1 hour ago, mons†er said:

don't feel like making a thread so I'll just ask here.

 

you can only listen to one of these Beyonce albums for the rest of time the other album you can never hear ever again, which one are you choosing?

 

 

****….. I mean B’Day is when I became a stan like that album is a classic in every sense. The whole era was sublime and that tour…. She was unstoppable…

 

But Renaissance has become such a source of joy that it’s became the album for me. Like the fact that she was able  to think of this album and the masterful way she set it up is just everything… Subjectively it’s her best work to me.

 

B’Day is forever that girl but Rennie is my heart

 

 

Edited August 14, 20233 yr by suneclipse121

Not the entire section telling them to shut up

 

Apparently this was in Charlotte

Am I the only one who likes Best Thing I Never Had? 

6 minutes ago, QueenB said:

Am I the only one who likes Best Thing I Never Had? 

Only the #real ones stan this track

10 minutes ago, QueenB said:

Am I the only one who likes Best Thing I Never Had? 

Nope. That song helped me thru a nasty breakup, and from the bridge to the end is just *chefs kiss* 

15 minutes ago, QueenB said:

Am I the only one who likes Best Thing I Never Had? 

It's the best bridge she's ever sung, the prettiest she's ever looked in a video, and the best vocal stacking of her career. Who is hating on that song? I WILL block them immediately.

7 hours ago, Devin said:

Notice how IT struggles to crack 100k streams a day. Further proves how much of a skip it is.

 

Devin this is not it my friend.

 

1 hour ago, Fleahive said:

It's the best bridge she's ever sung, the prettiest she's ever looked in a video, and the best vocal stacking of her career. Who is hating on that song? I WILL block them immediately.

All of these are ******* LIES  you don’t even believe this ****

Every bridge on renny is better than BTINH and that’s just the most recent album

25 minutes ago, bijonse said:

All of these are ******* LIES  you don’t even believe this ****

Lyrically not the best but vocally the best and I saw a tiktok of a hundred students screaming the bridge at the top of their lungs like they at a trailer swiffer concert. What vocal stacking was better? What video did she look the best in? I'll wait! 

Edited August 14, 20233 yr by Fleahive

She just needs to get rid of the corny piano on Best Hit 4 Ever Had, replace it with some a cello or lower strings, maybe at the time it gag it down our throats consistently like she does “I Care” and all these tacky baguettes would be praising it.  

So when do we admit The Gift is actually the second best album she released? Or are we afraid of the truth?

 

5 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

So when do we admit The Gift is actually the second best album she released? Or are we afraid of the truth?

 

There's not enough Beyoncé on it to be considered an actual Beyoncé album 

18 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

There's not enough Beyoncé on it to be considered an actual Beyoncé album 

The songs that Bey did however kinda eat up her previous projects, dont you agree? Plus its actually 10 (11 if you include the FYWB remix) Beyoncé songs, which can be considered a full album if we're being honest

 

Edited August 14, 20233 yr by Kristie Kuwa

21 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

The songs that Bey did however kinda eat up her previous projects, dont you agree? Plus its actually 10 (11 if you include the FYWB remix) Beyoncé songs, which can be considered a full album if we're being honest

 

But she's barely featured on half of those. Idk to me this just feels like a collaborative project that she was a part of. It's hard to properly measure it against her other albums. 

Y'all need to cut the bs already

 

Without disrespecting them for how good they are, no one of her albums from 4 and backwards compare to the grandeur that are the big 3 (ST, Lems and Ren)

 

And the recent lil cute side projects harbor some of her best songs as well (Summer, Bigger, etc)

 

Edited August 14, 20233 yr by XtunaStan

Just now, AxelFox said:

But she's barely featured on half of those. Idk to me this just feels like a collaborative project that she was a part of. It's hard to properly measure it against her other albums. 

Bigger - Bey

FYWB - Bey

Mood4Eva - Bey + Jay (majority Bey)

Water - Bey + Pharell (majority Bey)

BSG - Bey + Wizkid (majority Bey)

Already - Bey + Shatta Wale 

Otherside - Bey

My Power - Bey + all the others

Spirit - Bey

Black Parade - Bey

FYWB Remix - Bey

 

5/11 collabs, 3 of these however predominantly Bey

 

Yes its her most collab-heavy project, but its still mostly solo Bey on her tracks.

 

 

 

 

 

59 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

So when do we admit The Gift is actually the second best album she released? Or are we afraid of the truth?

