Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
New Music Out Now!!! 🎧💿

Cbreezy

ATRL Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Cbreezy

  1. Cbreezy replied to URBAN's topic in Base
    It's realizations like this that make Mani the most uniquely frustrating artist I have ever followed. Underperforming is by no means a new concept. I have stanned and presently stan a lot of unsung/underrated artists. But with Mani, it's like we've told ourselves at so many junctures that it can't actually be "this" bad. Even in our complaints, I get the sense we've all held on to a sliver of hope that there was either a grand plan in play or a savior scenario almost like we were passing through the trenches for a better day. Only to have these tentpole moments where you realize, in hindsight, that the real-time reality is and kinda always was way worse than we thought. To be THREE YEARS removed from an album that had the strangest rollout and consequently didn't do anything and still be in this meandering nothingness makes clear: it's not only been a bad situation, but it's also been worse than we have ever truly given it credit for in real time. The main saving grace, for better or worse, has been her silence. It keeps us hopeful and, dare I say, doesn't give the haters much to work with either way. The middle-ground reality is that no one is making noise about her one way or the other, which may actually be worse than our unending hope and the haters unfair drags. I say all that to say, I'm actually quite positive about what's to come. If only because I think it will give us the clarity we, as fans, deserve. If it's more of the same, then I imagine the already niche af base will simply move on. If it's game time and she lands another major label and goes all out, amazing. We're back in the saddle. If she goes the Tinashe, brick-by-brick route as an indie darling, then I'd be cool with that too. Random but related, I've always felt (and been frustrated by the reality that she doesn't clock that SHE is the sell regardless of budget. A Mani Single Ladies-like video would eat just as much as a big-budget Wild Side. I think she's been angling too much for the latter).
  2. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Ish lol. She announced a trilogy, but let's be fair: she never announced a named album, release date, or anything of the sort. To that point, many (even still now) question whether Act III is even an album. It, of course, is, but the point remains, I feel.
  3. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Don't drag me lol, but I'm actually surprised that some of y'all actually care about those 4K videos lol. It's like, outside of a cute refresh, I'm a bit stuck on what the actual excitement around them is about??? (Don't get me wrong, I also have the same OCD when it comes to ish, and it's kinda messy to announce something and then just go radio silent about it. But, at the same time, you'd think she literally announced a whole album and just went ghost on its release day with the fervency about the 4k videos). I know we don't have a ton talk about nor do we have a clue what's going on, but I'm genuinely more vested in the nuggets we can find about Act III and what's to come than pretend to be particularly engaged by that B'Day re-release which to me was nothing more than: a) a bandaid to cover a likely missed release window for Act III while she regroups and b) a vehicle to drop "new" song in Morning Dew in time for the Grammy cutoff. By design, it always felt a bit admin/nothingy to me.
  4. Not a fan of her Karen-ing of late, but this is actually a slay. She's a legacy act with great performance gravitas. She'll easily up the ante in terms of what the Sphere can do on the merit of her skill/stage show alone.
  5. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Fellow Chart Hive, this YouTube reversal (so now counts to charts again) benefits our girl, right?
  6. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Also... I really want her to pounce...now. I want her to use the Super Bowl to her benefit, but not in the obvious way some are anticipating/wanting from her. IMO, she should announce Act III later this month or in early December for a January release. Immediate preorders, variants, and all that jazz to benefit from the buying intensity of Q4/the holidays, while having the album itself land in the least competitive frame of the year. That way, heading into Halftime, the convo is more centered around which song from the album she'll perform or, if there is a new song with Jay, then it can be that for cross-beneficial promo. Rather than announcing a tour or album, it can be a Netflix commercial for Echoville advertised at Halftime. The Grammys are exactly a week before and I'm sure a Morning Dew nom/set of noms will get her out of the house for that, too. Essentially, I'd prefer her to execute on both sides of HT rather than us anticipating her using it as her era's definitive launchpad, which I'd still welcome but would be weird when Jay is the main artist this go-round. In short, use the heat of Halftime but execute...separately.
