$ebert

I think you just answered your own question, and the answer is no.

End ha People could never discredit Gaga, she has talent and success. @Ryan can we close this thread?

I love Britney but that song is horrible, I'm glad she is still making hits, she's a LEGEND. At the end of the day she IS Britney Spears, get your coins queen

We love to see bad people flop, it's what they deserve

When he said "girl" I was like…what

What excuses? Y'all are desperately comparing a jazz album to a studio album, that's fact Aren't you the one who complained about Katy being "bullied" the hypocrisy

I've never changed my narrative, stop with that nonsense argument lol I am not delusional to say she hasn't one of the strongest fan bases out there, that's why she's selling albums, that's a fact. People don't care about her new material, that's another fact. Let's wait for it to drop then lol

Still? Happy mistake didn't get any of the things I listed lol Apparently her show in Rock in Rio didn't have an impact on US, Brazil nor the world, remember it's a livestream show worldwide, you're trying to make it like it's a little show lol And my narrative does not change at all, I still agree with the irrelevance of the VMAs, it's nowhere to be what it is used to, but +4M people watched it, so, no one cared about her? Did she bombed? Yes, and… Gaga will always have talent, just look at the #1 song.

Nop, I'm pretty sure Stupid Love performed better than any song from 143, nice try tho! "huge Spotify support" yet still jazz, not appealing to most of the GP, released with no promo other than IG posts… Katy had the VMA's, Rock in Rio, WW had a radio deal, she had tons of promo compared to most girls, the mental gymnastics y'all do is something to be studied.

I think they know their fave is one of the most talented performers out there, so they put the bar way too high. Not always pays off tho. I think is so hard to make jazz music a hit, the EP is cute I use some songs on it

Are you surprised she managed to sell the same amount of copies as her last album? At the end of the day that only proves two things: - She has a big fan base. - Her fan base is loyal and still support her. The weeks ahead are the ones who really show what the GP thinks about it. So we'll see if she stays stable or drops down.

Did she get in a fight with YMCMB too? Im actually shocked they would sign her, after coming for Beyoncé

I agree, as I said before, she's good for a throwback. Even tho I think she should try to make people somewhat interested in her new material, I know it's hard cause it's not pleasant to listen but damn, she is not even trying anymore. Did you like the performance or what? Let's not get off topic sis, share your thoughts on it.

That's huge promo (+ VMAs and Rock in Rio). And she wasted it performing only two songs from her album I guess she knows the new music is not good and people don't care for her material anymore. She's good for a throwback tho!

There was not even one reference to her… I was saying this is not Gaga's main project, it's just a cute EP for the fans and the quality is really high, I actually love most of the songs. If fans wanted to start fan base wars they should wait for the studio album. Literally not even directed to any particular fan base, there are swifties, Bey hive and Katy fans here making fun of her numbers, like chill, go for a walk or something. I know Gaga is gonna bring it when doing mainstream music, I can't wait for her numbers to come out and shut their mouths

No y'all getting BRAVE. I can't wait for her studio album to debut to see what you're gonna say about it At least this EP has quality music, not every pop girl can say that. Yes Gaga educate them

Let's be serious for a minute. To claim GP is not here for her, while her song is at the top of the charts is ridiculous honestly. It's just not everyone's genre, I highly doubt she was expecting the album to chart.

Look at the charts, DWAS is up there. There's your answer. She can do both, successful and acclaimed, others can't even have one of those.

You know what makes me love and respect an artist like her? She's not afraid of releasing a project that is not mainstream music, not afraid of having "bad numbers" cause it's not intended to chart, shes such a creative soul with a unique vision. I love an artist like her and Kesha who can release music like that (Gag Order) to make statements and release their creativity

G.U.Y comes to mind. Also, I LOVE AINIY's intro, it gets me to a peaceful state of mind.

I love her but fame is too much for her. I don't even think she wants it, it makes me wonder if she actually does. I mean, she cancelled shows to do a VMA performance, so, she wants the spotlight but can't handle it? It's confusing, I hope she gets well soon, I believe she should take a long break and let her peak go away so she can come back as an indie artist.

YESSS!! Kesha Do you guys know if it's a live-streamed event?

Talent ALWAYS win

Well last time she got asked about him she answered in the worst way possible so I'm not surprised she wants to ban those questions. She should stand by her choice tho. Stupid people make stupid mistakes.

Es lo que merece Reinota I will be watching, kinda excited for this.