awesomepossum

Why is this the funniest thing I've ever seen

It's an Oscar, not a Grammy. The award is not recognizing a song for being a good song, it's recognizing a song for significantly contributing to a film. That's why Bond themes win so often, the songs are always prominently featured in the film and do a lot of heavy lifting to establish the entire emotional tone and direction of the film. None of Taylor's soundtrack add-ons have done that. If this isn't featured prominently in the film, it likely won't win or even be nominated. Unless they just feel like giving her an award because she's Taylor Swift.

WHO is listening to this

Your comment had no relation to anything I said.

What does same sex marriage have to do with the IOC disallowing trans women from competing as women?

Yes I have considered that and continue to understand that I may be wrong. As you may also be.

It's not apples and oranges. You were responding to the argument made by those who support the IOC's new policy - that trans people should compete in a separate league. No one on that side of the issue is saying the trans-inclusive league must be an exclusively trans league. That would be a strawman invented by you.

Well, for one example:

It's a sporting event specifically inclusive of the LGBTQIA community. You said there are so few trans women athletes that such a thing could not exist. Well it does exist. It's not exclusively for trans people as it includes the entire LGBTQIA community but it does exist.

It's justification for you to seriously consider that you might be missing something or not fully/accurately understanding the other side

Gay Games XII Valencia 2026Gay Games XII Valencia 2026:Valencia, host of the Gay Games 2026, a sporting and cultural event held every four years. Gay Games: united for equality, diversity and inclusion

They said they're testing for y chromosomes, not for an 'ideal woman' lol.

It's mostly irrelevant but it's not completely irrelevant. Doesn't the fact that increasing numbers of otherwise-progressive governments, political parties, individuals, and apolitical organizations like the IOC are disagreeing with you here? Like, in a certain sense you are right. Public opinion does not dictate reality. But shouldn't the change in public opinion and official opinion at least give you pause that maybe you're not really understanding the other side accurately? Have you ever considered the possibility that you might actually be wrong on this one? Or at least that you might be missing something? If you won't even consider the weaknesses in your own position then at a certain point the likelier scenario is that you are closed minded.

The IOC said they're testing for Y chromosomes, not testosterone levels. I'm old enough to remember when the idea of a separate trans or genderqueer sports category was not viewed as 'well meaning' at all. It was viewed as transphobic and the left would attack anyone taking that position. Even in your attempt to oppose the other side you are capitulating to their position.

Ask the IOC

Can they compete in the category of their gender assigned at birth?

The IOC says otherwise

A DUI is inexcusable, totally. But a lot of people get DUIs and they are not placed into a conservatorship.

Taylor Swift invented songwriting. Very sophisticated, Hilary!!

Am I the only one who doesn't like this music? Moscow Mule and Mojabi Ghost are his only songs that I like and he didn't even do them.

But they're living in the country in violation of US law, you just think there should be no such laws governing who can and can't live in any country. Framing it as though they are being 'persecuted' for their nationality is disingenuous. Undocumented immigrants are being deported because they have no right to be in the country. That applies to anyone living in any country without legal authorization anywhere in the world. If I moved to France, China, or any other country without legal authorization to do so, I would fully expect to be deported. And I would be deported. No one, regardless of nationality or ethnicity, has the right to live in a country without legal authorization.

So then your issue isn't with ICE or immigration enforcement, you don't think nation-states should exist. No borders, no countries, no citizenship anywhere. That's not the world we live in, and governments cannot function that way.

So you think every human being on Earth has the right to become an American citizen whenever they want just by entering the US with no application process or approval?

I think she will in 2028!