  7. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    I'm gonna sound like a**-kissing Hive (I'm not lol). But I think the main, and kinda only, misstep with the trilogy has been how deliberately vague she's been about how the albums are tied together. Like, to the GP, I don't get the sense they are even aware it's all part of an interconnected project. Scratch that, I KNOW that to be the case chatting with my casual/non-Hive friends offline. That combo of the release pacing being her usual 2-ish-year gap between projects and the albums themselves having totally different soundscapes ("Beyoncé's Dance album", "Beyoncé's Country album"), the GP legit aren't that aware. Even with the act 1, act 2 tagging. To them, it's "Oh, Beyoncé has a new album out." It's very simple, but lacking marketing choice, which makes me think it's deliberate - for whatever reason. Because, in all of her non-promo, all it takes is very simple lines in her IG captions. E.g., when closing the Rennie era with the tour, "I can't wait to take y'all on our next musical voyage" (hinting at CC), or when closing the CC/CCT era: "thank y'all for rocking with on this musical journey we're on. from Rennie, through CC,. See you at the next stop..." Of course, not as verbatim or corny as that, but...something lol. Note how none of that impedes her penchant for surprise. It's just establishing a narrative throughline. On the upside, I really do believe she will tie it all together with Echoville, so - at a macro level - none of our worries will even matter when all is said and done. In all truth, the public has increasingly limited attention spans anyway and, a part of me, thinks it's smart to be kinda vague about her ish to give herself room to manoeuvre and pivot with everything from re-scheduling to re-recording to re-filming. When she finally has all her ish locked and loaded, swooping down with an "unprecedented" visual that was made over "six years", "soundtracking her trilogy of #1 albums" in a way "never seen before" is exactly the type of thing that aligns with her playbook. The tying together will be retroactive, and it will all be presented as her "grand plan" all along (even if we know it wasn't), It's hella annoying, but it will work.
  8. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    LMAO! I don't endorse a lot of her antics and do feel it doesn't hurt for her to play ball a bit more, but I do think there is a method to the madness.
  9. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Unpopular opinion. I have never been all that fussed about her NOT releasing ish like FWT. Maybe it's the privilege of going, or maybe the fact that the superior Homecoming is widely avail, or maybe just being used to her antics, but it's never that deep. I've always been directionally more excited about what she's going to do next, about to drop next, etc. Not kiss-ass Hive at all (because I think she can be annoying af with this, and we as fans aren't fed as fully as we can be). But I do think there is a bigger picture. Even if it wasn't her grand plan. Legacy and library. By that, I mean, there always comes a time when it's beneficial and very lucrative for artists/their estates to open the vault. Look at MJ, Prince, and even some of our legends still with us like Mariah, who are nailing the anniversary rollouts. Put simply, you empty the clip now; what's left is there to show or "finally drop" later for the diehards? I also think that there is something very key a lot of fans miss in the desire for "more, more, more." If Bey put up every tour special on streaming, there is a compounding effect I don't think most clock. Not only does it normalize (and thus de-premium-ize) her accessibility, it actually exposes the fact that Bey - like all artists - has a tried and true repertoire. A core stage show or approach to performance that doesn't actually change that much. Imagine sitting at home and watching all her tours back to back; it'll soon become apparent that, for example, xyz song has very similar performances or she's not as vigorous with the choreo anymore (as we've discussed ad nauseam), or Rennie and CCT are more similar in setup and format than I remember at the shows. I also, again, think it inadvertently normalizes her presence in a way that dents her "stop everything you're doing and get my tickets" status that she enjoys today. In this economy, had she dropped FWT on streaming, or RWT on Netflix, you might see people opt to watch those at home for free than run to buy tickets. I LEGIT think she gets this to the max. So the MO now is: come and see me at premium cost, as it may be the only time you'll be able to experience this era. In reality, I imagine she'll open up the vault some much later down the line for the diehards. But more than anything, when it benefits her hustle the most. It's annoying, but it is smart.
  10. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    I like that we can have candid convos about this. Our girl is an absolute force, but she is also human, and she no doubt goes through all the ish that the rest of us do. And yes, it definitely looks like her spark is sparking more than it has in a while. And it's not just a weight thing (though - if this is a safe space - I do think that factors into things). Note how she was tiny at the start of RWT, but deffo seemed a bit nervous/getting back into the groove of things. THIS Bey, though, I'm very intrigued to see in action. Is she about to toss that Fatima Robinson "no need to do so much on stage" BS in the trash (where it belongs lol) or continue to strategically scale back, but just looking even fiercer while doing it? We'll see.
