Doctor Dick

That's a bit of a stretch to claim the GP loves her when she literally doesn't chart with new music anymore.

I get what you're saying now but I still disagree. If she was still churning out hits with songs like "Your Body" she would've still been largely seen as a MPG. She would never truly be below MPG status.

The charts operated differently back then. In a modern landscape both "Jolene" and "I Will Always Love You" would've peaked higher, specifically after Whitney's version started topping the charts. Back then, old songs couldn't chart on the Hot 100 but in a modern landscape if Whitney debuted with IWALY today, Dolly's cover would've automatically re-peaked as well.

Once a MPG, always a MPG. Xtina has been a relevant, chart-topping MPG for a decade and then started flopping. I don't think she could've maintained relevancy even with Your Body because the pop landscape was changing and she was never going to catch up with five year breaks in between eras. She killed her own career. Who tf becomes a MPG and takes five years in between her next two eras. She scored a lot of teens that were suddenly twenty-somethings when she released her follow-up and five years for someone who is like 15 and then 20 is a massive gap and you don't just wait around at that age when music is constantly evolving.

I still don't get how some users are fuming at your threads. It's clear you're trolling and setting Xtina up.

Why does this sound like "unstan if they flop".

IKI, IKY being Top 20 on streaming yet not being Top 20 on any platform.

My bisexual king.

I've never heard of a song being N/A on every platform and BOMBING on streaming and yet go #1 on radio. Inorganic as most things about her. Embarrassing to stan. EDIT: Even AI agrees if you type in her name:

That's so sweet! Just make sure the audio quality is high so we can actually hear the difference between a generational vocalist who can command a stadium with a single microphone, and a marketing strategist who uses chart data to cover up a limited range. Quality over quantity, babe. Put 'Die With a Smile' at the top, one of the biggest smashes in music history and try making one for Taylor's organic global smash hits though that won't get past a Top 3, I'm afraid.

Miley had the way bigger cultural peak but none of her individual eras had three huge hits and sold as well as Sabrina's Short'n'Sweet era.

Oh Calvin. You're clearly upset about the well-deserved lashings. Stream a playlist on Amazon Music and calm down while a WP is heading your way.

The coping in here. Try stanning someone organically popular and maybe you'll have less users dragging you, Calvin. Oh I agree. Her dad literally said he was going to buy copies of her debut to get it to chart in that leaked email. And that's who raised this snake. I spoke to a Swiftie and they showed me their music collection and they had 8 copies of TLOAS on vinyl and another 10 on CD. Of that album. Taylor is probably the most fraudulent pop star to ever enter the music industry. You don't suddenly become massive after over years of being "just" big because people just organically start liking you more than others. Organic massive success comes rather quickly (Gaga, Adele, MJ, Whitney etc.). If it takes you 10 albums you know there's something smelly going on, especially since her father openly admitted in that email to trying to manipulate interest.

What an absolute legend! The world lost a huge talent, a woman who gave so much to people who needed it and a kind heart and soul. R.I.P.

I was telling you what the term Elevator Music means. It's like Muzak. Gaga's music doesn't really fit that as elevator music needs to be inoffensive and bland. I think Taylor's music is just that. Not because I dislike her (which I do), but because it fits those terms more than anyone on that list.