-
Britney new album anniversary edition fail to enter B200, surprised?
It's funny because it's probably the 6th time we're repeating the simple fact the physical not released simultaneously with the streaming availability is the reason why it didn't chart yet some people still invent other irrelevant reasons to justify this. There's being a hater and there's being delusional but the two seems to have collided, these past few years. What will happen when she becomes the most streamed pre-00s female act (the biopic will set that in stone)? Another batch of excuses to cope with the harsh reality, maybe?
- Britney new album anniversary edition fail to enter B200, surprised?
- Niki & The Dove - "The Kiss"
-
Most streamed songs written by Max Martin by decade of release (on spotify)
Crazy how Britney navigated out of the deeply stigmatized teen pop sphere, which she was the queen of, even putting a pop song from the second phase of her career in there ("If U Seek Amy"). And that's not even counting "Toxic", "Gimme More" or "Womanizer", all from three very distinct producers, proving she was not a Max Martin one-trick-pony. This not stressed nearly enough around here.
-
Female vocalist with the best/worst discography ?
Mariah is the best, clearly but Christina had something going for her during Stripped and Back to Basics. Yes sometimes, it was a bit overstuffed and contrived (she really wanted to prove herself out of the teen pop world, which was quite stigmatizing at the time). But there were gems and tons of fun to be had, in between some more reflective moments. Bionic could have been great with the deluxe tracks replacing some of the more questionable choices found on the album. Sometimes, I wonder if her attitude didn't piss off an A&R who, then, decided to let that sink ship instead of helping her salvage the record (qualitywise, at least). The worst might be Gaga as she's never topped her The Fame + Monster years (even if The Fame already had a few fillers, here and there). I do enjoy BTW and Artpop, in spite of a lowered quality control but wasn't too keen on Joanne and Chromatica. It's interesting she's changed it up and tried new things (branching out into acting and side jazz projects) but the result is an inconsistent discography that started out firing on all cylinders only to lose steam afterward. Fortunately, she seems to have found a more coherent sound with MAYHEM so I should finally listen to it and maybe I'll witness her return to form.
-
You're a pop star; Christina's voice or Taylor's success
None. Christina's career and catalogue was underwelming, given the potential she had. As for Taylor, maintaining this type of success looks exhausting (+ you eventually burn out quality wise). If we're only talking about voices, Taylor's voice did connect with people in a MAJOR way and that's what matters as a popstar, to reach as many fans as possible.
-
What's your favourite music video of the 2020s so far?
I can't think of a better way to introduce a solo career as a popstar, tbh. The dramatics, the popculture references, the commentary on the industry and the price to pay to live your dreams (with personal footage sprinkled here and there, in the video). This was a homerun For those who haven't seen it, watch in on a big screen and not on your phone, I'm begging you!
-
Was Donna Summer the first MPG?
The question is probably too complex to to be answered with one, unique answer. I can agree with Donna because even if Diana was a ruthless, trailblazer for more than two decades, she didn't have the type of sales Donna pulled with Bad Girls. And we can't forget how crucial to electronic/dance music, her collaboration with Moroder was. This was a Britney/Danja, lightning in a bottle moment but even more forward thinking. I also would give credit to Cyndi for the 80s who kinda did a Teenage Dream, relentless pop era (with way better album sales than Katy's) before it was really a thing in 83', with She's So Unusual (that 1-6 punch sequence, from "Money Changes Everything" to "All Through The Night" was unheard of, for female popstars at the time). The punk-ish look was, in itself, quite outrageous for a maintream pop artist in the early 80s so she really took a risk, presenting herself like this to the GP. Janet is also impossible to ignore, with her chronicling the state of the world and becoming a grown, adult black woman, with the added pressure of having been a role model child star. Let's not even speak about her choreos that have still not been matched (even if Britney came close, from 2001 to 2004). "If" alone felt like the magna carta for future female pop performers, making a statement, running the show and taking full agency of their bodies. Finally, Olivia was probably the first female country crossover to full fledged popstar, at this level of success, before Shania and Taylor. She was an iconic face of the 70s, starred in one of the biggest movie ever and did the GGGB phase before it was even a thing (from Making a Good Thing Better to Grease and Totally Hot). Let's not forget, "Physical" becoming the biggest billboard female song of the 80s and the attached album, one of the very first visual project (with videos for every song). Imagine, just IMAGINE proto-ATRLers witnessing this in the 70s!
