Hi guys, so this is my first thread oh wow OH WOW  I am really excited to begin my terror of spam-churning threads but I thought I should start with something simple but chaotic enough

Which one of the alike-sounding songs do you prefer?

 

 

 

DISCUSS

Edited September 23, 20223 yr by Blackout2006

both are amazing and magical, honestly cant choose 

Not me thinking "With You" would maybe be a Mariah Carey song.

But you surprised me with even more irrelevance 

 

Taylor, sweetie 

9 minutes ago, magazine said:

Not me thinking "With You" would maybe be a Mariah Carey song.

But you surprised me with even more irrelevance 

 

Taylor, sweetie 

Not you thinking one of the most influential popstars of the last decade is "irrelevant"

 

f*ck this is the ultimate question

 

uhhh I guess Without You, but Wildest Dreams is fantastic too. something about Without You is slightly more epic imo

Wildest Dreams 

I don't listen to Lana

Without You, aka the original

Without You >>>>>>

 

I mean there's a reason Taylor copied it

Wildest Dreams improved the ten seconds that were inspired by Without You. There's a reason one of them was a big hit (and still does 1M streams/day) and the other was relegated to bonus track status 

Came for Jessica Simpson's With You.

Wildest Dreams

Wildest Dreams is absolute perfection, she copied it well. Without You is beautiful, but it’s low tier in Lana’s discography.

Without You aka the original blueprint 

Mariah & Jessica’s songs titled “With You” >>>> Without You > Wildest Dreams

Lana's unreleased "With You".

Sorry but Without You is the OG and wins this 

Everything I want, I have, so I didn't need Taylor's karaoke tribute!

 

Without You >>>