rate "Florence + The Machine's Official Discography" ATRL Megarate - CONCLUDED

[Florence Belch]

Welcome to the first "Florence + The Machine's Official Discography" ATRL Megarate!

 

 

I thank you all for the overwhelmingly positive response in the F+TM thread of some days ago, and @Ace Reject for approving the megarate!

At the following link you'll find the form where to submit your ballots:

 

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScI8wAyhvzSdp09au0YcgKXedlbSyf-ksPjzr9eAvPbkafajw/viewform

 

These are the following rules:

1. Give a rate from 1-10 for each track on the form.

2. Only decimals of 0.1 are allowed. Example: 7.2, 8.4, ..., not 7.25, 6.111, and so on.

3. You can rate up to five 11s, and up to five 0s.

BONUS: You can give ONLY one 12, and one -1 (beware of exposing your bad taste, my fellow Tuscan Machines).

4. I can see you with my Third Eye: NO TROLLING OR SABOTAGING RATES! Otherwise you'll be disqualified. Example: give an album all 10s, 4s, 0s, ...

5. In the optional "Overall thoughts" section under each album's cover, you are Free.mp3 to write whatever you want about that said album: be it your thoughts about a single track, about the memories you hold for the album, and so on. This is to encourage conversation once the results are out, thus making the megarate more entertaining!

6. Once you've submitted your ballot, to ensure it has transferred correctly onto the Google sheet, please contact me via thread or DM. You can edit your ballot whenever you want: remember then to submit it again (respect the deadline though!).

7. Of course, do not post your ballots on this thread.

 

SUBMISSION DEADLINE: MARCH 17, 2025. The tours, live albums, and overall album scores will be revealed on Monday 24th. The overall scores for the individual songs will be revealed starting from Thursday 27th.

 

Edited Monday at 11:40 AM by Florence Belch

[Florence Belch]

SONGLIST:

 

Spoiler

LUNGS

1. Dog Days Are Over

2. Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up)

3. I'm Not Calling Tou A Liar

4. Howl

5. Kiss With A Fist

6. Girl With An Eye

7. Drumming Song

8. Between Two Lungs

9. Cosmic Love

10. My Boy Builds Coffin

11. Hurricane Drunk

12. Blinding

13. You've Got The Love

14. Swimming

15. Heavy In Your Arms

16. Ghosts

17. Falling

18. Are You Hurting The One You Love?

19. Bird Song

20. Hospital Beds

21. Hardest Of Hearts

22. Addicted To Love

 

CEREMONIALS

1. Only If For A Night

2. Shake It Out

3. What The Water Gave Me

4 Never Let Me Go

5. Breaking Down

6. Lover To Lover

7. No Light, No Light

8. Seven Devils

9. Heartlines

10. Spectrum

11. All This And Heaven Too

12. Leave My Body

13. Remain Nameless

14. Strangeness & Charm

15. Bedroom Hymns

16. What The Water Gave Me (Demo)

17. Landscape

 

HOW BIG, HOW BLUE, HOW BEAUTIFUL

1. Ship To Wreck

2. What Kind Of Man

3. How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful

4. Queen Of Peace

5. Various Storms & Saints

6. Delilah

7. Long & Lost

8. Caught

9. Third Eye

10. St. Jude

11. Mother

12. Hiding

13. Make Up Your Mind

14. Which Witch

15. As Far As I Could Get

16. Pure Feeling

17. Conductor

 

FINAL FANTASY XV EP

1. Too Much Is Never Enough

2. Stand By Me

3. I Will Be

 

HIGH AS HOPE

1. June

2. Hunger

3. South London Forever

4. Big God

5. Sly Full Of Song

6. Grace

7. Patricia

8. 100 Years

9. The End Of Love

10. No Choir

 

DANCE FEVER

1. King

2. Free

3. Choreomania

4. Back In Town

5. Girls Against God

6. Dream Girl Evil

7. Prayer Factory

8. Cassandra

9. Heaven Is Here

10. Daffodil

11. My Love

12. Restraint

13. The Bomb

14. Mermaids

15. Morning Elvis

16. Search And Destroy

17. King (Poem Version)

18. Cassandra (Poem Version)

19. My Love (Poem Version)

 

