Pitchfork is one of the most talked about music publications on this Forum... what do we think Pitchfork will rank Renaissance by Queen B? 

 

My prediction: 8.3 

 

 

 

 

I predict a 7.6 but the real question is what will Melon give it 

8.5

 

1 minute ago, Redstreak said:

I predict a 7.6 but the real question is what will Melon give it 

we stopped caring what his ugly ass thinks after he named Charli the best album of 2019

 

4 minutes ago, Redstreak said:

I predict a 7.6 but the real question is what will Melon give it 

i just know he will give MOVE lashings

I'm predicting a 7.5. I don't think it'll get BNM.

9

I think a 9.0 BNM

7.9

it's difficult to say. they will either give it the 9.0 it deserves, or give her a hard time because they've given her such high scores in the past. I'm going to say 8.5 BNM

8.8

7.7 

9.5+, it's Beyoncé  

7.9 

7.5-7.7

8.1

I think it deserves 8.8+, but I see them giving it 7.8 - 8.0, no BNM, just to try and shock people as usual. And the POC writer will be bummed out that there's no BLM anthems on it or whatever. Bookmark this.  

8.2

8.6, BNM

It's Beyonce so 9.0+ 

I think they’re going to switch on her, especially since this one isn’t explicitly political… 7.8 no BNM.

Edited July 29, 20224 yr by kandicha

I'm expecting at least it getting an 8.2 because of it being Beyoncé. But, I could see this album possibly underperforming with critics. So, I'm curious to see what happens with the reviews.

Probably like 8.6. 

7.9 or 8.0

The writer for The Guardian was disappointed because the album isn't political and America Has A Problem wasn't about race (  ), so I fully expect the critics to give her the Kendrick Lamar treatment, which is a shame since this album is her most exciting and experimental yet.

8.8