Makes me want a pine cone real bad

This is so good. Both this and Isn't That Enough are really solid tracks! I hope either of them do well, it's been a while since Shawn had a decent hit.

POP: (MOCK UPDATE)
?? ?? SHAWN MENDES Why Why Why 70 0 70 0.085 

Spincrease: 146 spins from 35 stations

HOT AC:
− 50 SHAWN MENDES Why Why Why 48 0 48 0.034

 

It's a cute song, would I willingly play it? Not sure but if it pops up in a playlist, I wouldn't skip it.

wait these songs are good 

Oh wow he does not want to be forgotten. This is Good. radio will eat it up.

This is... really good. I am shocked 

I like both songs 

Had this on repeat for the day 

 

it really does give off mumford & sons vibe, the folk-ish stuff from the 2012 like imagine dragons' on top of the world etc such a pub guitar bop, i really like it

the other song was kinda boring, i guess it'll make more sense when the whole album's out.

I like it.

Very strong, but I spot some weakness in his songwriting. That one line should say 'him' not 'her' and we all know it

2 minutes ago, Troll Idle said:

Very strong, but I spot some weakness in his songwriting. That one line should say 'him' not 'her' and we all know it

here you f slurs go

Just now, jeffersonairplanes19 said:

here you f slurs go

stfu I love the song and wish to be adressed it's not that deep

Thought it was gonna be a snooze fest, but it's a bop  King never fails

I like it, it's cute, very chill.

This is so damn boring. It is literally a slowed down version of Texas Hold Em by Beyonce. And did he get a trans man pregnant cause I'm not buying it, Mendy.  That was a joke! I keep going back to him saying he was going to reveal a new side of himself and how he hopes he doesn't disappoint fans... Well, like the so-called Reaganomics  I'm still waiting on the trickle-down effects, we are still waiting. 

Why why why is beautiful. Very catchy and I sense a deservingly big hit for him. He looks great especially in the shirtless and singlet scenes in the MV too. 

 

loving this and the mv. 

Decent song, definitely better than the other one. Just a shame that right when it really picks up, it's already over. And this is one of the longest songs on the album  Could've gone from decent to good if it had a proper ending with a proper bridge and last chorus imo

Spotify - August 9
#26 Canada 126,014
#60 Global 2,067,226    
#94 US 478,836    
#185 UK 85,484 

Edited August 10, 20242 yr by Nefertiti0

He's so hot in the video, never really noticed until now.