34 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

But does Rihanna have an album credited as « Rihanna & ____ » ? If not, then you’re off topic!

And... Talk That Talk and ANTI both have 2 features only (out of 14 and 16 tracks, respectively).

 

You just embarrassed yourself a bit because when I said 4 million I was speaking about the CSPC figure, not pure sales. Talk That Talk, Unapologetic & Anti did 9.4M, 9.5M & 6.1M, respectively, as of July 2019.

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

What a living legend

Gaga will be the last mpg to cross the 30m pure album sales

3 minutes ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

Edited December 23, 20205 yr by Rhiannon

53 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

But does Rihanna have an album credited as « Rihanna & ____ » ? If not, then you’re off topic!

And... Talk That Talk and ANTI both have 2 features only (out of 14 and 16 tracks, respectively).

 

You just embarrassed yourself a bit because when I said 4 million I was speaking about the CSPC figure, not pure sales. Talk That Talk, Unapologetic & Anti did 9.4M, 9.5M & 6.1M, respectively, as of July 2019.

ANTi only did 6.1M?  I guess this era wasn't that big as someone try to prove. 


OT: Joanne and Chromatica will surpass 3m in next update. 

53 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

Collaborating with somebody else on a song and doing an entire album with someone else are two very different things. But even if you remove the orphan portion of Rihanna’s total she’d still be at nearly 80M. 

 

OT: Impressive career start  

Collaborating with popular rappers and producers is something totally different than collaborating with an ACTOR  

 

you truly don’t feel any shame when you say things like this

28 minutes ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

Wait  

37 minutes ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

omg 

so that Rih stan wants to claims songs having features but somehow are against album doing the same. How very convenient and specific 

The caucacity of that Rihanna stan OGH 

 

OT: Her numbers are extremely good for someone who debuted in 2008 (her actual breakthrough was in early 2009 even). 

2 hours ago, istan4badgalriri said:

Collaborating with somebody else on a song and doing an entire album with someone else are two very different things. But even if you remove the orphan portion of Rihanna’s total she’d still be at nearly 80M. 

 

OT: Impressive career start  

Combined, Gaga’s Grammy-winning collab albums account for a smaller proportion of her total sales than Rihanna’s orphan tracks, the majority of which are collabs. So this argument is pointless and just shows that you’re in here to misread numbers and attempt to be shady. 2016 is so long ago...
 

OT: Gaga’s 2018 release has skyrocketed past every female release since 25 other than Billie’s debut era  

People truly wants to be shady here when Gaga sold 10M sps from ASIB and Chromatica WW alone
 

not to mention her whole catalog got a boost after ASIB  

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

 mess, some ppl need to learn to let it go

-

Impressive

Edited December 23, 20205 yr by Yanko

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

 Easily the post of the year. Simple, to the point, straightforward, and in a couple of sentence BURIED the "solo!!!" argument Gaga haters have spammed  for a year. Literally wasted a year of their lives typing arguments that you refuted in 2 lines. 

Edited December 23, 20205 yr by perfillusion

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

Rih'd ha! 

2 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

Read the uninformed high horse orphan avon lady stans for filth honeeyy. Let them have it. Destroy them.yess Gagah slayy mamah

3 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

Edited December 23, 20205 yr by Artur

OMG Chromatica passing Joanne in less than a year and ASIB in its way to 10M 

 

3 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

chile

 

3 hours ago, Zs2236 said:

Sweetie. You should be the last one talking about solo. Orphan for your fave is around 20 million sps. That’s more than her biggest era that had a rerelease. Remove that and bam. Down to the mid seventies.... so keep it cute 

omg 

13 hours ago, katyhudson said:

0 studio albums crossed 5M since 2011 is A one era wonder indeed, just as Alanis and Norah Jones but less respected.

 

Although, are we surprised Sis?

 

Even Pink, who has NEVER been an MPG according to this forum, is dominating and will be ahead with her next release. 
 

 

OT: I never knew “TD” was so high in CSPC. - Truly the era of the ‘10’s in North America. “OOTB” surprised me also. 
 

 

31 minutes ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

 

Although, are we surprised Sis?

 

Even Pink, who has NEVER been an MPG according to this forum, is dominating and will be ahead with her next release. 
 

 

OT: I never knew “TD” was so high in CSPC. - Truly the era of the ‘10’s in North America. “OOTB” surprised me also. 
 

 

Are you okay?

 

Why do you keep discussing about others in your posts when this thread is clearly about Lady Gaga and not Pink or Katy Perry? If you want to discuss others make a separate thread in the base or sumn  

 

OT: the way she added 14 million units since her last update, ASIB a true global FORCE 

14 hours ago, jijie101 said:

Born This Way is bigger than any Katy album sans TD, yes including PRISM. And Alanis’s Jagged Little Pill is bigger than Katy’s whole existence, let’s not. 

 

And yet they have the nerve... The lack of self-awareness is stunning