1 minute ago, TheGerm said:

ARTPOP > Joanne 

Did anyone ever thought otherwise actually? I guess OAH did but we don’t care about them.

Just now, DonnieDarko said:

Did anyone ever thought otherwise actually? I guess OAH did but we don’t care about them.

Music critics, who I was told are of the utmost importance when it's convenient.

 

4 minutes ago, DonnieDarko said:

Did anyone ever thought otherwise actually? I guess OAH did but we don’t care about them.

 

1 minute ago, DoctorIce said:

Music critics, who I was told are of the utmost importance when it's convenient.

 

 

57 minutes ago, jesus del rey said:

Joanne is a good album that needed BloodT*rd to stay away from it.

 

 

1 hour ago, sunbathinganimal said:

Joanne sucks and I hate how people think if you say that you only want gaY BoPs from her 

I feel you on that - like a lot of people just didn’t like Joanne, and of course Gaga fans are gonna want a certain kind of genre foo they shouldn’t be shamed for that. I just see how much her other avenues have done for her so I respect that so much 

Only the first half of Joanne (bar Joanne the song) is good. Everything else is just... not up to par with the standard Gaga has put for herself. 

36 minutes ago, DoctorIce said:

Music critics, who I was told are of the utmost importance when it's convenient.

 

Drag me, lmao. 

Bloody Mary +1,037,839
Shallow +903,010
Poker Face +740,172
Always Remember Us This Way +720,685
Just Dance +660,069

 

 

the fact that this is a Sunday update, the way her numbers rose compared to a few months ago is amazing

So whats your favorite Chromatica Act? 

Chromatica 1 , Chromatica 2 or Chromatica 3? 

 

To me Chromatica 2 destroys the other two sections… 

 

2 hours ago, sunbathinganimal said:

Joanne sucks and I hate how people think if you say that you only want gaY BoPs from her 

This. Just because we don't want her to sell out to geriatrics and kill her streaming audience doesn't mean we only want pnp bops. 

Just now, EnigmaticAndroid said:

This. Just because we don't want her to sell out to geriatrics and kill her streaming audience doesn't mean we only want pnp bops. 

Preach

17 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said:

This. Just because we don't want her to sell out to geriatrics and kill her streaming audience doesn't mean we only want pnp bops. 

like there's nothing i'd love more from her at this point than a chill album but that doesn't mean it needs to be Million Reasons'd

3 minutes ago, sunbathinganimal said:

like there's nothing i'd love more from her at this point than a chill album but that doesn't mean it needs to be Million Reasons'd

Agreed; no hac ballads but chill, sophisticated songs 

 

This song deserved her most chic and expensive music video. We were so robbed.  The performance is so incredible. 

 

17 hours ago, Bhabylon said:

Some of these gays think Singer’s Prolapse is the best song on Joanne and that Alice would’ve been #1 for 3 months if it were the lead… They’re beyond help me thinks 

 

 

I will die on the hill that Alice was the perfect lead and even if it flopped in the US it would’ve still did better globally. And also, it’s not like it could’ve did any worse than Stupid Love. The first day numbers were there, just no one liked the song 

Not people trying to shame others for not wanting to buy a physical copy… of a single song  

3 hours ago, MadMax12 said:

The smart choice would have been Sour Candy. It has an anthemic chorus and the Black Pink hype would have got the streams. It’s about to outstream SL

Stupid Love top five. Sour Candy with music video #1 debut. Rain on Me with music video #1 debut. 

Had she done this pre-album drop, whewww the slayage.

 

58 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said:

This. Just because we don't want her to sell out to geriatrics and kill her streaming audience doesn't mean we only want pnp bops. 

Joanne has nothing to do with geriatrics, though? Considering Million Reasons, Shallow, and ARUTW, ballads are exactly how she can get the GP on her side. If y'all want her to be on the GP's mind, she has to play the "ballad" game.

9 minutes ago, AidanUnderYou said:

I will die on the hill that Alice was the perfect lead and even if it flopped in the US it would’ve still did better globally. And also, it’s not like it could’ve did any worse than Stupid Love. The first day numbers were there, just no one liked the song 

Considering I think the only commercial song was ROM, I would've gone with Replay as the lead with an insane video.

 

It's the song that represents the whole message of the album the best. A bop about trauma. 

2 minutes ago, TheLastChord said:

Considering I think the only commercial song was ROM, I would've gone with Replay as the lead with an insane video.

 

It's the song that represents the whole message of the album the best. A bop about trauma. 

Free Woman (French Radio Edit) without the empty first chorus could’ve slayed too

 

 

Jesus Woman at the Covid Ball was such an ethereal experience 

 

Even Fun Tonight became more listenable after the show tbh

5 hours ago, industry baby said:

I mean Stupid Love and Rain on Me Vinyl, CD, Cassette sales were one of the biggest disappointment of all time. 
Its simple her fanbase %100 selfish poor messy grindr gays that wont buy physical copies of her songs let alone digital itunes copy yet they’re loud and noisy enough to criticize her musical directions… Thats one of the main reasons she should never ever listen to this fanbase’s needs because they’ll only use the song for a day and then the next they they’ll want something else.

 

5 hours ago, besaid said:

I will forever hold a grudge against this base for letting those vinyl and cd releases flop. I bought ALL of them and love physical releases. Like, how are you a "stan" that posts on GG or ATRLs Gaga base and you won't buy a physical of her lead singles or #1 hits? The only recent vinyl of hers I missed was Hold My Hand. 

 

5 hours ago, iconicyayo said:

what’s the tea on SL / ROM vinyls? did they really flop so badly? 

Idk why you are blaming the fans when her team pressed only  5k vinyls ?

35 minutes ago, AidanUnderYou said:

I will die on the hill that Alice was the perfect lead and even if it flopped in the US it would’ve still did better globally. And also, it’s not like it could’ve did any worse than Stupid Love. The first day numbers were there, just no one liked the song 

5 minutes ago, Santhosh said:

 

 

Idk why you are blaming the fans when her team pressed only  5k vinyls ?

i’m not blaming anyone idk what happened 

so chromatica ball film is def scrapped? 

2 minutes ago, iconicyayo said:

so chromatica ball film is def scrapped? 

Realistically speaking, we do not know what is happening with that