2 amazing ballads that were released in the same year (1998)

Edited April 16Apr 16 by Pluto6

Impossible choice

frozen

Choice impossible.

Here For Them All

My All by miles

One of the prettiest ballads of all time.

Frozen by far, I never cared for My All or any of those Spanish ballads from that time. If it was against Breakdown or The Roof it would be a true competition

My All is the better song, but Frozen is undeniably more popular.

Even if you take away Mariah's vocals, she's an outstanding poet. That's talent, take notes, those of you saying certain former teen popstars are "gifted songwriters". THIS is how you do it.

Frozen is cute too.

My all is the song that got me into Mariah but Frozen is my favorite song of all time and made me stan Madonna

I love both.

Are different things.

1. Frozen is a mid-tempo not a ballad.

2. I think Frozen is better but My All was bigger (maybe because that, the ballads were so big the 90's).

Better: Frozen

Bigger: My All (but Frozen close, was a massive hit).

Edited April 16Apr 16 by descg

2 minutes ago, descg said:

1. Frozen is a mid-tempo not a ballad

Madonna's "Frozen" (1998) is best described as an electronic pop ballad with strong influences from several subgenres.

Edited April 16Apr 16 by Pluto6

Better: My All

Bigger: Frozen

31 minutes ago, Pluto6 said:

Madonna's "Frozen" (1998) is best described as an electronic pop ballad with strong influences from several subgenres.

So, what is a midtempo then? (rhetoric question)

Edit: The Power Of Goodbye is a electrónic ballad, Frozen is a mid-tempo (nothing better than a song from the same album as example).

Edited April 16Apr 16 by descg

One of these songs could be released today and it would still sound current tbh.

But it's an unfair fight to me cause i love My All as well

Uh...i wish i had lived through this period of music but i was busy being 6 or 8 or whatever

Did you have to compare two of my favorite songs?

Love both but I'd have to go for Frozen CuzI can listen to it any time and enjoy it. My alll I kinda have to be in a specific Mood.

Frozen is one of the best songs of all time. The other cute but Frozen is on another level.

I can't choose.

I love both songs.

But I think Frozen is more successful globally. I don't know

Frozen for both

Frozen actually gagged me bad and I'm a huge Mariah stan.

Frozen is amazing but My All just tickles a part of my brain that not many songs do.

And I think My All is a perfect example of how vocal delivery enhances a musical piece. Her voice and the way she sings this song is just other worldly. Few have made music at that level.

My All for all.

Frozen is a still an experimental masterpiece though.

frozen is so good. my all sounds like 100 other songs