9 minutes ago, Xalric said:

Mamamoo is 3rd gen but are the same age than SNSD.

idk its just weird, they're closer to mamamoo's ages than hyein and eunchae so

5 hours ago, CBC said:

how? they release an album every 2 weeks aren't people tired? 

 some people are stuck in 2018 

 

age doesn’t matter. Yeji and Karina are almost as old as Tzuyu and Chaeyoung 

Edited March 8, 20233 yr by Dialamba

9 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

idk its just weird, they're closer to mamamoo's ages than hyein and eunchae so

Bella, a soloist, just debuted last week, after 10 years of training, she's 29 years old.

 

 

It's just some people debut later in life.

 

3 minutes ago, Xalric said:

Bella, a soloist, just debuted last week, after 10 years of training, she's 29 years old.

 

 

It's just some people debut later in life.

 

i'm not trying it with their ages or calling them a hag. I usually call our pop girls hags here for the kiis but all of them are still young including the snsd hags

 

I mean, gidle's music is very 3rd gen too if that makes sense idk they're just very 3rd gen overall to me but maybe that's just me

1. WANNABE- 287,697,901

2. LOVE DIVE- 243,155,282

3. Hype Boy- 242,142,753

4. God's Menu- 240,917,921

5. FEVER- 224,748,127

6. Ditto- 219,755,525

7. ELEVEN- 212,215,482

8. DALLA DALLA- 206m

9. ANTIFRAGILE- 191,351,020

10. LOCO- 189,882,940 

 

both after like and OMG are coming to kick two itzy songs out they need to serve a loco/wannabe smash hit next comeback please @JYP

Irene is vocally better than JY and it is a fact though?

not to mention dancing, SP and visual!

 

but anyways I will still support TWICE against those US acts on billboard 200 

49 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

do people seriously consider Girdle as 4th gen? 

one of the members literally trained and almost debuted with crackstink and they're the same age range with bp and twice 

they also feel like they've been here as long as twice and bp like be fr

 

the generations really don’t make sense anymore

 

theyre 100% arbitrary and used by stans to filter out competition. If girdle’s stats could stand up to the rest of the 3rd gen then their stans would be clamouring for them to be 3rd gen

 

this thread is the house that Jeongyeon built. that user has some nerve coming in here like that 

 

8 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

i'm not trying it with their ages or calling them a hag. I usually call our pop girls hags here for the kiis but all of them are still young including the snsd hags

 

I mean, gidle's music is very 3rd gen too if that makes sense idk they're just very 3rd gen overall to me but maybe that's just me

Yeah I-DLE said multiple times how much they love and respect Gen2 and  Gen3, so it's natural how they have the same schtick than them.

 

Soyeon was a Hottest (2PM fan, she even attended several of their concerts and fans signing), Miyeon was a BlackJack, Bom bias, Yuqi was a BlackJack, Daraling, Shuhua was a 4nia (4minute), Soojin was a A-ing (Hyuna), and Minnie a multi Stan.

2 minutes ago, Save-Me-Oprah said:

the generations really don’t make sense anymore

 

theyre 100% arbitrary and used by stans to filter out competition. If girdle’s stats could stand up to the rest of the 3rd gen then their stans would be clamouring for them to be 3rd gen

 

that said I guess 2018-present is 3rd gen because nobody of note debuted for the entirety of 2017

 

I can make the bet that in a couple of year we will battle if NJ is 4 or 5th generation cause they are creating a whole new shift in the industry.

19 minutes ago, newaespa said:

Irene is vocally better than JY and it is a fact though?

not to mention dancing, SP and visual!

 

but anyways I will still support TWICE against those US acts on billboard 200 

how is irene better vocally than jeongyeon? that girl can't even support and is weak in all her registers. I can understand if you prefer her vocal tone over jeongyeon but to flat out said she's better than jeongyeon???

4 minutes ago, Xalric said:

I can make the bet that in a couple of year we will battle if NJ is 4 or 5th generation cause they are creating a whole new shift in the industry.

kinda agree I still don't think we're in 5th gen but I think in a few years we could see how newjeans is kinda the start of 5th gen idk

8 minutes ago, Xalric said:

I can make the bet that in a couple of year we will battle if NJ is 4 or 5th generation cause they are creating a whole new shift in the industry.