  11. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    I remember this and totally want her to dive back into that space again solo. Knowing her, it's the soundscape for whatever she has after Act III - and I want it real bad! It's hard because it'll invite the usual brand of hate that arguably sank The Gift, but I think with the "mainline Beyonce album" treatment and a promotional throughline that isn't confusing, it would do significantly better. It can essentially be the Afrobeats/Fela Kuti-inspired album she was initially readying with 4.
  12. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    A big part of why I want her to finish this trilogy neatly (both from an album and tour perspective) is because I legit feel she'll be free to get real edgy/diverse with her moves after the fact. She's one of the biggest touring draws and need not be tethered to new music or a full album cycle to hit the road. So, I fully would love to see her explore all the things. I've BEEN wanted for her that ish Taylor was trying to do before the pandemic hit. The whole LoverFest East / LoverFest West setup. Effectively one huge self-mounted festival, with one show on the East Coast and one on the West. Select international. Spot festivals like Copa as and when. And Vegas if she feels to. In an ideal world, she would mount stuff like these for her side projects as a way to extract the most $$$ avail from her activities without being married to them for long stretches. Like, imagine any of the above for The Gift if a full-fledged tour wasn't an option? Or the LoverFest example for CC instead of a tour? Like, I thought she was really going that route with the whole traveling Rodeo concept with the acts featured on the album. Would have been perfect and hella creative (despite how much I still enjoyed the CCT).
  13. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Ohhhh....I was confused for a sec lol. Ps. Still don't see Copa/Super Bowl crossover for reasons unpacked already lol. But would like to see her do both. If we can get to the visuals soon-ish, I wouldn't be mad at a Copa Homecoming-esque doc/concert film later next year. Especially if it's another case of album in 2027 and a tour in 2028. Copa as both a performance and standalone special would work as perfect promo for a follow-up Act III tour.
  14. Yes, but no. IMO, certain acts set the level high (MJ as the genesis, and later Bey, Madonna, Gaga, Shakira & J.Lo). The problem is that there is simply no longer a wide pool of artists that can reasonably meet the moment in the same way. And I blame that on the wider shapeshift/collapse of the music industry that now favors relatability and viralness over outright skill. So, it leaves us in this weird spot where the platform has the justified legacy it has, given the magical moments it has played host to in the past. But the present-day names tasked with creating more moments make for slim pickings. Add the layer of politics and supposed need for "fairness" (aka some years have to be x gender, some years have to be x genre) and it just makes it more of a roll of the dice as to whether it will be any good. I guess what I'm saying in so many words is that what used to be a near guarantee of an epic show has become very unpredictable.
  15. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Friend, I'm confused. You want ALL of that in a Bey segment within a Jay Halftime? I'm not a Jay stan, but I think you may be underrating him/his catalog. In a 13-ish minute performance, we'd be lucky to get a solid 3mins of Bey. And even then, I could see them having her pop out at separate points for both pacing and to maxmize her visibility/participation. And even still, her total screen time would be lucky to be 4mins. Jay has a catalog and also an arsenal of other collaborators. The US-based, US-serving Super Bowl is highly unlikely to be used as a vehicle to promote a festival...in Brazil lol. At best, the hope would be that she's paired up with a streamer (Netflix, Prime etc) for a livestreamed special of the show. THEN, it becomes kinda feasible for them to buy one of those coveted ad slots as Halftime for some kind of cross promo/visibility play (like Verizon). But that's still a stretch.
  16. Kanye is not touching that stage. Not sure where you've been but he came for Jay and his family. Not to mention his own public fall from grace and favor. Again, he's not touching that stage. When it comes to Bey, the songs you mentioned are all plausible, but Donk is not happening at Halftime lmao. A seconds-long instrumental interpolation at best. But even that feels like nah. The Bey Factor is an interesting one. They could go for the obvious like Crazy in Love (which makes the most sense for the audience, platform, and is, dare I say, brand-safe). But she's already performed it at hers. And, if you count the lil audio sprinkle of it she did with Bruno/Coldplay, she's actually done it twice. So, there are clear openings for other songs: Drunk in Love, Upgrade U, Bonnie & Clyde. Will they make for comparably big "moments" to Crazy? Maybe Drunk in Love, but iono. We'll see.
