Which of these moderate hits that served as the 3rd single from their respective albums is bigger?

Karma is much bigger than Lover was during its initial chart run. But Lover had a lot of longevity.

The one that is Cat in my lap, purring cuz she loves me

Lover, Karma is burning out fast

Overall Karma, but in my country definitely Lover.

 

Whereas Lover was quite a hit here, Karma has been N/A on the charts. Instead we're still going with Anti-Hero...

"Karma" has had the bigger chart success as a single, but I guess "Lover" will end up with more longevity.

Lover will be more remembered tbh

Despite Chart peak, I would go with „Lover” tbh

OH. Interesting take

 

On the run when they are/were singles, I think Karma is much bigger

450mil+ streams when its run hasnt completed yet

meanwhile as far as I remembered, Lover struggled to hit 400mil marks even with Lover Remix version

 

but Lover definitely has more longevity after the Lover era is done

proved with the song has surpassed ME! and YNTCD in streams although both has surpassed 500mil since 2020

Lover itself has surpassed 1 Billion streams on Spotify with all version combined

 

karma will end up the bigger song

Karma is bigger on its chart run but Lover had longevity. It’s difficult to compare since Karma still hasn’t had time to be remembered but it was a fan favorite from the start so Karma might remain bigger

For me it's Karma, Lover is a snoozefest.