policy that Hakeem Jeffries does not want. And so he will fail. And it is hubris and selfishness for him to want to tie history to his inevitable failure.
  10. AOC = Sanders Harris = Warren Ossoff = Biden Pete = Pete
  11. I do think some of the praise from centrists of Underwood is in bad faith though. Because some of the centrists who uplift her to attack progressives never acknowledge that Underwood is progressive for her district. Her record is much more progressive for someone in a district Harris only won by 5. If every Dem in a D+3 district voted like her, progressives wouldn't have much ammo against centrists. She also doesn't take AIPAC money to get elected in the way many Democrats do.
  12. I think people should keep on eye out on what "lowering the age of Medicare" actually will look like. There's a difference between: Lowering Medicare eligibility from 65 to 50 and folding those people into Medicare's subsidized rates that eliminates most cost-sharing. Letting people start at age 50 to pay premiums to Medicare for an almost public option-like alternative. I like Tammy Baldwin, but her "Medicare at 50" bill, for example, is not what progressives mean when we say to lower the age of Medicare. Let alone that Sanders' plan to put everyone on Medicare also then includes closing the current coverage gaps in Medicare. Baldwin's plan is the second option, not the first option explained above. Biden was particularly awful on healthcare because he didn't just stand against progressive policy, but used his administration to help proliferate the spread of private, predatory Medicare Advantage plans, for example.
  13. To be fair, there also would have been no point to send him S.1129 - Medicare for All Act of 2019 when he explicitly said he'd veto it:
  14. I mean, this is basically the factual reality of it. If you think lowering Medicare eligibility to 55 or 50 is good... then Medicare For All is better because it is an extension of what makes such policy good, taking those benefits further to everyone.
  15. The irony being that pop stars filling up the category prior would often be on EDM DJ songs like his. It's odd to not recognize that the Dance Pop category was just as much necessary given the bias older voters in the pop field would have for pop songs with more organic instrumentation. Pop Solo is the category that has given us winners like "Joanne (Stripped)". Pop Solo Dance Pop Dance Electronic are all clearly three different types of genres / sounds, and so I can't take anyone seriously if they claim they can't see how Melatonin isn't structurally or production-wise the same as songs in dance pop like Blue Moon but that Blue Moon is also different from what made it to Pop Solo.
  16. Just to be clear to this - student debt relief remains - ! - popular: I think also Buttigieg's donors ultimately show how their politics are cancerous by denying material reality. Student debt relief didn't become a pivotal issue in the 2020 primary and extremely popular amongst voters because of progressives and young voters ~being edgy~ or whatever he seems to think it is. It's popular because it's a form of debt materially restricting the real ability people have on being able to afford to live. And how did we get here? Because Democrats under Obama did a half-measure compromise where billions of dollars were used to fund new Pell Grants and Obama's presidency literally oversaw a massive campaign to get 1st generation students to go to college. "Be the first in your family to get a degree!". The reality of WHO is a college grad demographically fundamentally changed from 1990 to 2010.
  17. I think people have a strong annoyance to Buttigieg because no other figure, besides maybe Rahm Emanual, show such a disproportionate donor backing vs how much he's actually ever achieved in his political career (a mayor of a small college town considered to have done a bad job!). And that once you actually look at what he's saying, he's ultimately saying nothing and is talking in circle. 1) "People don't like having to pay for things they don't get to enjoy" is a silly argument because it doesn't actually apply to anything in politics. The foundation of taxation is the argument you will pay for something even if you may not necessarily use it yourself - people without children don't get to say their taxes don't go to fund schools, we don't end the child tax credits cause some adults don't have kids, etc. But even so, his claim is just not true. Student debt relief was popular! Announcing student debt relief caused Biden's popularity with young voters to soar. And, in part, Biden and Dems' popularity crashed with young people because 99% of the student debt relief that was done went to people over the age of 32. Almost no one under the age of 32 saw their student loans changed in any way. The tinkering around the edges Biden did - fixing how payments were documented for PSLF, IDR - led to a (great!) forgiveness for people who already had made 10-20 years of payments. 2) On the issue of Medicare For All, it's not even an issue of views. He's just straight up lying by claiming "everyone has come around to my original plan". In 2020, he ran on a public option where people could "buy into" a government-run plan and pay a yearly premium. This is literally the text of his public option buy-in published in 2019: https://medium.com/the-moment-by-pete-for-america/heres-a-better-way-to-do-medicare-for-all-4edaf2e4c261 It's perplexing why he is lying and claiming he has called for universal coverage for all but "with an opt out". But it's also no coincidence that CAP, now trying to kill the momentum for M4A, has similarly pivoted from the unpopular "public option" rhetoric and done the rhetorical lie of "of course we support auto-enrolling everyone and everyone being on the plan!!!... but then they can opt out".
  18. No one questioned the bold in this post: The thing people are telling you to not be complacent in is the text in the red because your view expressed in that statement ("I'll take...") is not one shared by a majority of Americans. We quite literally have a decade of evidence that the majority of Americans will indeed choose the nazi rapist over the centrist if centrists are why they feel gas is high. No one who would choose the centrist over the fascist cause they know better can take comfort in such a minority opinion.
  19. (Surely you can now understand why progressives were frustrated that these were the types of people liberal politicians and thinktankers were actually referencing when talking about making room in the Democratic Party for Never Trump Republicans? ddd Not to accuse or assume you were ever an O'Leary fan, to be clear. But just that there are many people who seem supportive in the abstract of moderation or incremental liberalism but then forget in practice in the US it looks like billionaire Canadian conservatives being like "I need Democrats to understand the real fascistsโ€ฆ.are the teachers unions!!!" like girl I'm sick of living in the real life nation version of Monoply dddddd)
  20. Didn't the last 10 years of politics just show you that your view on this is not shared by most Americans?
  21. "The Netanyahu regime" Oh girly he's snapping

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions โ†’ Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.