 

Are we still pretending that The Gift is the greatest thing ever happened? Enough. 

 

5 minutes ago, XtunaStan said:

Y'all need to cut the bs already

 

Without disrespecting them for how good they are, no one of her albums from 4 and backwards compare to the grandeur that are the big 3 (ST, Lems and Ren)

 

And the recent lil cute side projects harbor some of her best songs as well (Summer, Bigger, etc)

 

That could be only if you were allergic to R&B. 

 

So no, it's a flawed take. Both 4 and B'Day are splendid masterpieces. Even taking DC's catalogue into account, TWOTW as well as Destiny Fulfilled were showcasing Bey's outstanding creativity, artistry and genius at their time. 

 

All of those records are just as exquisite as Renaissance imo. 

14 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Are we still pretending that The Gift is the greatest thing ever happened? Enough. 

 

That could be only if you were allergic to R&B. 

 

So no, it's a flawed take. Both 4 and B'Day are splendid masterpieces. Even taking DC's catalogue into account, TWOTW as well as Destiny Fulfilled were showcasing Bey's outstanding creativity, artistry and genius at their time. 

 

All of those records are just as exquisite as Renaissance imo. 

Bigger + Otherside easily rank among her best ballads ever, FYWB, Water and Already are certified bops, BSG has one of her best messages ever, Black Parade is masterfully executed and crafted and a Grammy-awarded song for a reason (not every song has that), My Power is now iconic thanks to Ms Blue. 

I mean, whats there to discredit?

You mean to tell me Start Over can hold a candle against that or the very dated sounding I Miss You? 

 

 

Dont let numbers fool you, Ms Gift is THAT girl

Edited August 14, 20233 yr by Kristie Kuwa

18 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Bigger - Bey

FYWB - Bey

Mood4Eva - Bey + Jay (majority Bey)

Water - Bey + Pharell (majority Bey)

BSG - Bey + Wizkid (majority Bey)

Already - Bey + Shatta Wale 

Otherside - Bey

My Power - Bey + all the others

Spirit - Bey

Black Parade - Bey

FYWB Remix - Bey

 

5/11 collabs, 3 of these however predominantly Bey

 

Yes its her most collab-heavy project, but its still mostly solo Bey on her tracks.

 

 

 

 

 

She has like 10 seconds on Water and a shared chorus at the end, and she's basically a feature on songs like My Power. Not to mention some

of these are really short. 
 

Black Parade is a standalone song that she decided to just plaster on the deluxe edition. 

Idk this whole The Gift thing exists in its own separate realm outside of her studio albums for me. 

 

5 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Bigger + Otherside easily rank among her best ballads ever, FYWB, Water and Already are certified bops, BSG has one of her best messages ever, Black Parade is masterfully executed and crafted and a Grammy-awarded song for a reason (not every song has that), My Power is now iconic thanks to Ms Blue. 

I mean, whats there to discredit?

You mean to tell me Start Over can hold a candle against that or the very dated sounding I Miss You? 

 

 

Dont let numbers fool you, Ms Gift is THAT girl

I agree the gift eats up half her albums 

in particular IASF, debut and lemonade srry

 

let’s talk about lemonade actually being upper bottom half of her discog 

3 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

She has like 10 seconds on Water and a shared chorus at the end, and she's basically a feature on songs like My Power. Not to mention some

of these are really short. 
 

Black Parade is a standalone song that she decided to just plaster on the deluxe edition. 

Idk this whole The Gift thing exists in its own separate realm outside of her studio albums for me. 

 

So 7/11 doesnt belongs to ST, Schoolin Life doesnt belong to 4? WDYLM doesnt belongs to IASF?

 

Inchresting

 

 

Plus Black Parade was included because it basically aligned with the Black is King premiere

Renaissance 

B’Day

BEYONCÉ 

4

Black Is King

Lemonade

IASF

DIL

EVERYTHING IS LOVE

 

 

RENAISSANCE 

Lemonade

BEYONCÉ 

B’Day 

4

Dangerously in Love

The Gift 

Everything is Love 

I Am… Sasha Fierce 

Gift eats Lemonade for sure, with its 7-8 songs >>>  depressed monotone dialogue 

 

Bigger, Otherside are some of her greatest ballads. Proper ones she hadn’t delivered in quite a while. Already, Water easy slays. FYWB, BSG, easygoing music which are relatable. 
 

We count B’Days 11 songs as an album so why not the gift. 
 

The sis just has a horrible or genius way of naming albums. The best thing about lemonade is it’s title.