I'd say they're pretty equal in the US but WW there's no competition, ME was much bigger

7 hours ago, Taylucifer said:

PH is bigger

 

PH is also the better album. ME is just awful and an album that’s basically just fillers, it’s Ariana’s worst body of work

It's an extremely disjointed album clearly meant as a playlist rather than a body of work - there's no denying it. But I won't stand for the slander towards its deep cuts. "Be My Baby", "Break Your Heart Right Back", "Just A Little Bit Of Your Heart", and "My Everything" are all sublime, and special shout-out to the career highlights found among the bonus tracks ("Only 1" and "Cadillac Song" ).

 

Also, "Hands On Me" and "Why Try" might be products of their time, but I'd still much rather listen to them than "Bang Bang"

Planet her singles was local except KMM so Ariana era is bigger

2 hours ago, Moonlight Nation said:

It's an extremely disjointed album clearly meant as a playlist rather than a body of work - there's no denying it. But I won't stand for the slander towards its deep cuts. "Be My Baby", "Break Your Heart Right Back", "Just A Little Bit Of Your Heart", and "My Everything" are all sublime, and special shout-out to the career highlights found among the bonus tracks ("Only 1" and "Cadillac Song" ).

 

Also, "Hands On Me" and "Why Try" might be products of their time, but I'd still much rather listen to them than "Bang Bang"

 

i won’t deny, those are masterpieces 

ariana sweetie...

15 hours ago, KOMH said:

This is false. PH has already outcharted ME in just about every major market in addition to ranking higher on YECs. 

ME outpeaked Planet Her in a lot of markets and PH has the streaming era advantage, while the streaming model was just getting adjusted to the charts when streaming wasn't even present as much in 2014. The YE thing isn't really true either, ME was higher in the US despite PH having a longer time period that counts for the YEC, while ME has 3 months less and therefore many positions were split two two years (in 2014 and 2015). 

 

I love Doja a lot and think she's the next big main pop girl (deservingly so!), but My Everything felt bigger and the stats prove it. This is not to belittle PH's success, the era was enormous and might even end up a bit bigger in the US when all is said and done. 

 

 

Edited October 17, 20223 yr by genio

Planet her

 

the fact that it’s halfway to my everything’s (fan made) stats after a year