Everything posted by chicbitch
-
Are Taylor's lead singles always aimed at adding children into her fanbase?
Nothing about these scream Disney... atleast to me. And this is coming from someone who used to like Taylor but doesn't now.
- Are we ready for Woke 3.0?
-
Would you (actually) hold a MPG accountable for their digital footprint?
I agree.. I just find it so bizarre how some people who have done considerably worse seem to receive far less scrutiny or backlash. And you'd honestly be surprised by how many people who are so vocal about hating on certain artists are stanning artists with equally problematic, if not worse, pasts lol. I think there's a lot of selective accountability when it comes to these conversations that not a lot of people like to admit.
- Nicki Minaj: What's next?
-
Would you (actually) hold a MPG accountable for their digital footprint?
The recent Slayyyter drama has got me thinking about how we perceive artists' past online behaviour and how much weight we actually put on someone's digital footprint. Camila Cabello had a very similar situation with her old tweets resurfacing, but I also think there are quite a few other artists whose past online behaviour is either rarely discussed or conveniently left out of these conversations. Personally, I find the whole subject interesting because I do believe people can grow out of certain mindsets and behaviours, especially when we're talking about things they said years ago. Where I find things particularly interesting is the inconsistency. Some artists have their entire reputations shaped by things they said online years ago, while others seem to have a much easier time distancing themselves from their pasts. So I'm curious: how much does an artist's digital footprint actually influence the way you view them? Would you stop supporting someone over old tweets, Tumblr posts, online interactions etc.? Does a genuine apology change your perception, or do you think certain things will always follow someone? And do you think the industry and fanbases are consistent with who they choose to hold accountable?
-
Would you consider Taylor Swift to be a pop puppet?
Oh this isn't trying to snark on her at all, I'm just genuinely wondering if she's decided to step back and play a 'puppet' and just hand the label albums that just make money / generic / fans will eat it up. Cuz given her last releases... it's starting to show a pattern. "provides the label with money (not to sound conspiratorial lol) / someone who can churn out simple, digestible pop with little artistic identity, creative input or genuine care for what they're putting out." -- all very true for her in this state of her career. Maybe not as early as one would describe a "puppet" to be --a-la Britney-- but she's kinda falling into that category.
-
Would you consider Taylor Swift to be a pop puppet?
I was having this convo with an oomf of mine and I wanted to bring it here. Would you consider Taylor to be a pop puppet? .. By pop puppet, I mean someone who serves the masses and or provides the label with money (not to sound conspiratorial lol) / someone who can churn out simple, digestible pop with little artistic identity, creative input or genuine care for what they're putting out. Because I feel like her work has been lacking more and more over the years, and I'm not even talking about commercial success. She's obviously bigger than ever, but creatively I feel like there's been a decline. TLOSG honestly felt like a huge flop to me, and even The Tortured Poets Department, for as much praise as it gets, is incredibly boring and repetitive. A lot of the songwriting feels sloppy to me too. Do you think she's genuinely as involved in her artistry/albums as people make her out to be, or has she become more of a product of the industry at this point? I truly feel like there's a bigger conversation to be had about how much creative control she actually has versus how much of the 'Taylor Swift' brand is being manufactured around her.
-
Why didn't Kesha go with Max?
Cirkut kinda had to... He was discovered by Dr. Luke
- HDD: Hilary Duff's concert film potentially headed to the big screen
-
Why didn't Kesha go with Max?
I can understand why working with Max isn't necessarily an option for her now, but I'm specifically talking about 2014-2016, when she was still signed to a major label and the lawsuit was at its peak. I mean she was still under RCA and she had a couple albums left in her contract...
-
Why did Kesha tank seemingly overnight?
I think this is rewriting history a little lol. Kesha wasn't some underappreciated indie artist waiting for the GP to discover she could sing. The party girl image WORKED, until the market started moving on. Also, blaming RCA when her first era was commercially massive feels a little revisionist. The Dr. Luke situation absolutely complicated things, but the idea that a few ballads and a piano performance would've saved her career is wishful thinking.
-
Why didn't Kesha go with Max?
I've always wondered this because Max was literally right there during her early career and helped produce her first two albums alongside Dr. Luke. And considering how much of a hitmaking machine he was, you'd think her label would've wanted to make him a bigger part of her sound. I feel like she could've had an entirely different career trajectory sonically, especially once the whole party girl thing started getting stale. From what I can find, there was no clause specifically requiring her to work with Max, obviously, but her contract with Luke's production company did give him significant control over her recordings and required him to produce at least six songs per album. That doesn't mean she was contractually required to have him produce every single song, though... The way people talk about Kesha's career, you'd think Luke was the only producer on the planet who could make a hit record for her. and I can't help but wonder what would've happened if she'd been pushed in a different direction sonically while she was still at her commercial peak.. and why there seemingly wasn't a bigger push to have Max take the lead on her music.
-
Was Kesha supposed to be Gaga 2.0?
I actually agree with this to an extent. I feel like the party girl image was so tied to that specific era of pop music that once the sound started fading out, it became harder for her to maintain that same level of mainstream success. Which is a shame because I think Kesha had a lot more to offer beyond that image.
-
Was Kesha supposed to be Gaga 2.0?
I'm only asking because I feel like this was a pretty common topic around the time of her debut, yet nobody really mentions it anymore (as far as I can see). I don't see why it's such an outrageous question to ask lol, especially considering people were making these exact same comparisons back then.
- J.Lo announces new album/era that is "super fun and cunty for my gays"
-
Was Kesha supposed to be Gaga 2.0?
