PCD

VS

KATSEYE

6 member girl groups from different eras but who is the better dancer / performer and has the sharper move sets?

The LA burlesque dance troupe turned Nicole lead pop group or the rising multiethnic girl group trained under the Kpop methodology?

discuss

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Odette Violet

PCD hand down, they're mature, sexy and put on a decent performing, unlike the other high-school cheerleader group.

You set them up with that video. The distinction here is that while both groups are full of dancers + Nicole and Lara are both generational talents, the other katseye members are good to great singers and not random dancers, all katseye members are overqualified to lead a group separately. This boomer forum will still go for the throwback though.

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Sheep

Just now, Sheep said:

You set them up with that video. The distinction here is that while both grouos are full of dancers + Nicole and Lara are both generational talents, the other katseye members are good to great singers and not random dancers.

sis were talking about dancing here

Lara is gorgeous but to put her on the same level as Nicole is kinda delulu. She struggle on live at times

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Odette Violet

2 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

sis were talking about dancing here

Lara is gorgeous but to put her on the same level as Nicole is kinda delulu. She struggle on live at times

The only thing Lara struggles with is not stealing the show

You said performance/ choreo and vocals are a part of that. You have thousands of posts saying that's the only important thing in performance in the kpop base. These girls will be in stadiums by 2027

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Sheep

Just now, Sheep said:

The only thing Lara struggles with is not stealing the show

You said performance/ choreo and vocals are a part of that.

Nicole can sing circles around Lara let's not. Ms girl needs to hit those notes live

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Odette Violet

Just now, Odette Violet said:

Nicole can sing circles around Lara let's not. Ms girl needs to hit those notes live

Lara isnt the only singer and has no issues singing live dddd. Nicole is better at singing but they're both better than all but a few pop girls.

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Sheep

Just now, Sheep said:

Lara isnt the only singer and has no issues singing live dddd

Well she's supposed to be the Nicole / Beyonce of Katseye as I was told? dddd

anyway pls stick to the topic

Buttons alone > the tik tok dancers existence

6 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

Well she's supposed to be the Nicole / Beyonce of Katseye as I was told? dddd

anyway pls stick to the topic

Lara can sing some of Beyonce's hardest songs off the cuff. Manon is the worst singer in the group by far and is still holding a tune here. Do i need to remind you how our fav sings this song? Fresh young rookies without even an album out and they're already this good

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Sheep

Katseye are immediately better than Nicole and her backup dancers + Melody's screaming ass let's be serious girl

PCD kinda sucks ass because Nicole has to carry on her own vocally and it often shows, she kinda sounds like a warrior half the time and not in a good way tbh

48 minutes ago, Sheep said:

Lara can sing some of Beyonce's hardest songs off the cuff. Manon is the worst singer in the group by far and is still holding a tune here. Do i need to remind you how our fav sings this song? Fresh young rookies without even an album out and they're already this good

again how is this relevant at the topic being about dancing? I can post multiple videos of just Nicole singing but that would embarass all of katseye nnnn

6 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said:

Katseye are immediately better than Nicole and her backup dancers + Melody's screaming ass let's be serious girl

well this is about dancing for the most part but even Melody screaming ass is infinitely better than the girls not named Lara and Sophia

have you even heard her sing?

4 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

again how is this relevant at the topic being about dancing? I can post multiple videos of just Nicole singing but that would embarass all of katseye nnnn

well this is about dancing for the most part but even Melody screaming ass is infinitely better than the girls not named Lara and Sophia

have you even heard her sing?

So is it off topic or not?

Just now, Sheep said:

So is it off topic or not?

There is no video of Nicole without her back up dancers in the OP right?

I'm being generous enough not to post her singing videos cause none of this girls stands a chance

They both suck.

2 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

There is no video of Nicole without her back up dancers in the OP right?

I'm being generous enough not to post her singing videos cause none of this girls stands a chance

Right so singing is on topic and you just wanna get pouty because your set up thread failed on the grounds of 1 singer vs 5

The fact you need to hide behind a Tony award winner who last charted 20 years ago and not your real favs who can hardly sing Spicy live unassisted speaks volumes.

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Sheep

6 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

again how is this relevant at the topic being about dancing? I can post multiple videos of just Nicole singing but that would embarass all of katseye nnnn

well this is about dancing for the most part but even Melody screaming ass is infinitely better than the girls not named Lara and Sophia

have you even heard her sing?

She has the tonality of a horse and is straining most of the notes she's singing and this is after years without needing to perform and having plentiful vocal rest. The vocal line in Katseye solo tf out of her, not to mention literally everybody in Katseye is a better dancer than all of the PCD

Just now, Sheep said:

Right so singing is on topic and you just wanna get pouty because your set up thread failed on the grounds of 1 singer vs 5

the 5 singers in question

If Katseye have 5 then all PCD can sing then

1 minute ago, lgaga1fan said:

Katseye is a better dancer than all of the PCD

you should've stop right here cause imagine saying the other katseye girls can sing better than her

Just now, Odette Violet said:

you should've stop right here cause imagine saying the other katseye girls can sing better than her

"the vocal line in katseye solo tf out of her" is what i said and i'll stand by it. let's read before quoting, you deliberately took a quote out of context.

Just now, lgaga1fan said:

"the vocal line in katseye solo tf out of her" is what i said and i'll stand by it. let's read before quoting, you deliberately took a quote out of context.

there is only 2 in the vocal line. I mean why go for Melody if Nicole can also tf out them all

1 minute ago, Odette Violet said:

there is only 2 in the vocal line. I mean why go for Melody if Nicole can also tf out them all

kpop stan discovers soloists

Just now, Sheep said:

kpop stan discovers soloists

they sure made it sound like the vocal line has Beyonce, Kelly and Michelle in it

they can't go against Nicole so they have to pit the whole "vocal line" against the second best singer

Just now, Odette Violet said:

they sure made it sound like the vocal line has Beyonce, Kelly and Michelle in it

they can't go against Nicole so they have to pit the whole "vocal line" against the second best singer

No group you stan could outsing katesye so you have to cross continents and go back 20 years to let your pressed thoughts out

Edited December 3, 2025Dec 3 by Sheep