poll Speak Now vs My December

[DTF]

After experiencing massive career breakthroughs with their second eras, both legendary singer songwriters came back to the scene with self-written, emotional albums while wearing a dress. 
 

15 years later: Which album is more impactful and has stood the test of time with regard to artistry as a statement after the massive commercial success?

[BrandNewBrandon]

Sober > anything Taylor has ever recorded. 

[JoeAg]

I love Taylor but My December by FAR

 

Kelly is such an underappreciated songwriter! My December is an artistic feat, so obviously influenced by classic rock without ever feeling derivative or like pastiche. she has a very singular voice and it honestly is every bit as good of an album as Jagged Little Pill and The Joshua Tree are

 

My December was my favorite Kelly album for a really long time, but it's a bit too dark to remain my fav album by her. I'd say either All I Ever Wanted or Stronger occupies the top spot now. nonetheless, it's a f*cking stunning album and I hope it eventually will receive retrospective acclaim 

[Legend E]

My December, easily. One of the best albums ever. I have yet to see many artists reaching the highs of Sober, Maybe or Irvine.

 

Speak Now is cute tho!

[Slayn]

The taste exhibited in this thread is so pleasing to me, My December demolishes.

[naval23]

Sober clears Speak Now but Speak Now as a whole I prefer especially the lyrical SCATHING masterpiece 'Dear John'

[Roger21]

Dear John clears anything in that other record. 

[Vixen Eyes]

Mine vs Never Again

Sparks Fly vs One Minute

Back to December vs Hole

Speak Now vs Sober

Dear John vs Don't Waste Your Time

Mean vs Judas

The Story of Us vs Haunted

Never Grow Up vs Be Still

Enchanted vs Maybe

Better Than Revenge vs How I Feel

Innocent vs Yeah

Haunted vs Can I Have a Kiss

Last Kiss vs Irvine

Long Live vs Chivas

Ours vs Fading

If This Was a Movie vs Dirty Little Secret

Superman vs Not Today

 

Speak Now: 9

Tie: 2

My December: 6

 

wait i didnt expect this lol

[DoubleRainbow!]

Kelly can make a Better Than Revenge but Taylor can't make an Irvine 

[iamanearthling]

Is this a serious question? Of course Speak now.