OTHER SONGS + FEATURINGS

1. You've Got The Dirtee Love (with Dizzee Rascal)

2. Baptize

3. Breath Of Life

4. Spectrum (Say My Name) - Calvin Harris Remix

5. Call Me Cruella

6. Cornflake Girl

7. Covered in Blood (WTF)

8. Donkey Kosh / Florrible and Misrabella

8. Flakes

10. Halloween

11. Halo

12. Haunted House

13. Honey

14. I Love You All The Time

15. Jenny Of Oldstones

16. Just A Girl

17. Light Of Love

18. Moderation

19. My Best Dress

20. Not Fade Away

21. Over The Love

22. Postcards From Italy

23. Take Care

24. Tantalus

25. Throwing Bricks

26. Tiny Dancer

27. Where Are U Now

28. White Cliffs Of Dover

29. Wish That You Were Here

30. Ye Old Hope (Tear Out My Tongue)

31. David Byrne, Fatboy Slim - Here Lies Love (ft Florence Welch)

32. Jools Holland, Florence Welch - My Baby Just Cares For Me

33. Calvin Harris - Sweet Nothing (ft. Florence Welch)

34. ASAP Rocky - I Come Apart (ft. Florence Welch)

35. Felix White - Midnight (ft. Florence Welch)

36. Rufus Wainwright - When In Disgrace With Fortune And Men's Eyes (ft. Florence Welch)

37. Lady Gaga - Hey Girl (ft. Florence Welch)

38. The Rolling Stones - Wild Horses (ft. Florence Welch)

39. Taylor Swift - Florida!!! (ft. Florence + The Machine)

 

RESULTS:

 

Spoiler

The overall album scores are the following ones:

 

1. How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful: 8.251 (8.437 if we consider just the STW-M run)

2. Ceremonials: 7.961 (8.360 if we consider just the OIFAN-LMB run)

3. High As Hope: 7.595

4. Lungs: 7.145 (7.627 if we consider just the DDAO-YGTL run, making it 3rd)

5. Final Fantasy XV EP: 6.816

6. Dance Fever: 6.612 (7.195 if we consider just the K-ME run, making it 5th)

7. Other Songs Section: 5.637 (Unreleased: 5.317; Featurings: 5.432; Others: 6.294)

 

The overall scores for the individual songs are the following ones: 

127. King (Poem Version): 3.263
126. Cassandra (Poem Version): 3.556
125. My Love (Poem Version): 3.684
124. Halo: 3.706
123. You've Got The Dirtee Love (with Dizzee Rascal): 4.176
122. Not Fade Away: 4.206
121. Jools Holland, Florence Welch - My Baby Just Cares For Me: 4.571
120. Ye Old Hope (Tear Out My Tongue): 4.600
119. Where Are U Now: 4.606
118. David Byrne, Fatboy Slim - Here Lies Love (ft. Florence Welch): 4.621
117. Flakes: 4.694
116. Throwing Bricks: 4.750
115. Donkey Kosh / Florrible and Misrabella: 4.765
114. My Best Dress: 4.778
113. White Cliffs Of Dover: 4.781
112. Felix White - Midnight (ft. Florence Welch): 5.033
111. The Rolling Stones - Wild Horses (ft. Florence Welch): 5.086
110. Postcards From Italy: 5.091
109. Rufus Wainwright - When In Disgrace With Fortune And Men's Eyes (ft. Florence Welch): 5.135
108. Hospital Beds: 5.139
106. ASAP Rocky - I Come Apart (ft. Florence Welch): 5.286
107. Halloween: 5.286
105. Ghosts: 5.333
104. Search And Destroy: 5.438
103. Restraint: 5.450
102. Jenny Of Oldstones: 5.467
101. Back In Town: 5.469
100. Taylor Swift - Florida!!! (ft. Florence & The Machine): 5.484
99. Cornflake Girl: 5.515
98. Are You Hurting The One You Love?: 5.600
97. I Love You All The Time: 5.606
96. Prayer Factory: 5.667
95. Baptize: 5.703
94. Kiss With A Fist: 5.743
93. Take Care: 5.758
92. Tantalus: 5.824
91. Tiny Dancer: 5.879
90. I Will Be: 5.912
89. Call Me Cruella: 5.985
88. Girl With An Eye: 6.000
87. Addicted To Love: 6.000
86. Just A Girl: 6.029
85. Haunted House: 6.047
84. Lady Gaga - Hey Girl (ft. Florence Welch): 6.171
83. Girls Against God: 6.206
82. Covered In Blood (WTF): 6.243
81. Grace: 6.348
80. Spectrum (Say My Name) - Calvin Harris Remix: 6.421
79. What The Water Gave Me (Demo): 6.429
78. I'm Not Calling You A Liar: 6.455
77. Mermaids: 6.655
76. Honey: 6.667

