Discuss

I'll keep it cute and just say Christina 

Katy for all of course 

Katy

I voted for miss Katheryn Elizabeth Hudson, who had better mvs, songs and personality. 

Katy for all. Xtina has barely no impact.

Christina is obviously known for her hit song “Beautiful”, when Katy has classics like “Firework” and “Swish Swish”.

Christina for all. Recency bias is just clouding this thread. I can't think of anyone who's cited Katy as an inspiration. No shade either I'm a fan. 

I feel like the only remembered song from Christina Aguilera's discography is the collaboration with Pink, Lil Kim and Mya. Katy feels much more famous, iconic and her music is more consumed too.

1 minute ago, Erreur2 La Nature said:

I feel like the only remembered song from Christina Aguilera's discography is the collaboration with Pink, Lil Kim and Mya. Katy feels much more famous, iconic and her music is more consumed too.

Katy can have hits on her own, she doesn't need featuring. 

Christina Aguilera for all. 

15 minutes ago, rebeltwat said:

Christina for all. Recency bias is just clouding this thread. I can't think of anyone who's cited Katy as an inspiration. No shade either I'm a fan. 

This. 

34 minutes ago, rebeltwat said:

Christina for all. Recency bias is just clouding this thread. I can't think of anyone who's cited Katy as an inspiration. No shade either I'm a fan. 

Doja Cat, Dua Lipa, Ava Max, Kim Petras, Troye Sivan, even Lorde mentioned Teenage Dream as an inspiration

6 minutes ago, louis58 said:

Doja Cat, Dua Lipa, Ava Max, Kim Petras, Troye Sivan, even Lorde mentioned Teenage Dream as an inspiration

Recently Halsey, Danna Paola, even Coldplay were inspired by Teenage Dream

Katy for all.  

TD was just a colossal pop era and remains iconic for the music, album cover, and videos. It definitely felt like an MPG was on top of the world.

 

Xtina never had that kind of era nor impact.

2 minutes ago, banterfly said:

It definitely felt like an MPG was on top of the world.

 

Xtina never had that kind of era nor impact.

Lie.

 

 Stripped was most definitely Christina top of the world era. She was everywhere & global. 

28 minutes ago, banterfly said:

TD was just a colossal pop era and remains iconic for the music, album cover, and videos. It definitely felt like an MPG was on top of the world.

 

Xtina never had that kind of era nor impact.

 

I might add Prism era in this as well, that era was huge, every single is a hits. 

 

55 minutes ago, Power love said:

Lie.

 

 Stripped was most definitely Christina top of the world era. She was everywhere & global. 

It was a moderate era. I loved Stripped, but the GP did not respond to it as much as they did with TD. All the singles from Stripped were minor to moderate hits whereas TD's singles were in the zeitgeist all over the world and literally were number 1 songs GLOBALLY. 

 

Stripped is nowhere near any of the true queen MPG eras (e.g. TD, 21, 1989, Fame).

2 hours ago, rebeltwat said:

Christina for all. Recency bias is just clouding this thread. I can't think of anyone who's cited Katy as an inspiration. No shade either I'm a fan. 

Ava Max, Halsey, Coldplay, Troye Sivan, YUNGBLUD, Doja Cat, Maren Morris, Jessie J, Dua Lipa have all listed Katy and/or her music as inspiration for their own work.

Edited June 20, 20233 yr by PopKills

1 hour ago, banterfly said:

It was a moderate era. I loved Stripped, but the GP did not respond to it as much as they did with TD. All the singles from Stripped were minor to moderate hits whereas TD's singles were in the zeitgeist all over the world and literally were number 1 songs GLOBALLY. 

 

Stripped is nowhere near any of the true queen MPG eras (e.g. TD, 21, 1989, Fame).

Nowhere in my statement did i compare Stripped to TD. So that ramdom tantrum you threw was pointless. 
 

That user said Christina never had her MPG era & that’s a straight lie. There is nothing moderate about that era either. 

Edited June 20, 20233 yr by Power love

Katy I fear.