Just a month after its release it's out of the top 40, while Without Me is still top 20, and made history as one of the longest running top 10s ever with a total of 29 weeks. Nightmare also only has 41M views on YouTube, where Without Me garnered 231M. What happened?  

ATRL loved it. 

 

The reactions and reception was like unanimously positive across the board. 

 

 

Too much excellence. This generation can't relate.

 

It was ahead of its time

She doesn't care about the charts so she released a rock song. That's what happened.

Halsey ain't one of the pop girls that runs after lil quick singles.

Edited June 26, 20197 yr by halcyonday

Feminist gimmicks from Halsey don't sell.

I don't know

It's one of the best songs of the year

The GP didn't deserve it yet.

It always felt bland to me

 

Without Me >

 

She should stick with trap pop

without me was a very safe move. she took a risk by releasing a rock-oriented single which doesn’t sound like today’s current hits 

The geepee is never here for a rock song smashing in 2019, she should've worked with Louis Bell again for another hit masterpiece and make it her signature sound because Louis Bell's production excellency suits her best. Nightmare is a nice bop but Without Me >>>>

 

 

It deserved Without Me's success

7 minutes ago, halcyonday said:

She doesn't care about the charts so she released a rock song. That's what happened.

Halsey ain't one of the pop girls that runs after lil quick singles.

 

This. She should regret nothing. 

 

 

arT not the charT  

doesn't sound has good as Without Me  she shouldn't have changed lanes so quickly

It aged like milk 

Edited June 26, 20197 yr by SapphireSky

The GP was not here for Pink 2.0. 

who cares? it is one of the best songs of the decade

 

10 minutes ago, Ras said:

It always felt bland to me

 

Without Me >

 

She should stick with trap pop

Without Me is trap pop?  

Sadly the GP is hot here for female rock in 2019

It's too good for the GP anyway. 

1 minute ago, Evolution said:

who cares? it is one of the best songs of the decade

 

The GP said no.

Not sure because ATRL told me she was a main pop girl.

22 minutes ago, QueenofCopyPaste said:

ATRL loved it. 

 

The reactions and reception was like unanimously positive across the board. 

 

 

I knew this would happen once everyone was praising it . 

 

GP doesn't like woke girls. 

incredibly noisy for the gp. incredible song tho.