1 hour ago, AxelFox said:

No Heidi no comeback.

 

Most of the public is not familiar with Siobhan in order for them to rely on the nostalgia card for anything more than a 'oh I remember them' moment. 

the 1 member ppl associate w Sugababes most is Mutya

 

when Mutya left is when Sugababes start flopping - About You Now was the exception

Honestly ....

• if Heidi & Amelle join a tour (NEVER SAY NEVER)
• they make a TV doc-series that airs on BBC / ITV 
• and they have debut performance singing a medley of all their hits on some popular TV shows (Strictly Come Dancing ? The Voice ? X Factor - are these shows still popular in UK?)

I could see them building massive hype for a tour like what PCD did with React

2 minutes ago, reymiu said:

Honestly ....

• if Heidi & Amelle join a tour (NEVER SAY NEVER)
• they make a TV doc-series that airs on BBC / ITV 
• and they have debut performance singing a medley of all their hits on some popular TV shows (Strictly Come Dancing ? The Voice ? X Factor - are these shows still popular in UK?)

I could see them building massive hype for a tour like what PCD did with React

Keisha and Amelle hate each other. Last I heard, Keisha had her blocked on all social media platforms. There's no chance

3 minutes ago, Kanye West said:

Keisha and Amelle hate each other. Last I heard, Keisha had her blocked on all social media platforms. There's no chance

https://www.officialcharts.com/chart-news/sugababes-keisha-buchanan-reveals-how-heidi-range-and-amelle-berrabah-really-feel-about-original-line-up-reunion-with-mutya-buena-and-siobhan-donaghy__36832/

 

Didnt Keisha say that Amelle sent good luck wish to the 3 girls or smth like that

If All Saints can, the Sugababes can. If you mean in terms of getting a hit single then no, but I could see them having a successful album in the UK charts. The 30+ year old brit gays love them, and we all see how that demographic props up Kylie. 

 

Also the people mentioning Heidi seem uneducated cause the only draw Heidi would have would be with touring, but as we've seen they're touring fine without her. All an album needs to do is appease the current Sugababes fans, who overall like Siobhan more than Heidi. 

Edited April 24, 20233 yr by Spark

4 minutes ago, reymiu said:

https://www.officialcharts.com/chart-news/sugababes-keisha-buchanan-reveals-how-heidi-range-and-amelle-berrabah-really-feel-about-original-line-up-reunion-with-mutya-buena-and-siobhan-donaghy__36832/

 

Didnt Keisha say that Amelle sent good luck wish to the 3 girls or smth like that

Keisha clarified she heard from a "mutual acquaintance" about Amelle wishing them well which is probably a fan messaging them both. Keisha attempted to make amends with Amelle in 2018 by inviting her to the movies. Amelle called it "awkward" and "weird" in an interview following this. Amelle is also on record in February 2019 talking about how she still owned the Sugababes name over Keisha. In 2020 Amelle started posting throwback pictures to the Change promo campaign and both Keisha and Mutya made references to a "clout chaser" this same time. There are still issues between Keisha and Amelle

6 minutes ago, Kanye West said:

Keisha clarified she heard from a "mutual acquaintance" about Amelle wishing them well which is probably a fan messaging them both. Keisha attempted to make amends with Amelle in 2018 by inviting her to the movies. Amelle called it "awkward" and "weird" in an interview following this. Amelle is also on record in February 2019 talking about how she still owned the Sugababes name over Keisha. In 2020 Amelle started posting throwback pictures to the Change promo campaign and both Keisha and Mutya made references to a "clout chaser" this same time. There are still issues between Keisha and Amelle

which is why a BBC/ ITV docu-TV series is a MUST for the big comeback

If they release good music and promote? Yes. 
 

Europe is less ageist than the US. 

5 hours ago, Kanye West said:

In my opinion, The Lost Tapes could've already performed numbers like those groups you had mentioned but they handled it awfully. I agree with your points but they seem incapable

Yeah it wasn’t really handled like an album release, but I think it was just released as a gift to fans who had waited so long for it. An album released in the traditional way would definitely do better.

 

They should sign with BMG, they seem to know and understand these types of acts perfectly.

3 hours ago, reymiu said:

I could see them building massive hype for a tour like what PCD did with React

They don’t need to though, they are already selling out their tours, playing huge festivals, sold out The O2 Arena for later this year. Which is why that delusional user saying they need Heidi for success is so funny

They probably won’t see huge commercial success again but I hope they continue to make and release new music because I love their voices together