Looking back at 2009–2010, I find it interesting how Kesha emerged almost immediately after Gaga had completely changed what labels wanted out of a female pop star.. (and this is by no means shade, it's just tea nobody ever talks about) TiK ToK came out and suddenly there was another eccentric blonde girl doing electropop, except this one was drunk, covered in glitter and looked like she hadn't showered. Obviously the two had very different identities, but I do wonder how much of Kesha's initial marketing was influenced by Gaga's overnight success. Especially considering how desperate the industry became to find its next outrageous pop girl. And then you had girls like Neon Hitch, who almost seemed like an attempt to combine the two. The eccentricity of Gaga, the trashiness of Kesha, the Benny Blanco productions, the whole package. Except this time the public wasn't buying it and the album never even saw the light of day. It's kind of fascinating how many labels were throwing money at these girls trying to recreate that 2009 explosion, only for most of them to disappear by 2013. Do you think Kesha was initially intended to capitalize on Gaga's success, or was their simultaneous rise just a coincidence?
-
Is ADÉLA already the pop star Tate McRae was supposed to be?
I can see where you're coming from but I feel like my issue is that Britney had an actual identity beyond wearing low-rise jeans and doing choreography. You could recognize a Britney record within five seconds of hearing it. With Tate I still feel like we're waiting for her to establish something musically distinctive that isn't just another variation of Greedy.
-
JLo's smash hit era is upon us..
A few of my gay friends who are weirdly connected to the industry have been telling me that she's been in sessions with Max Martin, Cirkut, Oscar Scheller, Stuart Price and apparently even The Dare over the past couple months. One of them claims the lead single (for hew new project / droplet era) is already finished and is being described as a very aggressive, early 2010s electropop record (kinda serving TFM outtake.) The funniest part is that apparently Jennifer specifically requested something along the lines of Britney's Femme Fatale, Your Body by Xtina mixed with Kylie Minogue's Aphrodite rather than the usual Latin-pop shzzit she's been recycling for the past decade. I'm also hearing that Danny L Harle and SG Lewis were approached for additional production, although idk how much of that is actually true. Could we actually be getting a proper JLo pop era next year?
-
Is ADÉLA already the pop star Tate McRae was supposed to be?
I get what you're saying but let's be serious, the GP is not checking for that abrasive experimental hyperpop sound anymore and hasn't been since the whole brat phenomenon in 2024. There's a difference between adapting to the mainstream and having absolutely no artistic identity to begin with <3
-
Is ADÉLA already the pop star Tate McRae was supposed to be?
And a girl whispers over the same recycled beat and does an eight-count and suddenly she's the second coming of Britney Spears. I fear you're proving my point ...
-
Is ADÉLA already the pop star Tate McRae was supposed to be?
It's honestly kinda hilarious how Tate has spent the last several years being shoved down our throats as the second coming of Britney Spears, and yet somehow ADÉLA has managed to make more of an impression on me in one album cycle than Tate has throughout her entire career.... Like seriously, what exactly is Tate's appeal outside of being able to shake ass? She's several eras deep and I still couldn't tell you what her artistic identity is supposed to be. Every comeback is the same recycled choreography, the same whispery vocals, the same cheap Britney cosplay and another song about a man who apparently has her fighting for her life. Meanwhile ADÉLA comes along with PRIMA, immediately starts gaining traction on TikTok, has actual personality and manages to make the whole dancing pop girl thing feel interesting again. And unlike Tate, she doesn't seem like she's been assembled to be the next Britney... it's just effortless! I genuinely think ADÉLA has more charisma in a 15-second TikTok than Tate has managed to display in an entire promotional cycle. And that's what's so embarrassing about it. At this point I fear Tate is less the next Britney Spears and more the next Nicole Scherzinger. Except at least Nicole had the Pussycat Dolls.
- Rihanna did something today's pop girls won't ever do
-
Rihanna did something today's pop girls won't ever do
Taylor is probably the closest comparison, but even then, releasing an album every two years with a few rerecordings sprinkled in isn't quite the same as SEVEN studio albums in eight years, each accompanied by actual global smashes. Rihanna released an album in 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2010, 2011 AND 2012. 2008 was the only year she skipped during that entire run. And which of today's MPGs is realistically matching that level of output AND commercial consistency? None!
-
Rihanna did something today's pop girls won't ever do
Exactly, and this is why the album sales argument is so tired to me. Rihanna was putting out albums practically EVERY year, collecting generational smashes and building a catalogue that's still being consumed nearly two decades later. Meanwhile, some of the supposed "album artists" who were outselling her have entire eras that have practically evaporated from public consciousness. Mind you... these are the same girls ATRL was declaring victorious over Rihanna because they managed to shift an extra 100k copies first week in 2011. And where are those albums now?
-
Rihanna did something today's pop girls won't ever do
The way you're inadvertently proving my point. Nobody is arguing Rihanna was some Taylor Swift-level album seller. Seven consecutive albums producing at least one #1 single, 14 Hot 100 #1s overall, and a catalogue of hits spanning multiple shifts in the musical landscape. That's not something you can simply attribute to having a competent A&R department. If selecting demos and releasing albums annually were all it took, literally every label-manufactured pop girl of that period would've replicated her success. Rihanna was cranking out albums practically every year, collecting #1 singles like they were nothing and remaining a constant presence on the charts while the GP somehow never grew tired of her. Meanwhile, half of today's MPGs need a three-year hiatus, six months of teasing and an elaborate rebrand just to release an album that produces one moderate hit before disappearing again. Mind you, Rihanna was doing all of this without needing to manufacture some grand comeback narrative every album cycle. She simply released the music, got the hits and moved on to the next era. Your faves could barely survive that release schedule for two consecutive years, let alone an entire decade!