16 minutes ago, Diocles said:

Chromatica sweetie..

 

... is losing the poll big time 

 

Chromatica: 3.1 million equivalent album units

Hard Candy: 6 million equivalent album units

 

They are not even close. 

Hard Candy was narrowly bigger. But whereas Chromatica was an artistic peak for Gaga, HC was the first and biggest artistic downfall of a mostly immaculate 25 years carrer that would follow into the next era.

Hard candy sweetie.. 4 Minutes alone shits all over Chromatica the album 

16 minutes ago, XtunaStan said:

Hard Candy was narrowly bigger. But whereas Chromatica was an artistic peak for Gaga, HC was the first and biggest artistic downfall of a mostly immaculate 25 years carrer that would follow into the next era.

Chromatica was not an artistic peak  What do you guys find in these cheap Kygo drops and dated default 90's house beats  songs like Alice are beneath even the likes of Ava Max 

4 Minutes is bigger than Chromatica's three singles combined 

1 hour ago, PopKills said:

4 Minutes is bigger than any Chromatica song and the S&S tour is the biggest of all time so

 

Hard Candy by far 

 

1 hour ago, Аshanti said:

Chromatica -- 2B Spotify streams

Hard Candy -- idk 300m?

The answer is clear.

Are you high?

madonna vs. whatever

1 hour ago, Аshanti said:

Chromatica -- 2B Spotify streams

Hard Candy -- idk 300m?

The answer is clear.

Yes, yes. Compare a 2008 album streaming #s with a 2020 one. The self embarrassment

 

Anyway, how much are they both CSPC? Also, the S&S is the biggest female tour of all time, so

Not Madonna's worst album being better than ANY Gaga album.

 

 

 

Hard Candy. 4 Minutes was massive and smashed even with very touch competition with younger hip hop artists. The other song only hit #1 because of no competition and a pandemic lock down. 

 

Plus Hard Candy had the biggest female tour of all time that has yet to be beat. 

Hard Candy was actually successful 

Why are people bringing up tour receipts?  Madonna could have released 45 minutes of white noise and her tour still would have smashed. It has a weak relationship with the success of Hard Candy.

4 hours ago, Аshanti said:

Chromatica -- 2B Spotify streams

Hard Candy -- idk 300m?

The answer is clear.

Not "the answer is clear..."  Hard Candy came out long before the streaming era  

 

OT: It's Hard Candy 

11 hours ago, Goaty said:

Why are people bringing up tour receipts?  Madonna could have released 45 minutes of white noise and her tour still would have smashed. It has a weak relationship with the success of Hard Candy.

Agreed, Hard Grammy demolishes without the tour anyway

Chromatica is bigger and better. 
 

 

14 hours ago, lovemehateme said:

Chromatica: 3.1 million equivalent album units

Hard Candy: 6 million equivalent album units

 

They are not even close. 

At this current pace it will take Chromatica 11 years to match actually  (it wont keep this pace so it will likely never happen)

4Μ  >>>> Chromatica

The Sticky&Sweet Tour is the biggest female tour of all time so…

Edited May 22, 20224 yr by Lament

15 hours ago, Pop said:

Chromatica 

 

#1 album ✅

#1 Single ✅

Top 5 single ✅

Grammy ✅

 

Hard Candy 

 

#1 album ✅

#1 Single ❌

Top 5 single ✅

Grammy ✅

 

As we can see, Chromatica was bigger.

 

14 hours ago, lovemehateme said:

Chromatica: 3.1 million equivalent album units

Hard Candy: 6 million equivalent album units

 

They are not even close. 

I am not surprised certain people are ignoring this receipt in black and white 

Hard Candy was the 11th best selling album of 2008 and 4 Minutes was a massive hit. We don't even need to mention the Sticky & Sweet Tour...

14 hours ago, Wildcat said:

Hard Candy - 6,052,000

ARTPOP - 4,528,000

Cheek To Cheek - 1,776,000

Joanne - 3,226,000

Chromatica - 3,109,000

 

Bonus: The Hard Candy tour was also a MASSIVE success 

 

Sticky & Sweet Tour - $519M

Monster Ball - $273M

Born This Way Ball - $213M

ARTPOP Ball - $83M

Joanne - $94M

Enigma - $79M