Which 6th studio album wins?

 

 

I've only lived through one of these eras, so MAYHEM

 

 

Spoiler

I'm biased

 

Bedtime, easily 

Mayhem, Bedtime, Bedtime

 

Bedtime Stories.

However I gave MAYHEM the more acclaimed vote because it had Poptimism on its side and I assume Bedtime Stories would get more flack based on the cultural context alone (despite being acclaimed as well).

Gaga sweetie, I'm sorry you're being set up like this

They both kinda suck / overrated 

Bedtime Stories and it's not even close. Great album.

 

Is it just me, or is Mayhem really corny?

Edited October 27, 2025Oct 27 by UrMom

.

Edited October 27, 2025Oct 27 by David_Greengrass97

They're so different, Mayhem is so busy and noisy and Bedtimes Stories is so beautiful and soothing 

 

 

I prefer Bedtimes but (incredibly) far

But I love Abra 

49 minutes ago, David_Greengrass97 said:

But you're an OGH? 😐 Strange that you prefer MAYHEM to BS

you just didn't read it correctly, ofc I prefer Bedtime to Mayhem

 

but TFM against Bedtime? That would be a match.

 

lmao the edit 

Edited October 27, 2025Oct 27 by Démodé

I was born in 2000 so I can't speak on how massive Bedtime Stories was but I know for a fact that it has a better everything than Mayhem. 

Love Tried To Welcome Me is better than anything Gagita has ever made, I fear. 

not fair because gaga is my main, but bedtime is my favorite madonna album 

MAYHEM for all 

33 minutes ago, Kern said:

They both kinda suck / overrated 

In what universe is Bedtime Stories overrated? If anything it's usually her most underrated

madonna clears x

Gaga clears and it's not even close

46 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

However I gave MAYHEM the more acclaimed vote because it had Poptimism

try again 

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/madonna-bedtime-stories/

Gaga and her jojo siwa tribute album could never compare to Bedtime Stories

42 minutes ago, Démodé said:

you just didn't read it correctly, ofc I prefer Bedtime to Mayhem

 

but TFM against Bedtime? That would be a match.

Oh, whatever 

Mayhem clears. 

23 minutes ago, Kimi said:

try again 

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/madonna-bedtime-stories/

I voted for MAYHEM as the most acclaimed so I guess I got it right 

i wasn't alive for that era, so Mayhem for all i guess 

MAYHEM of course, we only stan SINGER in this house