  17. Finally. The delay in the announcement was puzzling. I actually think he missed a pretty unique opportunity to run that commercial at the end of his last LA show...which was at the very stadium he will be doing Halftime at. Anyway, I actually think ATRL are the ones who will be in for a rude awakening, as there just won't be the furore y'all think there will be over this. Most of the "he picked himself" spiel has come and gone with the initial leak. In the end, I think there will be one of two scenarios: 1) He aces it and brings out ALL the guests. Beyonce, Rihanna, Nas, Linkin Park, Alicia Keys, Pharrell. OR 2) He does it largely alone and has one of those "neither here nor there" Halftimes that a lot male acts have. I think his catalog is big enough for it to not outright suck, but if he overthinks the whole "let me overly spotlight MY legacy sans any guests" then it could be a slight snoozer. Whatever the case, the faux-outrage is a kii down. It's a done deal, it'll most likely give us some great pop culture moments. Ps. Call me Ms. Cleo, because I KNEW the spin would be "we asked him. We always wanted him" thing and that's exactly what the NFL press release says. It effectively neutralizes the "he picked himself" argument.
  18. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    When it comes to Copacoyonce, I wish and will it for her and us. My only thing is that, in the grand scheme of things, it's kind of a stan service more than some promotional must. Also, rather crucial: Beyonce is a Western world act. US/North America will always be her main base, followed by the UK, Europe, etc. So, unless she strikes up a deal for a huge global streaming event, there's no real commercial benefit or need to use US promotional slots to promote an international show in Brazil lol. Now, this is Beyonce and her whole schtick has been: doing what hasn't been done before. So, I would not be averse to her making a commercial moment out of it. Be that via a Homecoming-like concert film or even a livestream ala Xmas Halftime. But with us still being visual-less so far and mid-trilogy, I don't know if another filmed "special" even fits into the mix right now. But you, equally, may be onto something. Use the international heat from that to benefit whatever her touring plans are on home soil. We'll see.
  19. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Glad the Jay-Z ish is official. The delay was getting puzzling. A few thoughts. Assuming we are still Act III-ing and there is no OTIII or EIL2, I think the smartest way for Bey to give her man the spotlight while benefiting from the platform is to simply...announce her ish before Halftime! Between now and Jan, she ought to announce and/or release Act III. Going into Halftime, it then makes the expectation: oh, is Bey coming to perform XYZ song rather than "omg is she (using her man's show) to announce her album/or tour". She pops out and performs...whatever. A classique, a new song, whatever. It gives us an in-era "moment" while not overshadowing his moment. FYI, my interest is 200% vested in Bey, so this isn't a "give her man his shine" thing. It's more just optics and, even in them being a power couple, recognizing that navigating their individual and joint brands still requires a bit of foresight and tactfulness. Also...
  20. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    I see what you mean. But I push back a bit on the B"Day thing. Comparable to Act III, it's a relatively low-lift, low-risk expedition. IMO, if anything, beyond the main celebratory element, it was a litmus test to see if there'd be any blowback on the Dream element. Basically, establishing the commercial feasibility of working with him. And while there was no outcry, I still don't think it's coast clear. Bey is in a unique predicament in that she is relatively scandal-free. So, IMO, there has long been a bloodlust to take her down. Something she makes extremely hard by keeping her hands clean. I already noticed how much her name LEAD press titles when his case got filed, e.g., "Beyonce Producer The-Dream". So, it's not far-fetched for her to drop the lead for Act III produced by him and the media "deciding" in that moment to have an issue with it. We've literally seen how the "outcry" over who works with Dr. Luke is hella selective. Doja stays having his name attached to her credits with no blowback; Katy Perry, by contrast, got cooked. It's like the masses know it's hella contradictory, but will never play the one rule for all game. Instead, it's: if we like you, we'll turn a blind eye; if we want your blood, then we will play the faux-shock and dismay game at the loudest volume to sink the release. If I, with ample distance from her operation, can see this from afar, I don't think it's far-fetched for them to be thinking about this at an equally granular level. Bey may be loyal, but she should absolutely be most loyal to her own brand and career. Something I think, in her closeness to The-Dream, is a necessity for her that even he gets.