75: Hurricane Drunk: 6.727
74: Lover To Lover: 6.733
73: Bird Song: 6.781
72: My Boy Builds Coffins: 6.848
71: Remain Nameless: 6.909
70: 100 Years: 6.914
69: Stand By Me: 6.946
68: Landscape: 6.956
67: Falling: 6.968
66: Morning Elvis: 6.968
65: Patricia: 7.000
64: Swimming: 7.063
63: Light Of Love: 7.088
62: Sky Full Of Song: 7.167
61: Conductor: 7.177
60: Heaven Is Here: 7.189
59: Caught: 7.207
58: Hardest Of Hearts: 7.250
57: Bedroom Hymns: 7.276
56: Heartlines: 7.281
55: Between Two Lungs: 7.417
54: June: 7.438
53: Strangeness & Charm: 7.453
52: Blinding: 7.530
51: King: 7.531 

50: You've Got The Love: 7.576
49: Wish That You Were Here: 7.583
48: Too Much Is Never Enough: 7.591
47: Breath Of Life: 7.636
46: No Choir: 7.647
45: The Bomb: 7.656
44: Third Eye: 7.667
43: Long & Lost: 7.677
42: Hiding: 7.727
41: Calvin Harris - Sweet Nothing (ft. Florence Welch): 7.771
40: Moderation: 7.806
39: Breaking Down: 7.809
38: Leave My Body: 7.864
37: Make Up Your Mind: 7.897
36: Heavy In Your Arms: 7.900
35: South London Forever: 7.956
34: Over The Love: 7.970
33: Pure Feeling: 8.061
32: All This And Heaven Too: 8.061
31: Ship To Wreck: 8.103
30: Choreomania: 8.133
29: As Far As I Could Get: 8.233
28: Big God: 8.250
27: Seven Devils: 8.265
26: Dream Girl Evil: 8.273

25. St. Jude: 8.338
24. Daffodil: 8.345
23. Which Witch: 8.368
22. The End Of Love: 8.406
21. Mother: 8.414
20. Drumming Song: 8.419
19. Delilah: 8.500
18. Cassandra: 8.543
17. Shake It Out: 8.545
16. Free: 8.547
15. Spectrum: 8.679
14. Howl: 8.710
13. Various Storms & Saints: 8.710
12. My Love: 8.800
11. Only If For A Night: 8.814
10. Hunger: 8.824
9. Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up): 8.933
8. Dog Days Are Over: 9.059
7. No Light, No Light: 9.197
6. What Kind Of Man: 9.282
5. Queen Of Peace: 9.410
4. Never Let Me Go: 9.485
3. How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful: 9.500

2. What The Water Gave Me: 9.588

1. Cosmic Love: 9.737

 

Edited March 30 by Florence Belch

[Florence Belch]

PARTECIPANTS:

 

Spoiler

1. Florence Belch

2. @Schami66

3. @khalyan

4. @Album Leak

5. @Torment

6. @HonourableVomit

7. @PMM

8. @Giovanni

9. @Suka Bicza

10. @PaloSanto

11. @AshleyLovescats887

12. @Velvet Night

13. @Uncatena

14. @yyy

15. @ahauntingnearu

16. @killer_rose

17. @Khal

18. @1989

19. @creativity.

20. @Mikeymoonshine

21. @amamoy

22. @VeniceBeach

23. @BowWow

24. @BlackoutZone

25. @Why

26. @Mr. Peanutbutter

27. @Curaga

28. @gagacasanova

29. @Supervillain

30. @Heldenzeit

31. @Paddy

32. @MidnightsAtPeace

33. @stjosephprey4us

34. @Achilles.

