Since it’s November and the year is over, what’s some of the best Girl group songs I may have missed or ignored?! Right now I’m thinking of my year end rankings. 

I feel like the time this thread gets fun is till Baby Monsters debut

9 minutes ago, gigantopithecus said:

Are these the top 5 main vocalists of each gen if we group main vocals who are in the same group as one spot (like Ningning/Winter taking one spot)? I'm not as familiar with 4th gen so my list might be way off for that gen

 

For ggs:

 

2nd gen - Hyolyn, Taeyeon, Eunji, Luna, Jea. Hard to pick just 5 and I feel like someone else might rank above Jea?

3rd gen - Wendy, Solji, Solar/Wheein, Yuju, and picking a 5th is also hard. Choa, Seunghee, or Kei?

4th gen - Ningning/Winter, Lily, Monday, Miyeon/Minnie, and ???

 

I'm way less familiar with bgs so my list might be off but from ones I do know.. for bgs:

 

2nd gen - Kyuhyun/rest of SJ main vocals, Jonghyun/Onew, Yoseob, Hongki, Changmin??

3rd gen - Baekhyun/Chen/Kyungsoo, Eunkwang, Taeil/Doyoung/the rest of NCT main vocals, DK/Seungkwan, MJ. I feel like I'm possibly forgetting some important players here

4th gen - Not familiar enough

 

Yes theres probably lead vocalists who could stomp on some of this list but this is just for those with the official title So no need to bring them up

i like both but miyeon and minnie doesn’t really belong there, especially the latter 

Just now, hallucinate said:

i like both but miyeon and minnie doesn’t really belong there, especially the latter 

Then let me remove them I was worried about that but I didn't want to have two blank spots just bc I'm so uneducated

13 minutes ago, gigantopithecus said:

Are these the top 5 main vocalists of each gen if we group main vocals who are in the same group as one spot (like Ningning/Winter taking one spot)? I'm not as familiar with 4th gen so my list might be way off for that gen

 

For ggs:

 

2nd gen - Hyolyn, Taeyeon, Eunji, Luna, Jea. Hard to pick just 5 and I feel like someone else might rank above Jea?

3rd gen - Wendy, Solji, Solar/Wheein, Yuju, and picking a 5th is also hard. Choa, Seunghee, or Kei?

4th gen - Ningning/Winter, Lily, Monday, Miyeon/Minnie, and ???

 

I'm way less familiar with bgs so my list might be off but from ones I do know.. for bgs:

 

2nd gen - Kyuhyun/rest of SJ main vocals, Jonghyun/Onew, Yoseob, Hongki, Changmin??

3rd gen - Baekhyun/Chen/Kyungsoo, Eunkwang, Taeil/Doyoung/the rest of NCT main vocals, DK/Seungkwan, MJ. I feel like I'm possibly forgetting some important players here

4th gen - Not familiar enough

 

Yes theres probably lead vocalists who could stomp on some of this list but this is just for those with the official title So no need to bring them up

4th?/5th? gen BG - RIIZE Sohee

 

 

Spoiler

 

 

1 minute ago, TheCal said:

4th?/5th? gen BG - RIIZE Sohee

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

You know what? I'll add him! Little RIIZers, your work is paying off

 

16 minutes ago, Gorjesspazze9 said:

Since it’s November and the year is over, what’s some of the best Girl group songs I may have missed or ignored?! Right now I’m thinking of my year end rankings. 

If you're including bsides and haven't listened to the IVE bsides, give these a listen (wait for the chorus to hit in Holy Moly before judging)

 

11 minutes ago, gigantopithecus said:

You know what? I'll add him! Little RIIZers, your work is paying off

 

Oh SM has at least one Top 5 Main Vocalist for both ggs and bgs in every gen now!

 

Hype Boy, what are you doing here? 

Newjeans with 4 songs, the smashery 

Surprised Queencard didn't make it.  

 

 

 

Edited November 21, 20232 yr by katyberry

9 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said:

Hype Boy, what are you doing here? 

Newjeans with 4 songs, the smashery 

Surprised Queencard didn't make it.  

My new fave, Jungbieber, at #1  

13 minutes ago, katyberry said:

 

 

 

I love how everybody is on the same page with this I once again have no clue what an SM song description means though

 

 

 

I'm sorry but the ate ate, I would stan them if didn't find stupid af stanning npc it's giving otakus being in love with fictional characters 

Edited November 21, 20232 yr by Selenasworld

29 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said:

Hype Boy, what are you doing here? 

Newjeans with 4 songs, the smashery 

Surprised Queencard didn't make it.  

I Am deserves that My favorite IVE title track. Also surprised by Queencard not making it. One of my fav comebacks this year and I heard it all over TikTok

 

Standing Next to You deserves Seven's numbers. The superior Jungkook track

 

bts on hiatus, half of them in the military

and still, kings and presidents will always mention them

 

 

 

 

 

Jungbieber needs his Despacito ASAP!!! I'm shaking  

 

44 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said:

Hype Boy, what are you doing here? 

Newjeans with 4 songs, the smashery 

Surprised Queencard didn't make it.  

Ive needs to go back with their pop excellence bops. I am SOTY

1 hour ago, gigantopithecus said:

Are these the top 5 main vocalists of each gen if we group main vocals who are in the same group as one spot (like Ningning/Winter taking one spot)? I'm not as familiar with 4th gen so my list might be way off for that gen

 

For ggs:

 

2nd gen - Hyolyn, Taeyeon, Eunji, Luna, Jea. Hard to pick just 5 and I feel like someone else might rank above Jea?

3rd gen - Wendy, Solji, Solar/Wheein, Yuju, and picking a 5th is also hard. Choa, Seunghee, or Kei?

