cityfolk

I was hooked at first listen

TINASHE UPLIFTINGS PROVED A SUCCESS

TINASHE

this classic album

Dear Reader, it really isn't that difficult. Best of luck.

Already done:

Shady AF comeback! Opening with a personal attack - now that's Actually Romantic. You must love your friends CANCELLED!, sis. Most of those were in fact not released in 2010 - very obviously not looking to compare the Spotify streams of Moves Like Jagger. The OP asked for examples against their (mostly true) statement that deluxe singles are less successful, and I provided a handful - I will concede that a few were off the mark (Truth Hurts, the two early 2010's ones). One was even by a fellow eldest daughter (Gracie Abrams) btw (she, too, was the first lamb to the slaughter, but we all dressed up as wolves, and we looked fire fire). Now that's all been said... I'm wearing white (Yeah), so hate all you like (Uh-huh), sis. K bye for now, Sunshine <3

Tinashe getting due recognition

The entire album is fantastic, I'm obsessed

Great point! Patient Zero was up for sale as a standalone before The Showgirl Encore Edition was even announced, so it should indeed be compared to songs like Senorita or DESPECHA! Let's see how the comparisons pan out (Also, Gracie had streamings hits and her album went #2 before TST, I'd hardly say she was a Khia…) Don't girlboss too close to the sun, sis! Keep the essays coming, I like my friends cancelled just like Mrs Kelce

The question was for deluxe tracks performing better than standard album songs. The Swifties in this thread must've been right when they were talking about the literary crisis - and the fans seem to be Patient Zero for this crisis!

Señorita - Shawn Mendes (with Camila Cabello) (Album: Shawn Mendes) DESPECHÁ - Rosalía (Album: MOTOMAMI) That's so true - Gracie Abrams (Album: The Secret Of Us) Feather - Sabrina carpenter (Album: Emails I can't send) Too Sweet - Hozier (Album: Unreal Unearth) Truth Hurts - Lizzo (Album: Cuz I Love You) Moves like jagger - Maroon 5 (Album: hands all over) super bass - Nicki Minaj (Album: pink Friday) Can we get a comparison for all of these like with all the cherry-picked deluxe singles you stated?

The Life of a Showgirl - The Encore (Standing Ovation - Standing in my Cardigan in the Cabin in the Candlelight on Stage Edition)