7672

Depends but for someone who grew up in the US, obviously engaged with popular culture and subsequently spending most of her life in the industry I just find it unlikely personally.

Her book left out the entire Femme Fatale era which many consider to be the most robotic, controlled and unexplained time of her career.

Legally Blonde when she goes to Harvard

I really wonder what trauma and prescription drugs have done to her memory sometimes. What are the chances she had never heard of Dollywood before? Really?

Spotify either. Pretty sure it's never been on streaming. I wonder if she disowns it? Her Spotify page pic seems to be from that era though.

Seeing that blue disc is mad nostalgic for me. This would have been my most played album in '08 easily. 18 years is so crazy.

Having no AOTY was the main go-to for her haters to discredit her artistry and success before 2025. She finally won it and that's when they got real mad, resorting to making up nonsense like "Jay-Z bought it for her", "she's MAGA" and "she's only popular in the US", blah blah blah. She also pissed off the Country community by daring to win their main Grammy and outsell their biggest stars with more authentically Country sounding music than most of them are able to profit off today. That demographic really came for her neck after that Best Country Album win and even still do almost 2 years later. Somehow it's fine for Taylor Swift from Pennsylvania and Post Malone from New York to pick Country up and put it down as they please though, just not for the (black) girl born and raised in Houston with Deep Southern (black) parents on both sides. Interesting. I'll let you be the judge on whether that's acceptable or not.

She can still produce standalone hits and sell-out shows but I don't see the GP caring much about a new Lady Gaga album in 2026 tbh

Nope Laptop wrists though yes

It's not as detrimental as it could be to Taylor who's crafted her image around it, but sectors of the mainstream have tried to delegitimise Bey for her number of co-writers since Lemonade. There are plenty of articles, news segments and comments from celebs like Diane Warren. It's always people with an agenda though.

Not trying to take away from your point (I agree) but side note Beyoncé does get crucified for having lots of other artists credited in her work. Taylor also uses other artists' work for her own but ensures terms are negotiated to the point where she has to credit the bare minimum of her collaborators. And yes, it is largely because songwriting is her only real USP besides her forced personality. She's not a strong singer and the only style of performance she can really handle is stripped back acoustic style. The production carries the rest which is why she only did interviews to promote TLOAS.

I get the vibe she felt like doing something to beef this album cycle up and 'era-fy' it a little more. No live performances/tour and comparatively weak reception (I'm not talking about the stats) would have made TLOAS a completely forgettable album in the grand scheme of things.

OT I think it's because she makes no active effort to perform that well in the first place. People like to laugh at Katy because she's clearly tried and failed multiple times to regain some of her previous momentum and success. We're cruel and we like to drag others for falling flat on their faces when they try. It's not as fun to do when someone wasn't trying in the first place though.

U just posted a bunch of irrelevant **** to try and flex Christina

Idk but I really think her general stature is a little overrated tbh. Obviously a legend in the Disney world but I wouldn't think of her as one outside of it, although others treat her like one. No real consistent run in terms of quality or success. Just odd flashes.