Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Would you consider Taylor Swift to be a pop puppet?

Featured Replies

I was having this convo with an oomf of mine and I wanted to bring it here. Would you consider Taylor to be a pop puppet? .. By pop puppet, I mean someone who serves the masses and or provides the label with money (not to sound conspiratorial lol) / someone who can churn out simple, digestible pop with little artistic identity, creative input or genuine care for what they're putting out.

Because I feel like her work has been lacking more and more over the years, and I'm not even talking about commercial success. She's obviously bigger than ever, but creatively I feel like there's been a decline. TLOSG honestly felt like a huge flop to me, and even The Tortured Poets Department, for as much praise as it gets, is incredibly boring and repetitive. A lot of the songwriting feels sloppy to me too.

Do you think she's genuinely as involved in her artistry/albums as people make her out to be, or has she become more of a product of the industry at this point? I truly feel like there's a bigger conversation to be had about how much creative control she actually has versus how much of the 'Taylor Swift' brand is being manufactured around her.

taylor-swift-coffee.gif

Edited by chicbitch

  • Replies 27
  • Views 900
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • YourFavoriteWeapon
    YourFavoriteWeapon

    American Life is better than majority of Taylor's albums Madame X is lowkey better than Showgirl too

  • Lord Vetinari
    Lord Vetinari

    Sometimes I find it hard to distinguish Taylor Swift snark from QAnon conspiracies.

  • It's true and you should say it

I mean all artists are products at this point… Beyonce, Billie, Dua, Tate, Rihanna, Adele, Ariana, Selena, Olivia, Gaga, you name it. After all, it's a BUSINESS

blackoutbaby

Edited by TayDuaStan

Sometimes I find it hard to distinguish Taylor Swift snark from QAnon conspiracies.

11 minutes ago, chicbitch said:

I was having this convo with an oomf of mine and I wanted to bring it here. Would you consider Taylor to be a pop puppet? .. By pop puppet, I mean someone who serves the masses and or provides the label with money (not to sound conspiratorial lol) / someone who can churn out simple, digestible pop with little artistic identity, creative input or genuine care for what they're putting out.

Because I feel like her work has been lacking more and more over the years, and I'm not even talking about commercial success. She's obviously bigger than ever, but creatively I feel like there's been a decline. TLOSG honestly felt like a huge flop to me, and even The Tortured Poets Department, for as much praise as it gets, is incredibly boring and repetitive. A lot of the songwriting feels sloppy to me too.

Do you think she's genuinely as involved in her artistry/albums as people make her out to be, or has she become more of a product of the industry at this point? I truly feel like there's a bigger conversation to be had about how much creative control she actually has versus how much of the 'Taylor Swift' brand is being manufactured around her.

taylor-swift-coffee.gif

Idk about that, but if you really think she declined in quality, there's been worse in the history of the music industry, Madonna & Mariah just to name a few (Madonna served panned material like American Life, Hard Candy & Madame X 20 years in)… Mind you, TTPD & Showgirl sound like Mozart stuff in comparison to those slops

zaragoon1

Edited by TayDuaStan

puppet implies she's not in control, doing the label's bidding etc, all of which seems pretty dubious, you not liking something does not make them a puppet

15 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said:

Idk about that, but if you really think she declined in quality, there's been worse in the history of the music industry, Madonna & Mariah just to name a few (Madonna served panned material like American Life, Hard Candy & Madame X 20 years in)… Mind you, TTPD & Showgirl sound like Mozart stuff in comparison to those slops

zaragoon1

American Life is better than majority of Taylor's albums

zaragoon1

Madame X is lowkey better than Showgirl too

Edited by YourFavoriteWeapon

1 minute ago, YourFavoriteWeapon said:

Madame X is lowkey better than Showgirl too

It's true and you should say it

Unless you stan Bjork if someone less well known, no ATRL should be making a thread like this lmao.

She releases one subpar album and suddenly the rest of her work no longer exists? Thats like saying because Lady Gaga released Joanne the rest of her strong body of work is bad or lacks merit, or because Miley Cyrus released Younger Now the rest of her discography is automatically trash. Seems people lack critical thinking skills these days and will just spew absolute nonsense.

Edited by Mezik

No she's definitely not a puppet if anything she is 100% the driver behind the declining quality and the shady business tactics. But at the same time, I don't think having complete control is the ultimate goal for a popstar, it's important to know to delegate some aspects to people that are better than you at certain things, like Beyoncé and Madonna do. Even Britney, who arguably was a puppet has a stronger body of work than Taylor's last decade because she had the best people working for her.

1 hour ago, thisbirdhasflown said:

She's more in charge than she ever has been. rogue2

That part. And it shows

treacherous

She's a unique case because she's simultaneously the puppet and the puppet master.

She is too in charge to be one. A puppet would be someone like the origin of all industry puppets aka Britney Spears.

  • Author
5 hours ago, Lord Vetinari said:

Sometimes I find it hard to distinguish Taylor Swift snark from QAnon conspiracies.

Oh this isn't trying to snark on her at all, I'm just genuinely wondering if she's decided to step back and play a 'puppet' and just hand the label albums that just make money / generic / fans will eat it up. Cuz given her last releases... it's starting to show a pattern. "provides the label with money (not to sound conspiratorial lol) / someone who can churn out simple, digestible pop with little artistic identity, creative input or genuine care for what they're putting out." -- all very true for her in this state of her career. Maybe not as early as one would describe a "puppet" to be --a-la Britney-- but she's kinda falling into that category.

Releasing basic music doesn't make you a puppet - the two things are not synonymous.

In order to be a "pop puppet" you would have to not have control and she has proven time and time again she does have control - she chooses to release radio fodder.

Her father was in finance and had a senior management role in Merrill Lynch. Her mother was a marketing executive.

She did not not sell out to the business interests of the record label and become a pop puppet, she was always focused on the business and marketing side. It was not a sellout, it was more like a corporate merger, so no.

Quite famously not a puppet and has caused multiple industry-changing dramas.

Puppet more like mastermind, no wonder the music industry is substandard due to all her doing!!!!

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.