Hi I'm your very unbiased guest judge. Former host and former mainstay judge.. Allison Harvard - @Outbound Your simple, for me, is simple in the most basic way. The dramatic as well is just really basic. A little too vanilla. The positives: she gives good face in both photos. Guinevere van Seenus - @Lemon A great simple photo. The emotionless expression juxtaposed with the cigarette is really impactful to me. When I opened this.. I was shocked.. this is drama! Joan Smalls - @Element I think your simple misses the mark.. it's pretty intense in my eyes. I'd say it's more dramatic than your actual dramatic photo which is falling into a very corny/campy category. Not for me. Sasha Pivovarova - @Opulent These are both gorgeous photos that hit the mark just enough for me. I like the contrast with the editing and pops of colors here. Very impactful for me. Sora Choi - @petty I love both photos. I love that both photos are somewhat placed similarly with tiny adjustments for drama. Could it have been taken further? Maybe. Kate Moss - @Young In Love Your simple is incredible.. could've brought you further, but the dramatic photo is bad. Good luck everyone!