  21. For me, it's less that I don't think there's demand. I more so question the group's collective desire to do it. There's a world where I could see the likes of Molly, Frankie, and Una being up for it, but the rebrands of Rochelle and Vanessa don't feel as organically aligned with what the group gives. Make no mistake, they aren't "above it," but it's more an individual brand positioning thing and whether the $ would be worth compromising that.
  22. I cannot believe the Halftime headliner has still not been announced. It's almost always a September reveal and, in the Roc Nation years, has been exactly that every year sans The Weeknd (November). A part of me was sold on it being Jay, with the announcement naturally coming after his last show. But that has now come and gone, and still... crickets. It may well still be the case, and we're still within the frame where it could be announced imminently as a victory lap post his shows. But I'm now starting to wonder if it's someone else and this is either a) a deliberate bait-and-switch or b) just bad intel that was never true in the first place. We'll see.
  23. Larger than life! Interesting thread, as I have been having this debate for ions offline. I like my superstars to always have that "super" element. Be that a "super" vocal, "super" choreo, or "super charisma". Or ideally all of the above! It clearly was how things once were. Superstars were effectively our real-life superheroes, not because they were superhuman, but because their celebrity status was attached to their super ability. I TOTALLY get today's value attachment to relatability. It's definitely commodifiable and makes sense in a post-social media world. But I only care for it when it's paired with skill. Take Cardi B, for example. She's the definition of relatable, and it's a huge part of why she's such a big name. At the same time, she has an undeniable ability to turn her "star" on when it comes to performing, charisma, and being the larger-than-life character on stage. The problem with others is that we have an endless list of names who are relatable, but don't have star power. So, at best, they enjoy moments of virality/success, but it rarely translates to ubiquitous praise or popularity because there is not much to work with, nor any legitimate wow factor. Or, we have others, huge names even, who overindex in relatability/girl-next-doorness, but are so lacking in every conventional superstar metric that it, again, will never ever let them be universally praised or adored outside of their cult-like base (which is admittedly huge) because of it. In short lol, being larger than life will always be my pick and 200% justifies a superstar being a superstar. I DGAF about relatability if the core output is compelling.
  24. Agreed. They are absolutely tethered to a particular time and have somewhat of a so-bad-they're-good thing to them lol. Though they have some undeniably timeless bangers, and some of the individual members are extremely talented, even if the group wasn't the best hub for them to shine to their fullest ability (see: Vanessa, Rochelle especially). Because it was such a clusterf*ck of an operation at its height, a comeback (even if just for the nostalgia tour bag) would only work if the kitsch, 00s shamelessness of it all was something they leaned into wholeheartedly. Yet, with several of the members having rebranded as cooler, chic-er, etc in their individual journeys (again Rochelle and, to an extent, Vanessa with her solo attempt), it would be kinda weird going back to their messy formations, offbeat choreo, and all-around cheesiness. Rochelle would 200% Mylene Klass them (see: no thanks, but well-wishes), and they'd need Vanessa not to do the same as it literally doesn't work without at least one of them lol.
  25. Cbreezy replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    I think so, too. A few thoughts. This is the reason I will never moan too much about her keeping her cards close to her chest. Imagine she had laid out her plans for the trilogy at the point of Rennie (like many of the Hive demanded at the time); the amount of pivots BTS would make the frontend look a mess, too. From lapsed date frames, missed video launches, etc. It undoubtedly makes for a frustrating experience as a fan, but at the very least, she is keeping up the veneer of it looking like she's executing some grand plan on her own terms, when I can imagine the BTS is a very different story. The amount of vaulted material this woman must have will make her latter career and sunset years fascinating if ever they decide to open up the vault. We already know she makes tons of songs per project, but to think there are likely full-fledged projects unreleased is equal parts frustrating and exciting. Like the first iteration of 4, which was supposedly a Fela Kuti-inspired Afrobeats album (hence End of Time and RTW) and now a potential Rock album that may be subbed out for another Rock album for reasons discussed. Assuming for a sec that the reason for the possible reworking is true, should the Dream stuff blow over (and he's proven innocent), she automatically has material ready to roll for a deluxe. She probably won't (because she's not made that play with the other two acts), but it's, at the very least, an option.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.