Both songs deal with a similar theme, but which song did it better? Discuss

 

Love both songs but there's something compelling about Taylor's intonation in IHIH

Edited August 9, 20242 yr by YellowRibbon

the one that doesn't have the lyric about missing the 1830s.

the one that doesn't have the lyric about missing the 1830s. 

the one that doesn't have the lyric about missing the 1830s. [3]

the one that has the lyric about breaking patterns 

 

saturn is in another league compared to that nursery rhyme 

I was going to explain the IHIH lyric but I stopped typing and realised it's not worth it due to the lack of media literacy on ATRL.

 

She never says she misses the 1830s btw. A simple Google search of the lyrics will show that. 

 

Anyway I slightly prefer Saturn. A better song, but I love both.

both are one of my faves from their respective albums so idk how what that says about my life 

 

but i'll go with Saturn as i resonate with it more

 

(wait i just realized Saturn isn't in SOS )

 

 

Edited August 9, 20242 yr by Sabrina Carpenter

31 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

I was going to explain the IHIH lyric but I stopped typing and realised it's not worth it due to the lack of media literacy on ATRL.

 

She never says she misses the 1830s btw. A simple Google search of the lyrics will show that. 

 

Anyway I slightly prefer Saturn. A better song, but I love both.

No one cares if that's what she meant.

 

impact ≠ intent

Just now, yonsé said:

No one cares if that's what she meant.

 I was going to explain the IHIH lyric but I stopped typing and realised it's not worth it due the lack of media literacy on ATRL.

Thank you for proving my point 

Saturn is one of my favs of the year