A stanbase that is very fickle when it comes to supporting or defending their fav.  A stanbase that trashes, excessively criticizes or ridicules their fav more than you would expect them to.

 

ETA: There is nothing wrong with criticizing your fav. I think it's healthy to voice your opinion respectfully and not be a "yes" stan. Our favs are not perfect. None of them. But I think we can all agree bashing their every move is disloyal af.

Edited March 3, 20242 yr by Mons†erMuscle™

Idk about disloyal and all that but I’ve seen Ariana stans that genuinely hate her

most the fanbases listed are very loyal and dedicated. navy and monsters are [rightfully] the most critical. 

How can you be "disloyal" to Rih if you're still stanning her after 8 years of no new album? 

Idk, they all seem very loyal to me. 

Edited March 3, 20242 yr by awong918

Monsters 💯 they're useless 

Hive. Renaissance bigger than BIK feels diabolical 

how is Monsters winning when there was an ATRL narrative saying we forced ourselves to like Joanne

17 minutes ago, wantedyoutogrow said:

Idk about disloyal and all that but I’ve seen Ariana stans that genuinely hate her

Arianators added.

Little Monsters is the answer. I was also a fan of her but growing up made me realize she is full of sht   i’m still excited for a new album and i loved chromatica but i just don’t like the woman. Why should anyone be loyal to her when she always finds a way to lie?

 

Never saw an artist who promises so much and gives nothing in return. Why did she post that chromatica ball tour dvd post on instagram for example?  

katy cats because they all jumped ship

monsters have gone tru a lot, i would not call them disloyal, they are on the right to be fed up

12 minutes ago, Smarticle said:

how is Monsters winning when there was an ATRL narrative saying we forced ourselves to like Joanne

Was that when Joanne first dropped? Ask them how they feel about Joanne now.

2 minutes ago, Funnyfatty said:

Little Monsters is the answer. I was also a fan of her but growing up made me realize she is full of sht   i’m still excited for a new album and i loved chromatica but i just don’t like the woman. Why should anyone be loyal to her when she always finds a way to lie?

 

Never saw an artist who promises so much and gives nothing in return. Why did she post that chromatica ball tour dvd post on instagram for example?  

Perhaps because her stans are so critical of everything she does or does not do, she loses interest in giving us these nice things. I know I would. 

It would be between Katycats and monsters 

Edited March 3, 20242 yr by Taeyong

People saying monsters when we're still going strong after 16 years 

Lambs and Monsters are bad about this. I think Lambs take it to the next level of criticizing though 

2 minutes ago, PoisonCandy said:

People saying monsters when we're still going strong after 16 years 

I thought the question was about excessive criticism 

arianators are TERRIBLE i’ve never seen a fandom get 6 albums in less than a decade yet be so greedy and ungrateful about the artist and their output cause they aren’t doing the same numbers as their peak  ariana twitter has just been complaint after complaint since 2020 i genuinely think they all hate her 

Edited March 3, 20242 yr by ariesgroove

Just now, suburbannature said:

Lambs and Monsters are bad about this. I think Lambs take it to the next level of criticizing though 

Aren’t you calling her moo?  

 

I don’t see a reason to disrespect Mariah. She has many albums. After Caution she released many eps and a compilation of all her hidden songs. I respect her more than anyone else. 
 

Gaga is a liar. 

2 minutes ago, suburbannature said:

I thought the question was about excessive criticism 

Correct.

1 minute ago, suburbannature said:

I thought the question was about excessive criticism 

Hmm. Could be. I wouldn't call that disloyalty though.

5 minutes ago, Funnyfatty said:

Aren’t you calling her moo?  

 

I don’t see a reason to disrespect Mariah. She has many albums. After Caution she released many eps and a compilation of all her hidden songs. I respect her more than anyone else. 
 

Gaga is a liar. 

No one said there’s a reason to. That’s the point - the base is over the top critical these days expecting her to release with the frequency (and vocals) of her prime years. Hyperfixating on live notes. Etc  

Monsters

 

they only like Gaga when she’s winning awards or getting #1s on billboard so they can feel like they’ve accomplished something in life.
When she’s flopping they drag her.

43 minutes ago, wantedyoutogrow said:

Idk about disloyal and all that but I’ve seen Ariana stans that genuinely hate her

They’re just cringy. There’s one where someone said “bit*h we’re trying to get you a 3rd #1” and she was like okay

 

15 minutes ago, Karla Cabello said:

monsters have gone tru a lot, i would not call them disloyal, they are on the right to be fed up

What have they been through?  not more than Britney fans, lams, janet fans or even Madonna fans  

49 minutes ago, Smarticle said:

how is Monsters winning when there was an ATRL narrative saying we forced ourselves to like Joanne

OP is a cupcake mad because we don’t like LinkedInGa’s Kardashian ass

26 minutes ago, She-Rah said:

Monsters

 

they only like Gaga when she’s winning awards or getting #1s on billboard so they can feel like they’ve accomplished something in life.
When she’s flopping they drag her.

She smashes with good music and flops with horrible music. The same woman who released Bad Romance also released PI and Stupid hoe as a lead single and both DESERVINGLY flopped. Terrible songs.