 

3 minutes ago, jeanie said:

kinda agree I still don't think we're in 5th gen but I think in a few years we could see how newjeans is kinda the start of 5th gen idk

imo newjeans and babymonster are both 5th gen

they're only grouped with 4th gen now since they're literally the first 2 of 5th gen 

1 hour ago, MonsterNavy said:

@ me next time hoe

 

okay lemme listen to twice's discography now from start to end and i'll get back at you with my fair and not ignorant opinion brb

 

As if you really are going to

if we’re being real, twice should been hitting 1M and 2M first

7 minutes ago, jeanie said:

how is irene better vocally than jeongyeon? that girl can't even support and is weak in all her registers. I can understand if you prefer her vocal tone over jeongyeon but to flat out said she's better than jeongyeon???

Not Irene 

 

im seriously starting to have concerns over people in here I swear

1 hour ago, Eternium said:

TWOCE’s aces are Nayeon, Sana, Momo and Tzuyu, in that order. Every now and again, Chaeyoung can serve.

 

There is never a world where Jeongyeon has added anything or served. Just because she’s their most stable singer doesn’t make her a solid addition - she’s not even Irene level vocally.

When multiple people say you have the worst takes in this thread, now I understand there’s some truth to it

 

4 minutes ago, thirdward said:

if we’re being real, twice should been hitting 1M and 2M first

Are they hitting 2M this time? I don’t wanna set my girlies up but that preorder number is promising tbh

Just now, Witnessed ET said:

Are they hitting 2M this time? I don’t wanna set my girlies up but that preorder number is promising tbh

if jyp can get itzy to 1M

21 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Not Irene 

 

im seriously starting to have concerns over people in here I swear

Irene can actually serve.
 

Jeongyeon and Jihyo always get the worst choruses and take the song down a notch. Compare Sana/Nayeon on Feel Special’s first chorus versus Jeongyeon/Jihyo on the second chorus - the girls just don’t add much due to their lackluster tones  

 

At least Jihyo will serve energy. Jeongyeon feels like token stanning

Only on ATRL Irene is hyped as talented. She doesn’t excel in anything.  And she’s mainly popular for her visuals which isn’t a bad thing but you don’t see us acting as if Tzuyu is the most talented idol ever 

Edited March 8, 20233 yr by Dialamba

7 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Irene can actually serve.
 

Jeongyeon and Jihyo always get the worst choruses and take the song down a notch. Compare Sana/Nayeon on Feel Special’s first chorus versus Jeongyeon/Jihyo on the second chorus - the girls just don’t add much due to their lackluster tones  

 

At least Jihyo will serve energy. Jeongyeon feels like token stanning

Not the Feel Special comment again  it's giving one trick pony. Can you come up with something else.gif

 

also no comment on Irene  idk what 'serve' we're talking about when it comes to vocals, but maybe sis should learn what 'support' means before being compared to Jeongyeon

 

also i realized my gif didnt work earlier oop

 

anyway

 

 

5 hours ago, Save-Me-Oprah said:

love them but it’s wild that TWICE ended up with so many filler members even though they had a whole competition show that was apparently supposed to come up with the best of the best

 

the group is very much Jihyo, Nayeon, Jeongyeon, Chaeyoung and their backup dancers

 

not when Momo can dance her ass off 

 

Dahyun might be average in everything but at least sis writes a lot for the group and even composes i guess. perks of being an instrument player

the only true "fillers" in terms of talent are Sana, Mina and Tzuyu...but then again they are some of the most BREATHTAKING beauties in the industry and are decent singers who are stan attractors so there aint no complaints

 

1 hour ago, Xalric said:

The fact that Brave Bros bought himself a Rolls Royce the same than Yang Hyun Suk and never used all that money to actually promote his acts.

His collection of classic American muscle cars have their own building.  Brave Girls' USA tour was kinda about him looking at more cars to buy.

 

Jeongyeon gets dragged enough by gross netizens let's not add to that with mindless trolling. She can sing & is obviously better vocalist than irene, hang up that narrative.

 

In fact despite being a sheep, I reject entirely the narrative that all RV members can sing well. Irene and Yeri are both in the bottom 5 weakest female vocalists from an SM group along with Hyoyeon, Yoona & Victoria.