14 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

We're at ten active rates, so no more for the time being!

Oh  Does it mean when one is done I can start or is there a long waiting list  

On 25/3/2017 at 8:06 PM, prézli said:

I was thinking of a new rate while being banned...  

 

These Girls Are Problems. A rate for controversial female singers.  

 

Azealia Banks - Broke with Expensive Taste x Paris Hilton - Paris x Lindsay Lohan - A Little More Personal (Raw) x Natalia Kills - Trouble x Heidi Montag - Superficial

Here for this

On 25-3-2017 at 8:06 PM, prézli said:

I was thinking of a new rate while being banned...  

 

These Girls Are Problems. A rate for controversial female singers.  

 

Azealia Banks - Broke with Expensive Taste x Paris Hilton - Paris x Lindsay Lohan - A Little More Personal (Raw) x Natalia Kills - Trouble x Heidi Montag - Superficial

Sounds neat!

So here for pretzel's rate omg

Thinking about it @Ace Reject, do you think we should maybe adopt a Popjustice-esque format for some of the larger discography rates? I mean splitting them into multiple parts to make them more... palatable. 

 

I just realised making out a Donna Summer list of songs that she has quite a few, and for a somewhat niche rate it might be too intimidating for voters to be rating 200 songs, and the other alternative would be cutting out some albums entirely. I think this would work by pushing out the Moroder years as a test run before seeing if there's any interest in the 80s onward. 

On 4/8/2017 at 10:04 PM, Lazuli said:

Hi @Ace Reject I would like to host a Beach House discography rate! 

Beach House? I'm not sure if we are thinking if the same Beach House but if we are, I'll support that rate.

Hi @Ace Reject, I just want to know what you think of the suggestion for the rate I sent to you? What improvements should I do for it to go live (once there is an opening)?

2 hours ago, KatyCatPH said:

Beach House? I'm not sure if we are thinking if the same Beach House but if we are, I'll support that rate.

Is there another band called Beach House? 

 

 

Cranes in the Sky won TW2016!

 

Who's hosting part 2? I need to lash a certain band.

 

On 4/8/2017 at 11:34 AM, Ace Reject said:

We're at ten active rates, so no more for the time being!

Does this mean I can't start the Shania rate even tho it was already approved?

The Ciara Discography Rate is open now!

 

14 hours ago, Eeveelution said:

Cranes in the Sky won TW2016!

 

Who's hosting part 2? I need to lash a certain band.

 

Not you? 

 

I want A Moon Shaped Pool and Bottomless Pit 

 

*Angel jpeg*

5 minutes ago, Clueless said:

Not you? 

 

I want A Moon Shaped Pool and Bottomless Pit 

 

*Angel jpeg*

Nah, I have a ton of studying to do. 

 

Plus, I try to be a fair and objective host, and with Frank and Radiohead there...

 

Edited April 13, 20179 yr by Eeveelution

Just now, Eeveelution said:

Nah, I have a ton of studying to do. 

 

Plus I try to be a fair and objective host, and with Frank and Radiohead there...

 

Frank can choke tbh!

Self-titled albums need to die. Unfortunately they're a seemingly permanent staple of music at this point.

 

Acey sis, Donna rate?

 

I think an early Summer start around May/June would be perfect? 

Would it be possible to do an ATRL's Top 100 Videogame Franchises Rate or ATRL's Top 100 Videogames of All-Time around June (E3)? I think it would be interesting and bring attention to the Entertainment section.

The winner of the Ayumi rate with an average of 9.79 was M!

 

 

Thanks boo!

On 4/10/2017 at 9:19 AM, Subomie said:

Thinking about it @Ace Reject, do you think we should maybe adopt a Popjustice-esque format for some of the larger discography rates? I mean splitting them into multiple parts to make them more... palatable. 

 

I just realised making out a Donna Summer list of songs that she has quite a few, and for a somewhat niche rate it might be too intimidating for voters to be rating 200 songs, and the other alternative would be cutting out some albums entirely. I think this would work by pushing out the Moroder years as a test run before seeing if there's any interest in the 80s onward. 

YES. Split it up by eras. This is a disco or an essentials?

@prézli, half of those albums have been used already!

On 4/12/2017 at 5:46 PM, Eeveelution said:

Cranes in the Sky won TW2016!

 

Who's hosting part 2? I need to lash a certain band.

 

I would actually ... like This WAS 2013 to be restarted! Especially with three of these five artists releasing new material this year!

1 hour ago, Ace Reject said:

@prézli, half of those albums have been used already!

Oh.

On 4/2/2017 at 4:32 PM, conatus said:

Charmbracelord vs. This Is Me...Then vs. something else could be... Cute?

 

Who else released in '02 that would fit?

 

 

EDIT: Just Whitney? A New Day Has Come? Get rid of J.Lo and we could have a Vocal Trinity in '02 rate? Thoughts @Ace Reject?

 

I KNOW that there was an American Life/Damita Jo/Body Language rate. Am trying to recall if Charmbracelet/Just Whitney/A New Day Has Come was the planned sequel, or if it actually happened?

 

BTW, whatever happened to the This WAS POP series? Am much, much unhappy that's seemingly been discontinued?

any news on my 80s one-hit wonders rate? can I redact the list and fix it up?