Across all 31 songs there seems to be a lot of witchcraft related themes as well as the criminal/ escaped prisoner themes. Although I really enjoy the album the 31 tracks together are daunting. I feel like this could have been down into an album themed with the folky witchy songs and the guilty as sin, daddy I love him etc songs. 
 

if you were to rearrange the album to be more digestible how would you?

I'd split PTSD from The Psychology and we have a winner.

The Tortured Poets Department (Single)

1. Fortnight (feat. Post Malone)

 

Just treat them as two separate albums, then throw TTPD in the trash bin. Keep The Anthology.

I am not gonna lie this might be her first album that I will have to make a playlist out of because it's just too much.

 

Maybe if she released The Anthology as a separate album on streaming services, like a side B it would feel less overwhelming idk.

Folklore and Evermore are essentially the same thing but they're split into two different moods and it just works.

I have a redux playlist for when I want to listen to both parts, but not the whole thing. I cut 10 songs from it for this playlist, but I will probably always just go to the standard or the anthology and listen to that version from front to back. 

 

This tracklist I made earlier and organized it to tell some kind of narrative. 

 

I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can) - Spotted new interest who is not good for them

Guilty As Sin? - Obsessed about them in their mind

Down Bad - Starting fling with toxic person

Fortnight - Quick smitted fling

But Daddy I Love Him - Relationship with others impacted, response

My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys - Relationship turmoils, person moving on to other people; infidelity 

How Did It End? - End of relationship

I Look in People's Windows - Pining for that person, dealing with the loss

The Black Dog - Realizing that 

Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus - Infidelity haunting

I Hate It Here - Realization that she needs to get out of this place

Fresh Out the Slammer - Reflection on the relationship

imgonnagetyouback - Pines for revenge

The Albatross - Gets revenge

Florida!!! - Goes somewhere else

1. My Boy Only Breaks His Favourite Toys

2. But Daddy I Love Him

3. Umbrella (Rihanna cover)

1. Florida !!!

2. Florida ???

3. Florida (Florence solo version)

4. Florida (sped up)

5. Florida (dancing witch elvira remix)