Dancing, stage presence, vocals, songwriting, better music? Who's more talented between the two shriekstresses?

 

 

Camila.

 

Camila is first and foremost a singer-songwriter , it's a god given talent. 

 

Tate's thing is something different. 

Tate by far

They both have "distinct" voices, let's just say that 

Both very talented shriekstresses. Camila is an excellent actress and Tate is an excellent dancer sooo about equal.

Went into the thread thinking Tate but I think Camila is an all-rounder.

Camila was always a very strong performer and had a voice that could carry a song.  Tate seems to have a ways to go still. 

camila actually sings, at least 

camila with ease, but racistrl will vote for tate mcrally

Tate only has the dancing going on for her 

Tate voice isn’t as annoying as Camila. She can dance well unlike Camila who dancings like those inflatable balloon in front of a car dealership. also she doesn’t do god awful sloppy runs like Camila does 

Camila is a full package. 

3 minutes ago, Mtjjproducer said:

Tate voice isn’t as annoying as Camila. She can dance well unlike Camila who dancings like those inflatable balloon in front of a car dealership. also she doesn’t do god awful sloppy runs like Camila does 

Tate x

Camila. 

Tate may not be the best vocalist (but neither is Camila), but she has way better and more recognisable music and overall makes her songs work in a way that Camila simply can't. 

 

Also, You is the best song out of both their entire discographies, so that's that. Mostly because of Troye, admittedly, but their voices sound nice together. 

 

Edited November 19, 20232 yr by SlowGinFizzzz

They're both not amazing but Camila is better. I mean she has the 5H songs, Havana, my oh my, señorita, never be the same. And she is a good performer 

Now wait a minute.. not only do they sound alike but they kinda look alike too. Was Camila cloned wtf

Mid off

1 hour ago, Mtjjproducer said:

She can dance well unlike Camila who dancings like those inflatable balloon in front of a car dealership.

Camilla for all but dancing.

Camila by far .

Edited November 19, 20232 yr by jdanton2

Maybe Camila

both have similar stage presence 

the fact that Camila is still being compared to lol

 

both are good really

 

Camila started stronger tho, Tate should take notes how to sustain such hype and not crash and burn

Camila has Liar.