Which song do you think is a bigger comeback hit?

Edited August 8, 20233 yr by Trent W

Flowers had the bigger commercial peak/initial run but I can’t help to think that Shallow will be more remembered. It also has more acclaim & prestige to its cred.

Flowers was the bigger hit.

But I wouldn't say it's a comeback as the album tanked harder than Plastic hearts

5 minutes ago, Chaos Angel said:

Flowers had the bigger commercial peak/initial run but I can’t help to think that Shallow will be more remembered. It also has more acclaim & prestige to its cred.

Not when Flowers chart performance obliterates it, is the better structured song, and Shallow is not even near the best of the films soundtrack. Puhlease.

I think Flowers success It’s unmatchable

Flower bigger song but gaga had the biggest era. 

Flowers broke the record for fastest song to 100M and 1 billion streams

 

It's likely the #1 song of 2023 on the Hot 100 while "Shallow" was a measly #19 for 2019

 

Globally, Flowers also went #1 in France and Germany which Shallow missed 

 

So Flowers

Flowers is the bigger song, but I like Shallow more 

Shallow is much more iconic.

Shallow sweetie. 

Flowers wins the short-term but I think Shallow will out-classic.

Flowers >>>>

Flowers by far in terms of stream/chart success but Shallow will be more remembered and an instant classic already i fear

21 minutes ago, naval23 said:

Flowers broke the record for fastest song to 100M and 1 billion streams

 

It's likely the #1 song of 2023 on the Hot 100 while "Shallow" was a measly #19 for 2019

 

Globally, Flowers also went #1 in France and Germany which Shallow missed 

 

So Flowers

Shallow released in September of 2018 and still was #19 on 2019 year end chart. 

 

Shallow is probably the biggest international song in France of the last 10 years at least. It's diamond there and if certificates like 5x diamond existed , Shallow would probably already been 5x diamond in France 

39 minutes ago, little legend said:

Shallow released in September of 2018 and still was #19 on 2019 year end chart. 

 

Shallow is probably the biggest international song in France of the last 10 years at least. It's diamond there and if certificates like 5x diamond existed , Shallow would probably already been 5x diamond in France 

It charted for 8 weeks in 2018 for Billboards chart and only 2 were in the top 10 and 3 were in the top 20. It probably would've been enough for top 10 year end maximum. 

Shallow sweetie

Flowers sweetie...

Shallow sweetie 

Flowers is way bigger

But Shallow did its job which was to sell the ASIB Soundtrack. It ended up being one of the biggest albums of 2018-2019 and reinvigorated Gaga’s career so…

Flowers

Flowers especially it had not been attached to a movie, no performances or promo

flower is trash

Shallow is a modern classic, it wins by default