11 minutes ago, Madame X said:

i just know that hung up woiuld pass the other 2 madonna songs (and many other deserving songs) and ill have a meltdown! that didn't even happen in my rate!  and i promise (!!) i didn't rig it! 

but i can see it happening there for some reason. 

The thought of Hung Up above Into the Groove and Vogue... no maam. The way I can already see the comments of people being like "how did they only rank it at #42? I don't even know the other songs above it!" 

 

Yeah let's just replace Hung Up with Lady (Hear Me Tonight). Also Best of My Love is ab so LUTELY a top 10 contender too (though what ISN'T from that list)

21 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Hmm. What about a rate of the 100 best dance songs, as picked by Slant? Been DYING for someone to host it!

 

https://www.slantmagazine.com/music/100-greatest-dance-songs/

 

I just think an idiosyncratic and yet comprehensive list like this would be more fruitful! Different types of dance, by different artists across gender and ethnicity lines, throughout the decades!

 

FYC: French Kiss for top 20

No thanks.  This list does not look that cute.  I was hoping for something more accessible. 

On 4/14/2021 at 6:00 PM, Ace Reject said:

Hmm. What about a rate of the 100 best dance songs, as picked by Slant? Been DYING for someone to host it!

 

https://www.slantmagazine.com/music/100-greatest-dance-songs/

 

I just think an idiosyncratic and yet comprehensive list like this would be more fruitful! Different types of dance, by different artists across gender and ethnicity lines, throughout the decades!

 

FYC: French Kiss for top 20

Well pass it to me. I don't mind coming out of retirement to host it since the quality in this list for an atrl rate comes rarely. 

So can I get the 2010s dance rate since someone else is taking the Slant list rate? 

18 hours ago, Tom Vercetti said:

Well pass it to me. I don't mind coming out of retirement to host it since the quality in this list for an atrl rate comes rarely. 

That's my man! 

13 hours ago, jpow said:

So can I get the 2010s dance rate since someone else is taking the Slant list rate? 

Sure. DM a list you're working on; we'll edit it together - like we did for the rates @JoAddams and @naval23 hosted.

Can someone update the homepage? I  can't find ongoing rates

3 hours ago, BlueTimberwolf said:

Can someone update the homepage? I  can't find ongoing rates

First thing you see on the very first page! ONGOING RATES in bold and underlined status!

3 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

First thing you see on the very first page! ONGOING RATES in bold and underlined status!

ok sorry, I was looking 4 one of the rates and didn't see it so I assumed it hadn't been updated.  Must have just skipped over it

Someone should host a definitive Lemonade ranking in honor of the 5th anniversary!

5 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Someone should host a definitive Lemonade ranking in honor of the 5th anniversary!

Have we had an Anti ranking? That would be sickening. 

 

it's finally up 

9 hours ago, Auburn said:

 

it's finally up 

Even though I'm mad as hell at you right now, you know I'll get over this when I start scoring. 

 

But if Black Diamomd comes out shortly after this is over, we're gonna have words.

 

5 minutes ago, jdmc219 said:

Even though I'm mad as hell at you right now, you know I'll get over this when I start scoring. 

 

But if Black Diamomd comes out shortly after this is over, we're gonna have words.

 

it feels like Black Diamond is never coming at this point lol  

TLC's 30th anniversary is coming up soon. Be on the lookout. A discography rate is coming!

58 minutes ago, jdmc219 said:

TLC's 30th anniversary is coming up soon. Be on the lookout. A discography rate is coming!

What about a Pussycat Dolls discography rate including Nicole's (and her background dancers') solo stuffs? 

6 minutes ago, prézli said:

What about a Pussycat Dolls discography rate including Nicole's (and her background dancers') solo stuffs? 

No.

 

Please, no. 

 

Off of THAT - you know what I realized? Bruno Mars has never had an album of his rated. Why is that?

4 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

No.

 

Please, no. 

 

Off of THAT - you know what I realized? Bruno Mars has never had an album of his rated. Why is that?

 

Because ATRL hates successful male artists. 

On 4/24/2021 at 7:31 PM, naval23 said:

I think it's gonna be a hit. They have a pretty solid fan base here and they have the hits to back it up. I may need help recruiting.

I've been lurking on ATRL for a while, and I came across these Rates. They seem really fun so I'm interested in hosting some. I've hosted similar games on other forums so I know basically how to do it. I have a couple of ideas, just wondering if I'd be able to open one or not.

 

The ones I've made lists for and I'd like to host the most are 'The 1975 Singles Rate' (35 songs) and 'FKA twigs Discography Rate' (38 songs ) but I'm open to hosting other rates as well. If there are ideas for other rates in the works and you need a host, I'd be happy to see if I could help.

id also be interested in hosting:

taylor swift singles/discography rate

mitski discography rate

fleetwood mac singles rate

carly Rae Jepsen singles/discography rate

Coldplay singles/discography rate

Edited May 5, 20215 yr by greento

13 hours ago, greento said:

I've been lurking on ATRL for a while, and I came across these Rates. They seem really fun so I'm interested in hosting some. I've hosted similar games on other forums so I know basically how to do it. I have a couple of ideas, just wondering if I'd be able to open one or not.

 

The ones I've made lists for and I'd like to host the most are 'The 1975 Singles Rate' (35 songs) and 'FKA twigs Discography Rate' (38 songs ) but I'm open to hosting other rates as well. If there are ideas for other rates in the works and you need a host, I'd be happy to see if I could help.

id also be interested in hosting:

taylor swift singles/discography rate

mitski discography rate

fleetwood mac singles rate

carly Rae Jepsen singles/discography rate

Coldplay singles/discography rate

Welcome!

 

Have been baying for a current singles rate forever so - start The 1975!

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

Welcome!

 

Have been baying for a current singles rate forever so - start The 1975!

Thanks so much! I’ll get working on opening it as soon as possible. 
 

I don’t really know who I should tag, what would you suggest doing to find participants?

@Ace Reject Has there ever been a singles rate for Alicia Keys here or on OldTRL?

was reputation ever used in a rate? I'd like to use it somehow if not

 

I want to host something! it's been a long time since I hosted a rate and I want it to be a fun pop rate. or what about Taylor Swift singles?

 

I actually hosted the original Taylor Swift singles rate on old atrl where "Begin Again" won (rightfully!) but at that time it was up to and including the Red era, could be interesting to revisit?

On 5/6/2021 at 7:28 AM, jdmc219 said:

@Ace Reject Has there ever been a singles rate for Alicia Keys here or on OldTRL?

There has been!

14 hours ago, minho said:

was reputation ever used in a rate? I'd like to use it somehow if not

 

I want to host something! it's been a long time since I hosted a rate and I want it to be a fun pop rate. or what about Taylor Swift singles?

 

I actually hosted the original Taylor Swift singles rate on old atrl where "Begin Again" won (rightfully!) but at that time it was up to and including the Red era, could be interesting to revisit?

Sis! Yes! I agree with you - she’s released five albums since then. Would you like to do a comprehensive rate, or just a singles rate of everything from Shake It Off - No Body, No Crime?

 

or you could do 2017 Makes The Woman:

 

Reputation

Witness

Woman

Laila’s Dream (Rapsody)

Out of the Storm (Waxahatchee)

 

Up to you!