9 hours ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

Hilary / Ashley / Vanessa rate when?

still hoping for a miley / demi / selena rate one day each era at a time

That feels better suited for a singles rate

2005 Makes the Woman: Arular vs Confessions vs Emancipation vs Extraordinary Machine vs Robyn vs Speak for Yourself

5 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

2005 Makes the Woman: Arular vs Confessions vs Emancipation vs Extraordinary Machine vs Robyn vs Speak for Yourself

replace it with Supernature

3 minutes ago, California said:

replace it with Supernature

1. Goldfrapp is a duo

2. If anything is being dropped it's Robyn I fear

Just now, Eeveelution said:

1. Goldfrapp is a duo

and the duo has a woman

but yeah Robyn can go too

1 minute ago, California said:

and the duo has a woman

Ykw we needed Black Cherry in 2003 so sure

1 hour ago, Eeveelution said:

2005 Makes the Woman: Arular vs Confessions vs Emancipation vs Extraordinary Machine vs Robyn vs Speak for Yourself

Imogen's replaced with Mary, but, yes, that is the lineup! The three biggest albums by women (commercially) that year v. the three most acclaimed! [Leaving Some Hearts out of this...]

Part 2: Keyshia/Shakira/Imogen/Ashlee/Lil Kim/Missy. (You're welcome in advance!)

20 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Imogen's replaced with Mary, but, yes, that is the lineup! The three biggest albums by women (commercially) that year v. the three most acclaimed! [Leaving Some Hearts out of this...]

I can work with this

On 1/6/2026 at 9:07 AM, Ace Reject said:

Some Hearts

thank you, jesus (take the wheel)

On 1/4/2026 at 3:44 PM, Saddy said:

The winner is Houdini by Dua Lipa

Since we have bunch of rates happening rn, I will wait a lil before starting the one you wanted @Ace Reject (unless you want me to start it now)

And boy howdy is 2024 Makes The Woman going to be WEIRD now.

SZA (Lana tracks). St. Vincent. Clairo. Camila Cabello. Normani.

Don't know if I hate you all enough to make you listen to 143. Maybe a good old Kim Deal/Kim Gordon face-off instead?

Clairo

41 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Camila Cabello

The way you seem to really want us to rate Camila in some way

Idk if @MP2K's 2024 R&B rate is still happening but would 2024MTW be a good place to put Ravyn if not

7 minutes ago, conatus said:

The way you seem to really want us to rate Camila in some way

You know, she's never been rated. In any capacity!

Just now, Ace Reject said:

You know, she's never been rated. In any capacity!

9 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

You know, she's never been rated. In any capacity!

I wonder why

18 minutes ago, conatus said:

9 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

I wonder why

Yes, she is a buzz killer - but what other options do we have? And a lot of people at least liked that album...

BTW without spoiling Sup's upcoming rate, or @conatus your 2025 'dance' thing, or whoever does This WAS 2025 Part 2

2025 MAKES THE WOMAN:

Zara Larsson. Kesha. Jade. Rose Gray. Olivia Dean. Tate McRae.

Your lineup!

On 1/5/2026 at 1:35 PM, jacklovesyou1 said:

Hilary / Ashley / Vanessa rate when?

still hoping for a miley / demi / selena rate one day each era at a time

It's time for you to host a rate. Would LOVE for you to tackle It's Not That Deep/Something Beautiful/I Said I Love You First/brighter days ahead!

4 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

It's time for you to host a rate. Would LOVE for you to tackle It's Not That Deep/Something Beautiful/I Said I Love You First/brighter days ahead!

omg ace i am so down to do a rate but i'd need help with graphics but i'll do it

I'm honestly down to rate Camila on the grounds of having a fun punching bag, but then I fear certain users actually go up for her... and if I have to watch somebody try to big up CaCa while shitting on Normani, I might catch WPs.

WAIT @Ace Reject Scrap what i just said I am 10000000% down to do that rate fhweiohfoih inbox me when i can start etc

There's no overlap there so we're good! Just need a judgement call on whether we're opting for Eusexua or Afterglow for my dance/electronic rate, because I don't know if Eusexua is being saved for another rate/TW2025 Part 2.

(Black Star vs. The BPM vs. Lifetime vs. Through the Wall vs. whichever twigs album, just as a reminder)

3 minutes ago, conatus said:

There's no overlap there so we're good! Just need a judgement call on whether we're opting for Eusexua or Afterglow for my dance/electronic rate, because I don't know if Eusexua is being saved for another rate/TW2025 Part 2.

(Black Star vs. The BPM vs. Lifetime vs. Through the Wall vs. whichever twigs album, just as a reminder)

Plus Fancy That, right? Or are you snubbing that?