May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714646 3 minutes ago, chosensparkles said: I mean at the end of the day, we shall remember Shallah stalled on pop radio and was rejected there but had its moment on HAC/AC Stupid Love went this high due to payola and radio deals while ROM had this combination plus Ariana to help us on Pop radio And even ROM wasn't making that much of a dent on Pop radio. It went #1 with mainly streaming and sales on album release. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714646 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714660 2 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: When in true Celine fashion it gets panned with a 55 on MC the only way she gets a panned album ever again is if ARTPOP Act II was released an automatic 50 Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714660 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714670 Just now, Canonical Ensembl said: And even ROM wasn't making that much of a dent on Pop radio. It went #1 with mainly streaming and sales on album release. exactly, people need to remember that Pop radio is first ageist and mysoginistic so female in their 30s no matter the material just don't have huge peaks or rise to the top spot like a 20 something shiny new girl can do Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714670 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714695 A self-written Celine'd album would be legendary tbh. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714695 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714706 4 minutes ago, chosensparkles said: the only way she gets a panned album ever again is if ARTPOP Act II was released an automatic 50 NAWT the hyperpop predictor when critics drag/ignore every AC release bar Adele because she's Adele Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714706 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714711 1 minute ago, Canonical Ensembl said: A self-written Celine'd album would be legendary tbh. I need her to serve her Tapestry Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714711 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714758 Honestly, Fad's done 4 AC releases and they either got underwhelming reviews (ASIB not going over 80 on MC was criminal) or ignored (Coochie 4 Sale). The fact that Chromatica of all her recent releases got her the most acclaim from publications kinda says it all. Music critics are just not here for HaGa At the very least not for bland wine ballads, they could turn if she served songwriting. Edited May 14, 20224 yr by EnigmaticAndroid Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714758 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714798 15 minutes ago, chosensparkles said: the only way she gets a panned album ever again is if ARTPOP Act II was released an automatic 50 100 in our hearts. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714798 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714804 she would be so panned for HAC album pls rightfully so Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714804 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714844 8 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: Honestly, Fad's done 4 AC releases and they either got underwhelming reviews (ASIB not going over 80 on MC was criminal) or ignored (Coochie 4 Sale). The fact that Chromatica of all her recent releases got her the most acclaim from publications kinda says it all. Music critics are just not here for HaGa At the very least not for bland wine ballads, they could turn if she served songwriting. Chromatica has gained from the poptimism, look at all the pop albums out there and tell me some deserves those scores? Rare (as much as I love miss Selena) got a 76/100... Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714844 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714866 Face it, GaGa thrives when performing pop songs on piano. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714866 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714870 She already released a Celine'd album, it's called A Star Is Born Original Soundtrack. "I'll Never Love Again" is literally a 90s Diane Warren power ballad. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714870 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714885 Just now, Protocol said: She already released a Celine'd album, it's called A Star Is Born Original Soundtrack. "I'll Never Love Again" is literally a 90s Diane Warren power ballad. and she will sadly do it again sis Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714885 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714906 Release a pop bop album > perform on piano > if it takes off, release a stripped down version for the geepee Sounds like a great plan, bob doesn’t have the professionalism for that. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714906 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21714925 8 minutes ago, chosensparkles said: Chromatica has gained from the poptimism, look at all the pop albums out there and tell me some deserves those scores? Rare (as much as I love miss Selena) got a 76/100... Eh, the way it was crafted as an album is a clear step above the bulk of Gaga's catalog. Like the one consistent criticism she's had across her entire career was that her albums usually feel messy and unfocused, it was never that shocking that critics got on board when she delivered an actually cohesive album with fleshed out themes. You can actually trace consistent ideas (dehumanization, psychosis, catharsis through dance music, freedom and healing) that are developed across the album whereas Artpop and Joanne attempted to be proper "albums" but failed and The Fame is a kinda surface-level commentary on fame. Chromatica is the definition of something that's better than the sum of its parts, and even then it has multiple career-best songs. Edited May 14, 20224 yr by EnigmaticAndroid Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21714925 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715197 22 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: Eh, the way it was crafted as an album is a clear step above the bulk of Gaga's catalog. Like the one consistent criticism she's had across her entire career was that her albums usually feel messy and unfocused, it was never that shocking that critics got on board when she delivered an actually cohesive album with fleshed out themes. You can actually trace consistent ideas (dehumanization, psychosis, catharsis through dance music, freedom and healing) that are developed across the album whereas Artpop and Joanne attempted to be proper "albums" but failed and The Fame is a kinda surface-level commentary on fame. Chromatica is the definition of something that's better than the sum of its parts, and even then it has multiple career-best songs. Wonderfully said. Chromatica gained her best reviews yet because it was a cohesive album. One really can’t say it benefited from some kind of high Gaga was on because her previous releases and follow up ones failed to do that. The critics just liked Chromatica (and Dawn Of Chromatica). Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715197 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715362 is Hold my Puss even gonna chart Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715362 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715536 14 minutes ago, Orsay said: is Hold my Puss even gonna chart On the bubbling under maybe Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715536 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715580 1 hour ago, chosensparkles said: the only way she gets a panned album ever again is if ARTPOP Act II was released an automatic 50 50 too high for AP Act II, i fear Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715580 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715588 Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715588 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715668 Chromatica has sold 4M Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715668 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715671 1 hour ago, Kimi said: and she will sadly do it again sis Gaga has never really done the same genre or sound twice (besides C2C and L4S). All of her pop albums have different genre influences. This pisses critics off. They want her to release the same type of albums over and over again, but she is always trying something new. All I want from LG7 is something new. I don’t care if it is pop or bluegrass. An album full of original jazz piano songs would be cute Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715671 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715729 14 minutes ago, The Witch said: now who's gonna tell her Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715729 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715738 2 hours ago, Artur said: Poker Face 704,137,720 (+572,137) Just Dance 549,539,127 (+547,010) Bad Romance 732,970,284 (+546,269) The way few months ago BR was outstreaming both These 3 classics are so funny. But Fad Dance truly exploded Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715738 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
May 14, 20224 yr comment_21715766 Not Rina's album apparently being a Bible This Way rehash She better SERVE or we will be Ava Max-ing her Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/650/#findComment-21715766 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