35. @Parachutes

36. @sparrowblue

37. @makeawish

38. @Ponzi

39. @Ewan Chaos

40. @Taylor fanboy

41. @jacklovesyou1

42. @CBC

43. @GentleDance

44. @crymelanie

45. @Suilen

 

Edited March 23 by Florence Belch

[Florence Belch]

TAGLIST:

 

Spoiler

@Schami66 @khalyan @Album Leak @Torment @HonourableVomit @PMM @Giovanni @Suka Bicza @PaloSanto @AshleyLovescats887 @Velvet Night @Uncatena @yyy @ahauntingnearu @killer_rose @Khal @1989 @creativity. @Mikeymoonshine @amamoy @VeniceBeach @BowWow @BlackoutZone @Why @Mr. Peanutbutter @Curaga @gagacasanova @Supervillain @Heldenzeit @Paddy @MidnightsAtPeace @stjosephprey4us @Achilles. @Parachutes @sparrowblue @makeawish @Ponzi @Ewan Chaos @Taylor fanboy @jacklovesyou1 @CBC @GentleDance @crymelanie @Suilen @hoax @greento @BrokenMachine @LOTF @anastaciabby

 

Feel free to tell me if you want to get added or removed from the taglist!

Edited March 28 by Florence Belch

[creativity.]

I will def do this, pls add me to taglist

[Uncatena]

Oh yay this is gonna be fun.

 

For your 11 pt. consideration:

 

 

 

[Velvet Night]

I'll absolutely participate! Thank you so much for your effort!
 

[PMM]

will be doing this. not because I want to but because Florence Belch called me (tagged me) 

and thank the f god for the google rate one. Will send my votes this weekend. Thanks Florence 

edit: i know my fav song will be in the bottom 10 
 

Edited November 28, 2024 by PMM

[Florence Belch]

1 minute ago, Uncatena said:

Oh yay this is gonna be fun.

 

For your 11 pt. consideration:

 

 

 

You may be serving excellent TASTE, I'll have to be extra-careful with these 11s 

 

[GraceRandolph]

I'll be doing this

 

[CBC]

I will be answering her call

 

[Florence Belch]

1 minute ago, PMM said:

will be doing this. no because I want to but because Florence Belch called me (tagged me) 

and thank the f god for the google rate one. Will send my votes this weekend. Thanks Florence 

edit: i know my fav song will be in the bottom 10 
 

Ooooh, I can't wait to see which one is your favorite, my fellow Tuscan Machine, so I can drag them all if anyone makes it bomb

 

 

Spoiler

I just know which songs will be receiving the most -1s, and the thought already makes me cackle hard sgsgdf

 

 

[AshleyLovescats887]

I am answering the phone  

 

 

p.s: if 'Choreomania' or 'Donkey Kosh' aren't in the top 10 y'all are tasteless

[Mr. Peanutbutter]

I'm in 

[Antisocialites]

might be a good time to finally get through Dance Fever

 

[RideOrDie]

might be a good time to finally get through Lungs

 

Edited November 28, 2024 by RideOrDie

[Torment]

I'm definitely in.  

[makeawish]

provisionally i'm in but i'm not thinking about it til january, i'm already doing five other rates already lol

[JoeAg]

ahhh so down! thanks for thinking of me 

[MidnightsAtPeace]

I will definitely participate to make sure Which Witch is getting that no.1 placement 

[BlackoutZone]

I haven't seen the list yet, but yall better NOT sleep on her bonus tracks classics:

 

[Gagaast]

I haven't heard most songs and albums. Perfect opportunity for me to discover the discography. 

I am in.

[killer_rose]

Ceremonials and HBHBHB tracks coming for blood.

I am calling FBI if I see You've Got The Snore in top 10/20.

[CBC]

46 minutes ago, Antisocialites said:

might be a good time to finally get through Dance Fever

 

You should, the albums has amazing songs like Daffodil, Cassandra and Dream Evil Girl are some highlights!

 

44 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

might be a good time to finally get through Lungs

 

Exactly, Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up), Drumming Song, Drumming Song, Kiss With A Fist are super underrated!

 

 

 

btw op, can we get a list of all the songs we're rating please? This messy queen likes to release 283713 versions of the same album

[Mikeymoonshine]

I've not done one of these before but I LOVE Florence so I'm in.