This is so sad. The album is great...

Will Lover be above it this week

The one that got away, but not for 873 ppl 

Edited September 10, 20206 yr by Fetch

Not surprised, the album is GARBAGE .

6 hours ago, DanceFreak said:

Not bad for an indie artist.

Norman ****ing Rockwell! first two weeks: 3-9

8 hours ago, ReverseWarholian said:

I thought this would maybe avoid a Madame X or Liberation sized decline since there are no tour bundles involved but I guess people just genuinely don't care. It'll probably do like 9k max second week 

Some of her delusional fans dragged Liberation's second week's sales and explicitly told me that Smile would never have a similar trend because it didn't have tour bundles at all. Well, well, well.

10 hours ago, Rama said:

There were more COVID deaths in the States this week than people buying Smile

 

The scream I let out I-  

 

 

 

If this was five or six years ago this thread would have like 200 pages  

9 hours ago, Extinctkid said:

NCT outsold and nobody even knows them in the US 

Sis.... NCT has an actual fanbase. 
 

This isn’t even going to sell 100k when it’s all said and done omg. 

12 hours ago, Rama said:

There were more COVID deaths in the States this week than people buying Smile

 

13 hours ago, Rama said:

There were more COVID deaths in the States this week than people buying Smile

 

You think this is funny?

Enjoy the WP

873 

Madame X saved

Only 4 pages? 
ATRLers don’t even care enough to drag her now

 

Also it’s what she deserves for releasing garbage after garbage

Hands down the biggest flop for a MPG

 

17 minutes ago, Serendipity said:

Hands down the biggest flop for a MPG

Making history.

Tbh, I was expecting worse

I knew it was over for Katy the minute I heard Smile the song and saw those atrocious clown visuals. No ma’am. Choices.

37 minutes ago, Chainsmoker said:

Tbh, I was expecting worse

Worse than 863 in a second week? I mean 

 

 

 

This album is called Clown album which is exactly what it is not Smile being the title. Her fall from the Top was quick and steep. American idol ruined her career she was too in people's faces not for her music but for her California barbie personality which turned people off. Besides she just came from her biggest flop era with Witness.

so what is the truth 
 

 

 

10 hours ago, Aviana said:

Only 4 pages? 
ATRLers don’t even care enough to drag her now

 

Also it’s what she deserves for releasing garbage after garbage

 

12 hours ago, Petty Bourgeoisie said:

If this was five or six years ago this thread would have like 200 pages  

if this was Gaga, Beyonce, Taylor, or Rihanna.... the endless lashings

 

13 hours ago, Petty Bourgeoisie said:

If this was five or six years ago this thread would have like 200 pages  

The apathy is how you know her career is dead, tbh.

Not even her haters waste their time on her anymore I guess, this thread is dead 

Welp at fans being happy that she is hanging on to top 100 on week 2  

 

I don’t think her career will ever recover from this.