4th gen - Ningning/Winter, Lily, Monday, ??, and ???

 

I'm way less familiar with bgs so my list might be off but from ones I do know.. for bgs:

 

2nd gen - Kyuhyun/rest of SJ main vocals, Jonghyun/Onew, Yoseob, Hongki, Changmin??

3rd gen - Baekhyun/Chen/Kyungsoo, Eunkwang, Taeil/Doyoung/the rest of NCT main vocals, DK/Seungkwan, MJ. I feel like I'm possibly forgetting some important players here

4th gen - Sohee (added!), idk enough to add anyone else

 

Yes theres probably lead vocalists who could stomp on some of this list but this is just for those with the official title So no need to bring them up

4th gen gg I would swan (purple kiss)

1 hour ago, gigantopithecus said:

Are these the top 5 main vocalists of each gen if we group main vocals who are in the same group as one spot (like Ningning/Winter taking one spot)? I'm not as familiar with 4th gen so my list might be way off for that gen

 

For ggs:

 

2nd gen - Hyolyn, Taeyeon, Eunji, Luna, Jea. Hard to pick just 5 and I feel like someone else might rank above Jea?

3rd gen - Wendy, Solji, Solar/Wheein, Yuju, and picking a 5th is also hard. Choa, Seunghee, or Kei?

4th gen - Ningning/Winter, Lily, Monday, ??, and ???

 

I'm way less familiar with bgs so my list might be off but from ones I do know.. for bgs:

 

2nd gen - Kyuhyun/rest of SJ main vocals, Jonghyun/Onew, Yoseob, Hongki, Changmin??

3rd gen - Baekhyun/Chen/Kyungsoo, Eunkwang, Taeil/Doyoung/the rest of NCT main vocals, DK/Seungkwan, MJ. I feel like I'm possibly forgetting some important players here

4th gen - Sohee (added!), idk enough to add anyone else

 

Yes theres probably lead vocalists who could stomp on some of this list but this is just for those with the official title So no need to bring them up

Add Liz to the 4th gen gg list sis, she’s way better technically than Minnie imo

wait I forgot the girlies from Drramcatcher and Purple Kiss. Yup they’re up there.

 

1 hour ago, hallucinate said:

i like both but miyeon and minnie doesn’t really belong there, especially the latter 

I mean Miyeon is pretty good though, she’s technically more sound than a huge chunk of 4th gen girlies. We just haven’t heard a lot of her yet live.

 

Edited November 22, 20232 yr by Witnessed ET

3 minutes ago, Spears_Stan said:

4th gen gg I would swan (purple kiss)

Oh yes looked her up and she is ADDED now

 

8 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Add Liz to the 4th gen gg list sis, she’s way better technically than Minnie imo

wait I forgot the girlies from Drramcatcher and Purple Kiss. Yup they’re up there.

 

I mean Miyeon is pretty good though, she’s technically more sound than a huge chunk of 4th gen girlies. We just haven’t heard a lot of her yet live.

 

I'll add Liz too and now we have a complete top 5 Is Dreamcatcher 4th gen though? I thought they were 3rd but if they're 4th, I've heard those vocals and I'm sure their main deserves a spot

5 minutes ago, gigantopithecus said:

Oh yes looked her up and she is ADDED now

 

 

Her solo is very good

 

There are too many good vocalists in Gen 2 to choose from

 

Taeyeon, Jessica, Seohyun, Luna, Eunji, Solji, Jea, Narsha, Gain, Hyolyn, Soyu, Jieun, Raina

IU, Ailee, Lee Hi (soloists)

 

 

Gen 4, on the other hand, you can't count more than 5 

5 hours ago, DelRey said:

Me when I bought 2 copies of Birthday cake version, that circular box was cheap af but I sold both at the end

I actually thought the Cake version was cute  

I will agree that they were cheap, but they looked more expensive than these ugly bags

1 hour ago, gigantopithecus said:

Are these the top 5 main vocalists of each gen if we group main vocals who are in the same group as one spot (like Ningning/Winter taking one spot)? I'm not as familiar with 4th gen so my list might be way off for that gen

 

For ggs:

 

2nd gen - Hyolyn, Taeyeon, Eunji, Luna, Jea. Hard to pick just 5 and I feel like someone else might rank above Jea?

3rd gen - Wendy, Solji, Solar/Wheein, Yuju, and picking a 5th is also hard. Choa, Seunghee, or Kei?

4th gen - Ningning/Winter, Lily, Monday, Swan (she has been ADDED), and Liz (also an edited addition to the list)

 

I'm way less familiar with bgs so my list might be off but from ones I do know.. for bgs:

 

2nd gen - Kyuhyun/rest of SJ main vocals, Jonghyun/Onew, Yoseob, Hongki, Changmin??

3rd gen - Baekhyun/Chen/Kyungsoo, Eunkwang, Taeil/Doyoung/the rest of NCT main vocals, DK/Seungkwan, MJ. I feel like I'm possibly forgetting some important players here

4th gen - Sohee (added!), idk enough to add anyone else

 

Yes theres probably lead vocalists who could stomp on some of this list but this is just for those with the official title So no need to bring them up

 

According to this video:

#1 NMIXX Lily

#2 NMIXX Haewon

#3 AESPA Ningning

#4 NMIXX Sullyoon

#5 IVE Liz

#6 AESPA Winter

#7 PURPLE KISS Goeun

#8 AESPA Karina

#9 PURPLE KISS Swan

#10 NEWJEANS Hanni

Seunghan is taking an hiatus from the group. 

 

 

 

 

Edited November 22, 20232 yr by Mitsuki