-
Legacy artists who did not surpass their idols
Why all the Britney shade out of nowhere ? The first pop legacy figure your mind associated this thread with was her?! Kinda proves she's the biggest popstar since Madonna, taking everything into account (success, fame, enduring influence, bulletproof musical catalogue, iconicity, opening so many doors and being the 1st to break so many records). Only Queen can boast about being top 10 most pre-saved album, along side herself, with Britney25. An album seen as an underperformance at the time, in spite of selling as much as the all-time pure sales peak of her early 00s peers! Can someone post a video like this, covering only one era, with a popstar that debuted post-Britney and wasn't influenced by her? I'd say Lana with Born to die but even her Lolita schtick was clearly referencing Ms. Spears.
- "Dreams" hits 3 billion streams
-
Janet Jackson's streams on Spotify are borderline unacceptable!!
I think she's happy with her current standing because the few things she could do to improve her numbers, she shies away from. In a more hopeful note, the album seems to be back in her mind so it might get released before 2030! Yay for us Also, her touring has gotten better, with more consistency and less cancellations. I'll do my work as a Janet fan and speak to the younger generations. If there was only one female singer/entertainer to listen to truly understand how female pop music has moved forward, it's her. A masterclass in songwriting, harmony, dancing, visuals and concept albums. She doesn't even have a bad album (20 Y.O is decent and far from the real bad albums, a few popstars have subjected us to) and her run from 86' to 04 is one for the book. The visuals alone (singles/albums covers, music videos, photoshoots), down to the font used, were all expertly crafted with a perfectionism that is almost scary when you think about the work it required. Janet had the biggest star on earth as her brother and she did the impossible, that is creating a bulletproof legacy for herself and paving the way for pretty much every great popstar we've gotten afterward. Like who would have dared releasing videos like this, in the late nineties? That was a whole statement, coming right after her janet. peak. And The Velvet Rope... No words can do it justice so go listen to it, if you still haven't ! How do you release this when you already have Control and Rhythm Nation 1814 in your discography ?!
-
Britney Spears| Spotify: Criminal +815k daily !
Yes, I know that. I was mostly speaking about her overall growth, these past few years, the haters are trying to give the credit to her selling her catalogue. They truly are desperate, right now (often pivoting to attack her personal life because her numbers are just THAT good). Even retired, not playing the game and with a controversial image, she's still very relevant through her iconicity + overall discography. Some people went with the "She's over" cope out a bit too early, methink. By the way, I still think her playlisting could be improved but I'm not an expert on that field. I clearly remember, she was among the lowest playlisting from her gen for many, many years but she's finally catching up.
-
Britney Spears| Spotify: Criminal +815k daily !
Normal playlisting (for once in her career, knowing how radio wasn't too keen on her either) + a pristine discography (even Jean has a few gems) = a streaming resurgence that leaves the haters irrate, anxious and sleepless! Once in a lifetime, generational pop legends tend to do that... By the way, hate posting generates engagement and keep people relevant so thanks for your services
-
Could Tate pull off Gimme More?
"Gimme more" is a very seductive song, with a dark edge, going hand in hand with the morbid fascination the public has for the original Miss American Dream. It calls for musical intelligence (to not overdo the sex kitten thing and fall into parody territory) and 0 over singing (which is impossible to do for most of the bigger voiced singers, praised to the highest heaven in here). The vocals on the track are crystal clear and dynamic enough so the lyrics don't sound repetitive (even with the "gimme more" part, being repeated endlessly + acting as the chorus). There's also beautiful, iconic adlibs towards the end and a magical chemistry between Brit, Keri and Danja. So no, not "EvRyboDy" is able to pull off this song (the falsetto alone would be a deal breaker for many ), without it sounding a total mess, and claims of the contrary prove how musically ignorant a chunk of this forum truly is. PS/This song reminds me of a Janet podcast I've listened to last year's, where Jimmy Jam & Terry Lewis were saying she knew how to breathe, completely in sync with the music (which not a lot of people can do). This is exactly what we hear in "Gimme More" too!
-
Britney clocks haters & imiTATErs
By the way, she's right about being ahead of her time even when people counted her out (see Britney, In The Zone, Blackout or Femme Fatale). And now, retired and not playing the industry game, her blueprint is NOW stronger than ever and her streams have seen an insane growth these past few years (Rolling Stone even wrote an article about how the younger generation have grown fondly of her and are now discovering her music). Her twenty years career shaped/shapes the future of pop, in a way. This may sound like she's bragging but it's the truth, objectively.
Blur
ATRL Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited