its kinda sad how they're wasting their talents with this shite music, like why not show of Lara's vocals for example 
Touch was elevator music and Gnarly is just horrible

they have to be joking, for sure

The ATRL smash thread must mean this will translate to streams right???!

Girls…. what are we doing?

 

 

1 hour ago, Dottie Hinkle said:

It's cute that you think they contributed anything to the creative process of this song. They copypasted everything from the demo including Alice's accent

Not sure how I inferred they contributed anything or not. The song was still tailored for them perfectly.

1 hour ago, Dottie Hinkle said:

This song is aggressively bad and is what happens when a company that is heavily corporate tries to ride alternative waves 

That part. I even like the Alice Longyu Gao style of the track but the lyrics are so…off.
 

They should have leaned into the competition/machine aspect of like coming up in popstar academy and made this kind of a "meta" song. Visuals ate though. 

I'n really curious about how Korea will respond after their music show run

They paid it in the video I kinda love sawry

They def just want to go viral/get people talking whether it's good or bad lol 

 

 

I dont like this

 

They shouldve stuck with the cute 2000s/elevator style stuff cause it made them stand out

why do I kinda not hate it anymore?

 

oh god 

 

I think the video makes it make sense

18 minutes ago, 50thStateofMind said:

 

They got the buzz that they wanted 

 

 

If the next single is better, they will be getting the last laugh

This is just absolutely garbage holy ****. It's like they asked ChatGPT to write a brat song for a girl group 

The clean version is enjoyable if you are into less mainstream music, but the one that got the video is way too vulgar for me.

Anyway, the song needed some kind of change at the end imo, not necessarily a bridge, but maybe an extra reworked chorus… Something like BLACKPINK's Pink Venom.

a bop idgaf 

31 minutes ago, magazine said:

why do I kinda not hate it anymore?

me after a couple spins bopping to the clean ver.

Hottie, hottie, this ain't just a hobby
I'm legit, I'm legit (Gnarly)

45 minutes ago, magazine said:

why do I kinda not hate it anymore?

 

oh god 

 

I think the video makes it make sense

It's camp I fear 

 

https://www.thefader.com/2025/04/30/katseye-gnarly-meaning-new-ep-2025-interview

 

EP confirmed...I think it'll be called Beautiful Chaos or something similar.

I'm still rooting for these girls but what the f*ck is this??  almost unlistenable to me. At least people are talking about them I guess..

"I think this EP, from the music to the visuals, the dancing, the styling (...) we really were involved in a lot of the aspects of the EP."

"So the EP is inspired off of that. It's also darker, it's edgier, it feels like we're growing up and maturing."

 

7 hours ago, professor2000 said:

You know what this reminds me of… when Girlicious dropped "Stupid ****" and I just sat there in silence like wth was that?  
 

(yes, I know that's a old ass reference lol…but both times I was genuinely shocked and how bad of a song was released by a group I was otherwise excited for). 
 

Both almost felt like a parody or something 

Stupid **** was still trash but also genuinely 10x better than whatever this is though. 

Omg the decline....