12 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

There has been!

Sis! Yes! I agree with you - she’s released five albums since then. Would you like to do a comprehensive rate, or just a singles rate of everything from Shake It Off - No Body, No Crime?

 

or you could do 2017 Makes The Woman:

 

Reputation

Witness

Woman

Laila’s Dream (Rapsody)

Out of the Storm (Waxahatchee)

 

Up to you!

 

 

I’d love to do a comprehensive thing honesty. It would be interesting to see how pre-1989 stacks against modern stuff! I can compile a list.

 

i’d prefer Taylor, I can start it anytime! I’ll just get started on graphics 

tons of fun surprises in store. get in: Miss Americana: The Taylor Swift Singles Rate is  LIVE

Promoting rates gives me a headache, but I need to do better. 

should I add OMD to my rate @Ace Reject

20 hours ago, madonnas said:

should I add OMD to my rate @Ace Reject

OMD? Why not?

1 hour ago, Ace Reject said:

OMD? Why not?

 

 

 

Song kinda sucks, but they are indeed icons.  

 

 

Photoshop designers - anybody willing to make images for my rate?

@madonnasthere could theoretically be a 1997 follow-up rate with Come On Over, Butterfly, Homogenic, Impossible Princess (to stand in for PJ) and maybe even The Velvet Rope as a kind of sequel to the 1995 rate.

 

Shania will get the last laugh yet!

 

10 minutes ago, Sanctuary said:

@madonnasthere could theoretically be a 1997 follow-up rate with Come On Over, Butterfly, Homogenic, Impossible Princess (to stand in for PJ) and maybe even The Velvet Rope as a kind of sequel to the 1995 rate.

 

Shania will get the last laugh yet!

 

I think that would be fun, and I would do it!  But I don't know how well Shania would fare tbh!  Still it's worth a try!

 

That being said I *am* going to be doing another rate right after my 1995 one.  A very different mood, too. 

Come On Over, Let's Talk About Love, Butterfly, The Velvet Rope would make for an EPIC 1997 Makes the Woman Rate lowkey 

20 hours ago, Sanctuary said:

@madonnasthere could theoretically be a 1997 follow-up rate with Come On Over, Butterfly, Homogenic, Impossible Princess (to stand in for PJ) and maybe even The Velvet Rope as a kind of sequel to the 1995 rate.

 

Shania will get the last laugh yet!

 

 

20 hours ago, madonnas said:

I think that would be fun, and I would do it!  But I don't know how well Shania would fare tbh!  Still it's worth a try!

 

That being said I *am* going to be doing another rate right after my 1995 one.  A very different mood, too. 

 

18 hours ago, naval23 said:

Come On Over, Let's Talk About Love, Butterfly, The Velvet Rope would make for an EPIC 1997 Makes the Woman Rate lowkey 

It's like you guys have been reading my mind!

 

So, one of the rates from Classic ATRL that I held closely to my heart (and so did others like @supaspaz and @minho) was the 97-98 Rebellion Rate - Butterfly, The Velvet Rope, Impossible Princess, and Ray of Light. We will be doing a REDO of that rate!

 

And the lineups for 1997 and 1998 Makes the Woman are below:

 

Baduizm

Supa Dupa Fly

Homogenic

Come on Over

Let's Talk About Love

 

AND

 

The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill

Car Wheels on a Gravel Road (Lucinda Williams)

My Love is Your Love

Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie

The Globe Sessions (Sheryl Crow)

 

Hope you'll all join! 

 

(1999 will probably feature Faith Hill, Fiona Apple, Macy Gray, Utada Hikaru, and... we'll see!)

That 1997 rate

the redo AND that second 97 line up look great!

4 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

 

 

It's like you guys have been reading my mind!

 

So, one of the rates from Classic ATRL that I held closely to my heart (and so did others like @supaspaz and @minho) was the 97-98 Rebellion Rate - Butterfly, The Velvet Rope, Impossible Princess, and Ray of Light. We will be doing a REDO of that rate!

 

And the lineups for 1997 and 1998 Makes the Woman are below:

 

Baduizm

Supa Dupa Fly

Homogenic

Come on Over

Let's Talk About Love

 

AND

 

The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill

Car Wheels on a Gravel Road (Lucinda Williams)

My Love is Your Love

Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie

The Globe Sessions (Sheryl Crow)

 

Hope you'll all join! 

 

(1999 will probably feature Faith Hill, Fiona Apple, Macy Gray, Utada Hikaru, and... we'll see!)

I am down to host these if nobody else doesn't, but I am totally okay doing the rate series of UK new wave - gay 80s synth pop - college rock radio singles.

5 minutes ago, madonnas said:

I am down to host these if nobody else doesn't, but I am totally okay doing the rate series of UK new wave - gay 80s synth pop - college rock radio singles.

As long as those are three separate rates, sure!

 

Also want to do 99-00 Girl Collectives: Sleater Kinney/The Chicks/Destiny's Child/TLC/All Saints/Sugababes. Who wants in?

Just now, Ace Reject said:

As long as those are three separate rates, sure!

 

Also want to do 99-00 Girl Collectives: Sleater Kinney/The Chicks/Destiny's Child/TLC/All Saints/Sugababes. Who wants in?

Yes, otherwise it would be a 200 song rate and I don't ever wanna do that again after the M rate drained my stamina.  I'll do it in that order (unless, ofc someone wants to take the gay rate or college rock rate from me, though I'd prefer to do the gay one myself, college rock is up for grabs!)

 

 

btw two things

1) Really sorry about the 1995 results, it's not my fault!  

2) can I start the UK rate this weekend?  I want to have time to write up a good OP

4 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

So, one of the rates from Classic ATRL that I held closely to my heart (and so did others like @supaspaz and @minho) was the 97-98 Rebellion Rate - Butterfly, The Velvet Rope, Impossible Princess, and Ray of Light. We will be doing a REDO of that rate!

 

And we should still redo the first ATRL rate ever, Femme Fatale vs. Born This Way vs. 4, when the 10th anniversary (lord, we're getting old) comes up later this year.

Just now, supaspaz said:

And we should still redo the first ATRL rate ever, Femme Fatale vs. Born This Way vs. 4, when the 10th anniversary (lord, we're getting old) comes up later this year.

Check your messages.

11 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Check your messages.

Did you send me a PM?

36 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

And we should still redo the first ATRL rate ever, Femme Fatale vs. Born This Way vs. 4, when the 10th anniversary (lord, we're getting old) comes up later this year.

Are we including TTT so Watch n Learn can get a cute quick top 10?

11 hours ago, madonnas said:

Are we including TTT so Watch n Learn can get a cute quick top 10?

My preference would be a straight redo, but I suppose it's not up to me.

Just now, supaspaz said:

My preference would be a straight redo, but I suppose it's not up to me.

Hopefully this time UP n Down can win! 

don't forget to include Spiceworld in the 1997 rates  

Given recent events, I think somebody might need to take over this rate (don't look at me though):

 

.

Hyperballad won 1995MTW